TR

Share Purchase Deception: One-Year Limit in a Turkish Appeal Ruling

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 16 November 2026

Share Purchase Deception: One-Year Limit in a Turkish Appeal Ruling

If company shares that changed hands for about 2.4 million US dollars three days earlier are sold to an investor living abroad for 6 million US dollars, can the investor claim the difference years later as tort compensation? Or are the pre-contract steers assessed under the rules on "deception", which are tied to the contract itself and subject to a short time limit? In a damages case brought by a foreign investor, the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal answered this question through the one-year forfeiture period in Article 39 of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK).

In its decision dated 06.11.2025, Docket No. E.2025/1438, Decision No. K.2025/1740, the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal dismissed on the merits the claimant's appeal against the ruling of the Istanbul 15th Commercial Court of First Instance, which had rejected the case because the forfeiture period had expired. The decision is open to appeal on points of law.

In short: A foreign claimant who wanted to invest in real estate in Türkiye alleged that, instead of buying the commercial units of a housing complex directly, he was steered into buying the shares of the limited company that owned those units. The shares were transferred to him under contracts dated 29.05.2015. He states that he later learned through an independent audit review that the shares had been bought three days before the transfer by the defendant and another person for a much lower price, and he claimed partial compensation of TRY 100,000.00 under the tort rules. The court of first instance characterised the claim as a defect of consent and rejected it because the one-year period in TBK Article 39 had passed; the Regional Court of Appeal upheld this result.

🔁 Three times the price in three days: the alleged chain of share transfers

According to the petition, the claimant is a Saudi-born businessman who invests in real estate and commercial business-centre projects. When he wanted to invest in Türkiye he met one of the defendants. In 2015, while considering buying the commercial units of a housing complex in Esenyurt, he was steered towards buying the shares of a limited company whose assets consisted of those units, rather than buying the units directly.

According to the claimant's account, the process ran as follows:

  • The company's previous shareholders were companies established in the United Kingdom.
  • The shares were first transferred to the defendant and another person, who has since died, and three days later were sold to the claimant under share transfer agreements and protocols dated 29.05.2015.
  • In the appeal petition it is alleged that the first transfer was made on 26.05.2015 for USD 2,426,441.28, while the transfer to the claimant was made for USD 6,000,000.
  • The general assembly resolution on the share transfer is dated 01.06.2015 and was published in the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette on 09.06.2015.
  • The claimant, who lives abroad, appointed one of the defendants as the company's fully authorised manager.

The claimant states that after problems arose he had the company's records reviewed by an independent audit firm, and that through this review he learned that the shares had been bought three days before their transfer to him for a much lower price. On 19.12.2022 he applied to the Küçükçekmece Chief Public Prosecutor's Office alleging breach of trust, qualified fraud and forgery of a private document, and reports that an indictment was prepared against one of the defendants. He based the case on TBK Article 49 and, for now, claimed TRY 100,000.00.

🧾 The defendant's defence

The defendant whose case is examined on appeal argued that the claimant had not proved any fraudulent conduct and that the burden of proof lay with the claimant. The main points of the defence are these:

  1. On 29.05.2015 the defendant was not a manager or authorised person in the company.
  2. A case based on a share transfer must be filed within a one-year forfeiture period; the same period applies to a claim of excessive benefit.
  3. The defendant stated that the shares were transferred after lengthy negotiations, not within a few days, and that a valuation report had been prepared shortly before the sale.

⚖️ How the court of first instance characterised the claim

The Istanbul 15th Commercial Court of First Instance (2024/720 E., 2025/306 K., 15.04.2025) did not stay bound by the label in the petition. Starting from the principle that "describing the facts is for the parties, the legal characterisation is for the judge", it held that the allegation of an excessive price should be assessed under the situations that impair consent (mistake, deception, duress) or under excessive benefit.

The court relied on the one-year and five-year periods in TBK Article 28, which regulates excessive benefit, and on the one-year period in TBK Article 39 for mistake, deception and duress; it also found that the name of the defendant in the appeal did not appear in the complaint petition. As a result it rejected the case against this defendant because the forfeiture period had expired. The case against the other defendant was separated, registered under Docket No. 2025/271, and a decision of lack of jurisdiction was issued on the ground that the civil court of general jurisdiction is competent. The appeal review of that separated case is being conducted by the same Chamber under Docket No. 2025/1439; the decision examined here concerns only the defendant who was a company partner.

📨 The grounds of appeal and the Chamber's answer

On appeal, the claimant's lawyer argued that the case arose from a tort of a commercial nature and that, although the name was mistakenly omitted from the complaint petition, this defendant had also been complained about. He stated that a decision of non-prosecution was issued for this defendant on 04.07.2024, that the objection was rejected, and that an application was made to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Cassation regarding the final decision. According to the claimant, the longer criminal limitation period should apply under TBK Article 72, and for this it is not necessary that a criminal case has been filed or a conviction given against the perpetrator.

The Chamber did not find these grounds well-founded. The main findings in the reasoning are as follows:

  • According to the petition, all the alleged torts were committed in order to have the share transfer agreement of 29.05.2015 signed; no separate act after the transfer that harmed the claimant or the company is described.
  • Once the contract has been formed, the effect of the pre-contract acts on the contract and its validity must be assessed. For this reason the provisions on excessive benefit, mistake, deception and duress in TBK Article 28 and the following articles, together with the periods attached to them, apply.
  • Beyond this point TBK Article 72, which regulates the limitation period for torts, cannot be applied; so there is no need to investigate whether the act constitutes a crime or whether the longer criminal limitation period applies.
  • After learning of the situation through the independent audit report, the claimant did not notify that he was not bound by the contract, or file a case, within the period determined by adding the mediation period; in that situation he is deemed to have ratified the contract as regards the price.

Finding no procedural defect and no violation of law or public order in the first-instance decision, the Chamber dismissed the appeal on the merits under Article 353/1-b-1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) and left the appeal costs on the claimant. The decision was given unanimously on 06.11.2025, and an appeal on points of law remains open within two weeks of notification.

📎 Text of the decision: The decision of the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal was obtained through Bedesten (mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr) and checked by docket and decision number in the Court of Cassation decision search system; party names are anonymised in the source, and one personal name and a website name remaining in the text have been removed.

🧩 Tort or defect of consent?

The decision turns on characterisation. The injured party relies on tort because of the time limit: under TBK Article 72, a claim for compensation is in principle time-barred two years after the loss and the person liable become known, and in any case ten years after the act; however, if the compensation arises from an act for which criminal law provides a longer limitation period, that period applies.

The Chamber, however, emphasised that in this case the tort allegation did not produce any loss independent of the contract: all the alleged steering and persuasion served a single outcome, namely concluding the share transfer agreement at a high price. From this viewpoint the loss is the price agreed in the contract itself, so the fate of the contract is also determined under the TBK provisions on defects of consent.

Under TBK Article 36, if one party concluded the contract because the other deceived him, he is not bound by the contract even if his mistake is not essential; where the deception comes from a third person, it is required that the other party knew or should have known of the deception. The first paragraph of TBK Article 39 provides that if the deceived party does not notify that he is not bound by the contract, or does not claim back what he has given, within one year from the moment he learned of the deception, he is deemed to have ratified the contract. The Chamber expressly characterised this period as a forfeiture period.

The second paragraph of the same article also provides that the ratification of a contract that is not binding because of deception or duress does not remove the right to compensation. The reasoning of the appeal decision examined here contains no separate assessment of this paragraph; the Chamber reached the conclusion that a claimant who has ratified the contract cannot, after the forfeiture period has passed, claim a loss arising from the contract. Because the decision was given with the appeal on points of law open, it cannot be understood from the text whether this approach has passed Court of Cassation review as of the date of publication.

For an appeal decision in which a similar share transfer was discussed from the angle of disproportion between the parties' performances, see the article on the claim of excessive benefit in a share transferTR; for a decision in which the criminal limitation period was addressed in a different context for money handed over against a promise of returns, see the article on a bank employee's promise of returnsTR.

⏳ How the time limit ran, and mediation

The dates in the decision matter because they show how the period was assessed:

  • Share transfer agreements: 29.05.2015
  • Criminal complaint: 19.12.2022
  • Mandatory mediation application: 03.10.2024; final minutes: 06.11.2024
  • Date of the case: 22.11.2024

The claimant argued that he learned of the excessive price through the independent audit report and filed the criminal complaint on that basis. The Chamber accepted that the one-year period began to run with this discovery, and stated that even if the mediation period is added, the claimant did not give notice or file a case within the period. The decision does not separately show the date of the independent audit report.

As for the criminal investigation, the Chamber stated that since TBK Article 72 would not be applied there was no need for this inquiry, and so left the discussion outside the time-limit provision.

💬 Frequently Asked Questions

Why was the case examined only with respect to one defendant?

The court of first instance separated the case against the other defendant, who was later appointed as manager of the company, and issued a decision of lack of jurisdiction in that case on the ground that the civil court of general jurisdiction is competent. Because the appeal review of that decision is being conducted under a separate docket number of the same Chamber, the decision examined here concerns only the defendant who was a company partner.

Why did the Chamber change the label of the case?

Under Article 33 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK), the judge applies Turkish law ex officio; explaining the facts is for the parties, while determining the legal rule applicable to them is for the judge. Seeing that the account in the petition rested entirely on pre-contract steering and an excessive price, the Chamber assessed the dispute within the framework of defects of consent.

Did the decision of non-prosecution affect the outcome?

In the appeal petition the claimant stated that a decision of non-prosecution was issued for the defendant on 04.07.2024 and that an application was made to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Cassation for this decision to be set aside. Because the Chamber saw no need to investigate whether the act constitutes a crime, the result of that investigation was not decisive in the reasoning of the appeal decision.

Has the decision become final?

Under HMK Article 361, the decision was given with an appeal on points of law open within two weeks of notification of the reasoned decision. Whether it was appealed and the outcome of any Court of Cassation review do not appear in the published text.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page, and other decisions are in the Precedent DecisionsTR archive.

The information in this article may not be up to date and is provided for general information only; the content is compiled from the appeal decision of the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, published through Bedesten and checked in the Court of Cassation decision search system. The decision was given with an appeal on points of law open, and a different result may be reached on Court of Cassation review. Statements of fact rest on the claims and defences of the parties and the findings of the court of first instance. Cases that differ in the nature of the pre-contract acts, the date of discovery and the routes taken may reach different results. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Pay Alımında Aldatma Süresi – İst. BAM 14. HD 2025/1740.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp