Cloned Investment Site Access Ban Denied: Istanbul 2025/788

One of the most common methods in investment fraud is setting up websites that imitate the name, logo and corporate language of a genuine, licensed institution. The harm from these sites does not stop with the investor; the institution whose name is used also suffers reputational damage. So can the company whose name is used have these sites shut down quickly, before filing a lawsuit? The case examined by the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber, shows that the answer depends largely on how the application is built.
By its decision of 15 May 2025, Docket No. E.2025/589, Decision No. K.2025/788, the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber unanimously and finally dismissed on the merits the appeal against the first instance decision rejecting a request for content removal and an access ban against three websites using the name and logo of a portfolio management company subject to Capital Markets Board regulations.
- Three sites, a fake analyst and a WhatsApp group
- The reasoning of the intellectual and industrial property rights court for rejection
- The jurisdiction argument raised on appeal
- Regional Court of Appeal: prima facie proof and the counterparty
- What was in the case and what was missing?
- What the decision means for investors and institutions
- Frequently Asked Questions
🌐 Three sites, a fake analyst and a WhatsApp group
The applicant is a portfolio management company that manages investment funds subject to Capital Markets Board regulations and serves individual and institutional investors. According to the company's account, the following picture was identified on three separate websites with which it has no legal, commercial or corporate connection:
- The company's title, brand and logo were used on the sites without permission, giving visitors the impression that the sites belonged to the company.
- A person was presented as an employee and "chief analyst" of the company and shown as if giving seminars within the company.
- In the "Press Contact" section of the sites there was a fake e-mail address containing this person's name.
- The company's title and logo were used in videos and images on the sites.
- Site users were added to a WhatsApp group called "... Ticaret" (... Trade), where misleading information about the company and its activities was given.
- It was claimed that the sites operated for fraud and personal data collection, and that some people acted on the basis of these sites and suffered losses.
The company stated that many people who saw the information in the WhatsApp groups began to call and e-mail it, that even its own customers contacted it to receive this "training", and that its customer portfolio and commercial reputation would suffer if no access ban was issued. For this reason, through a miscellaneous case file opened before any lawsuit, it requested a precautionary measure for the content on the sites to be taken down and, on the ground that content removal would be insufficient, for access to the sites to be blocked.
⚖️ The reasoning of the intellectual and industrial property rights court for rejection
The request was made to the Istanbul 3rd Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights Civil Court. By its decision of 13 March 2025, No. 2025/43 Misc. (D.İş), Decision No. 2025/46 K., the court rejected the request. The backbone of the reasoning is as follows:
- The request was based on the relevant provisions of the Turkish Civil Code, that is, on a violation of commercial reputation and personality rights.
- Given the way the claim was put forward, the state of the evidence and the posts, no use as a trademark or in trade within the meaning described in Articles 7 and 29 of the Industrial Property Code (SMK) was established.
- Article 159/1 of the SMK, which defines the court's jurisdiction for precautionary measures, makes a measure available only where the use in question amounts to an infringement of the requesting party's industrial property right.
- Whether the company's commercial reputation was damaged and whether the content was used without permission falls outside the protective scope of the SMK.
📨 The jurisdiction argument raised on appeal
In the appeal petition, the company's lawyer repeated the details of the events and put forward a noteworthy procedural argument. By the Constitutional Court's decision of 11 October 2023, Merits No. 2020/76 and Decision No. 2023/172, Article 9 of Law No. 5651, which regulated content removal and access ban applications to the criminal judgeship of peace on the ground of violation of personality rights, was annulled. According to the lawyer, in view of this annulment the civil courts for intellectual and industrial property rights have jurisdiction over content removal and access ban requests.
This argument points to the question of which court to apply to once the route through the criminal judgeship of peace is closed. However, the Regional Court of Appeal did not separately resolve this jurisdiction debate; it based the rejection on two other grounds.
🔍 Regional Court of Appeal: prima facie proof and the counterparty
The Chamber first set out the framework to be applied. Under Article 159 of the SMK, persons entitled to bring an action under this Law may request a precautionary measure provided they prove that the use takes place within the country in a way that infringes their industrial property rights, or that serious and effective preparations have been made for it. Where the Law is silent, the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) applies; Article 389 of the HMK allows a measure where there is concern that a change in the current situation would make it significantly harder to obtain the right, or that a delay would cause serious harm. Article 390/3 of the HMK also requires the party requesting the measure to prove prima facie that it is justified on the merits of the case.
Within this framework the Chamber found two deficiencies decisive:
- No evidence of ownership of the right: The company submitted three notarial record reports dated 18 February 2025 and WhatsApp correspondence as evidence; however, it submitted no evidence showing that it holds the right to the trademark and logo. No evidence preservation or expert examination was requested either. For this reason the conditions of prima facie proof under Article 159 of the SMK and Article 389 of the HMK were not met.
- The counterparty of the measure was not shown: The request did not state the natural or legal person against whom the measure would be directed. According to the Chamber, for a measure to be requested, the person against whom it would be applied must be named in the petition; if this person cannot be identified, the procedural steps needed to identify them (such as an expert examination or inquiries to the relevant institutions) must be indicated.
On these two grounds the Chamber found the first instance court's rejection consistent with the contents of the case and dismissed the appeal on the merits under Article 353/1-b-1 of the HMK. The decision was given as final under Articles 362/1-f and 394/5 of the HMK.
🧾 What was in the case and what was missing?
The decision is also valuable because it states clearly which documents were not regarded as sufficient. Comparing the elements that were in the case with those that were not, the picture is as follows:
- In the case: Notarial record reports for the three sites; correspondence from a phone number in the name of the fake analyst; correspondence in the WhatsApp group called "... Ticaret" (... Trade).
- Not in the case: A document showing the right to the trademark and logo; a request for evidence preservation; a request for an expert examination; the identity of the person against whom the measure would be directed, or a procedural proposal for identifying this person.
A notarial record is an important tool for documenting what was published on the sites; however, in this decision it was not regarded as sufficient on its own. From the court's point of view, the problem is less the existence of the sites than the fact that the right the applicant wanted protected, and the person against whom the measure would be applied, remained unclear. In a similar way, how the prima facie proof standard was applied in another capital markets dispute can also be seen in the decision on a precautionary measure on shares held under a fiduciary transferTR.
🛡️ What the decision means for investors and institutions
The outcome of the decision does not mean that the sites are lawful. The Chamber did not discuss whether the content on the sites was genuine or whether it had a fraudulent purpose; it determined only that this application, built in this way and with this evidence, did not meet the conditions for a precautionary measure. This distinction matters in two respects:
- For the institution: The basis of an application against clone sites (trademark right or personality right), the competent court and the counterparty of the measure are independent problems. In the decision, the first instance court interpreted the scope of the SMK narrowly, while the Regional Court of Appeal focused on the lack of proof and of a counterparty. The question of jurisdiction was left unanswered.
- For the investor: A site carrying the logo of a licensed institution, or an "analyst" being presented as that institution's employee, does not show that the site belongs to that institution. In this case the company itself stated that it had no connection with the sites and that even its own customers were misled.
The administrative side of access bans is a separate route. On the judicial review of Capital Markets Board access ban decisions against unauthorised sites, the decision on an access ban on a forex site whose Turkish language option was removed complements this article; for the place in criminal proceedings of an access ban issued because of trademark infringement, see the decision on an access ban for trademark infringementTR.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Did the Regional Court of Appeal decide that the sites were not fraudulent?
If the counterparty of the measure is unknown, can the request not be made at all?
Did the Constitutional Court's annulment of Article 9 of Law No. 5651 change the outcome?
Can this decision be appealed to the Court of Cassation?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page; other recent decisions on investment disputes are on the Precedent DecisionsTR page.
This article is for general information only; its content has been compiled from the appeal decision of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber, published through Bedesten (mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr). In the text of the decision, the company's title, the domain names of the websites, and the name and phone number of the person presented as the fake analyst have been anonymised. The decision concerns a request for a precautionary measure; the lawfulness of the content on the sites and any possible compensation or criminal proceedings are outside the scope of this article. In a dispute that appears similar, the outcome may differ depending on the legal basis of the application, the evidence submitted, whether the counterparty of the measure can be identified, and the competent court. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made on the basis of this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Klon Sitede Erişim Engeli Tedbiri – İst. BAM 44. HD 2025/788.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Share Purchase Deception: One-Year Limit in a Turkish Appeal Ruling
- Court Resists Cassation Reversal on Limitation, Ankara 2026/1327
- Forex 'Licensed Guarantee' Ad Fined: Council of State 2023/4732
- 1:400 Forex Leverage Claim: Court of Cassation 2024/9133
- Bank Pledge over Client Shares: Court of Cassation 2024/2923
- Forex Spread Fine Upheld: Council of State 2024/5786