Crypto Gains and Legality in Tax: Council of State 2024/7487

Can the gains from buying and selling Bitcoin and similar crypto assets be taxed? This question has been debated for years between the tax administration and taxpayers. In some cases tax inspectors treated crypto assets as "digital commodities" and tried to tax trading gains as commercial income; taxpayers argued that the Income Tax Law contains no provision on crypto assets. In an assessment file for the year 2015, the Third Chamber of the Council of State approached this debate through the principle of legality in taxation.
By its decision of 24.12.2024, Docket No. (E.) 2022/2868, Decision No. (K.) 2024/7487, the 3rd Chamber of the Council of State rejected the tax administration's appeal against the decisions cancelling a tax assessment with penalty on gains accepted to derive from crypto currency trading, and upheld the part of the judgment cancelling the special irregularity penalty. The decision was given by majority and is final.
🔎 What Did the Tax Inspection Report Say?
According to the text of the decision, the tax inspection report prepared on the plaintiff found that the commercial income earned from e-commerce advertising activity, from a management role on a platform and from crypto currency trading had been left outside the records and the tax return. On the basis of the report, income tax with a tax loss penalty of one times the tax was assessed ex officio for 2015, and a special irregularity penalty was also imposed under paragraph 1 of Article 353 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
The report's approach to crypto currencies was summarised as follows: crypto currencies are not movable or immovable property, intangible rights or physical commodities as defined in the current legal system; the most suitable solution is to regard them as a special kind of digital asset or investment instrument. For tax law purposes they are not money but a virtual product that is bought and sold; Bitcoin should therefore be interpreted as a "digital commodity", and the gains arising from these activities should be taxed as commercial income or corporate income.
The tax court noted that, although the report did not say so expressly, this assessment was largely taken from a peer-reviewed academic article, that there are different views on the subject and that there is no settled practice.
🧾 The Tax Court's Distinction
The tax court did not treat the assessment as a whole but separated the income items:
- Advertising activity: The plaintiff was accepted to have bought accounts and viewing services, commissioned animations and rented virtual servers, that is, to have carried out a capital-intensive activity within a commercial organisation; the assessment on the tax base of TL 1,004,219.86 excluding VAT, received in bank accounts for this activity, was found lawful.
- Management activity: The assessment on the tax base of TL 20,697.48 excluding VAT was also found lawful.
- Crypto currency item: The assessment and the special irregularity penalty on this item were cancelled.
The court based its decision on the crypto item on two grounds. First, according to the court, it is clear that crypto currencies are used as a means of payment in purchasing various services; the plaintiff also argued that payments of about TL 210,000, which appeared to have been made through two payment institutions, came from cashing out virtual currencies bought in 2013 and 2014 and were not income earned in 2015, and nothing concrete was established to the contrary. Second, the report itself admitted that the blockchain records of the purchases could not be reached and that the profit between purchase and sale could not be calculated. According to the court, this item was calculated on assumption. The regional administrative court rejected the appeals, and the tax administration went to the Council of State against the part that was unfavourable to it.
⚖️ The Council of State's Reasoning: Legality
The 3rd Chamber found the part on the special irregularity penalty consistent with the reasoning of the first-instance decision; it built its assessment of the crypto gain on constitutional principles:
- Certainty and legal security (Constitution Art. 2): Individuals must be able to learn from the law which legal consequence attaches to which act and arrange their conduct accordingly.
- Tax is an interference with the right to property (Constitution Arts. 35 and 13): This interference must rest on law, serve the public interest and be proportionate.
- Legality of taxation (Constitution Art. 73/3): Matters such as liability, tax base, rate, assessment, accrual, collection, sanction and limitation must be regulated by law.
- Income elements are limited (Income Tax Law Arts. 1-2): For a gain to be taxable, it must fall into one of the seven income elements listed in the Income Tax Law.
Within this framework the Chamber found the following: tax legislation contains no definition of crypto currency or crypto assets, no determination of which type of asset they are to be classified under, and no valuation standard. In that situation there is no legal basis for deciding under which income element gains from crypto assets are to be assessed. Taxing with a penalty on the view of the inspector that the gain is commercial income does not comply with the principle of legality.
As a result, the Chamber upheld the part of the judgment on the special irregularity penalty and rejected the appeal against the part concerning income tax with a tax loss penalty of one times the tax.
🗣️ Two Different Dissenting Opinions
The decision contains two dissenting opinions, and each objects to the majority from a different angle:
- Lack of reasoning: According to the first dissenting opinion, the inspection report clearly treated crypto currencies as a "digital commodity" and proposed taxation as commercial income. The court did not discuss this legal characterisation and was content with findings of "assumption" and "lack of consensus". A decision that lacks sufficient reasoning, under Article 141 of the Constitution and Article 24 of the Administrative Procedure Law, should be reversed.
- Commercial organisation: According to the second dissenting opinion, under Article 37 of the Income Tax Law the specific nature of income loses its importance for gains earned within a commercial organisation. Since the plaintiff was accepted to run a capital-intensive and organised commercial activity, income from crypto trading within that activity is also commercial income. The accuracy of the tax base and double counting should have been examined; this opinion does not agree with the conclusion that the gain is not taxable at all.
The second dissenting opinion is important because it shows the limit of the decision in practice: when crypto trading is carried out as part of a commercial business, the debate may shift from "is crypto gain taxable?" to "was the tax base of the commercial income calculated correctly?".
⛓️ Blockchain Records and the Problem of Proof
A less noticed but practically important aspect of the decision concerns proof. The administration could not reach, through the blockchain, the purchase records of the crypto currencies that the taxpayer said had been bought in 2013 and 2014, and so could not calculate the difference between purchase and sale. Even so, all the money received in the bank accounts was treated as 2015 income. The tax court found this approach to rest on assumption.
This finding points to the importance, in disputes about crypto assets, of documenting the purchase cost, the transaction date and the source of the money. The court took into account that amounts coming from payment institutions cannot always be counted as that year's gain and may come from converting into cash assets acquired in earlier years.
🧭 Limits of the Decision and Later Developments
The scope of the decision needs to be read correctly:
- The dispute concerns the year 2015, and the Chamber found that, as of the date of the decision, tax legislation contained no definition specific to crypto assets.
- In the same case, the assessment on advertising and management income was found lawful; the decision does not mean that all of a taxpayer's online income falls outside tax.
- The decision was given by majority, and the second dissenting opinion holds that crypto income within a commercial organisation may be treated as commercial income.
- In 2024, Law No. 7518 added provisions on crypto asset service providers to Capital Markets Law No. 6362. This regulation concerns capital markets legislation; it does not by itself change the income elements in the Income Tax Law.
For current debates and legislative work on taxing crypto gains, see our articles Taxation of Crypto Gains (2026)TR and Debates on the Taxation of Crypto AssetsTR; for the administrative licensing problem of crypto offices, see the article on Council of State 4th Chamber 2025/3497TR.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Did the Council of State rule that crypto gains are exempt from tax?
What happened to the taxpayer's other income?
Why was the special irregularity penalty cancelled?
What did the members who wrote dissenting opinions think?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page; other decisions on crypto assets and tax disputes are listed on the Precedent DecisionsTR page.
This article is for general information only; its content is compiled from the decision of the 3rd Chamber of the Council of State published on mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr. The decision rests on an assessment for the year 2015 and on the legislation in force on the date of the decision; later changes in tax legislation may affect the result. References to legal scholarship and personal names in the text of the decision have been removed from the PDF. In a case that looks similar, the outcome may differ according to the nature of the activity, whether there is a commercial organisation, the transaction records and the court's assessment. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made on the basis of this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Kripto Kazancında Kanunilik – Danıştay 3. D 2024/7487.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Fake Investment Ads: Platform Liability, Germany and Türkiye
- Bank Liability for Forex Pool Account: Court of Cassation Ruling
- Lawsuit Against a Dissolved Company: Istanbul Appeal Court 2025/513
- Bank Reversed a Deposit Without Consent: Court of Cassation 2023
- Recovery Scams: Warning Signs of Fake Fund Recovery Offers
- Forex Scheme Operation: How a Victim Joins the Case (2026)