TR

Bank Liability for Forex Pool Account: Court of Cassation Ruling

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 18 November 2026

Bank Liability for Forex Pool Account: Court of Cassation Ruling

Investors who trade with a forex company based abroad often send their money not to that company itself but to an account opened at a bank in Türkiye. When the trades go badly and the money is lost, the first question is whether the bank that opened the account can be held responsible, since the overseas company is hard to reach. Does using the account as a "pool account" make the bank a partner of the intermediary? The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld a ruling that answered these questions in the negative, in a compensation claim brought against a bank by an investor who had sent money to the Turkish bank account of a UK-based brokerage.

In its decision of 01.06.2022, Docket No. (E.) 2020/7461, Decision No. (K.) 2022/4330, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reviewed the case at a hearing and unanimously upheld the decision of the 13th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, which had rejected on the merits the appeal against the first-instance ruling dismissing the investor's compensation claim against the bank.

In short: The claimant sent money to accounts opened at the head office branch of a bank in Türkiye by a UK-based forex brokerage, traded with leverage and lost money. After amending the claim to 395,600 TL and 60,000 USD, the claimant argued that the bank had facilitated the company's collection of deposits and had an organic link with it. The courts found that the bank had only opened commercial deposit accounts, had taken no part in derivative transactions, that the organic link was not proven and that there was no adequate causal link between the loss and the bank. The Court of Cassation upheld this result.

💸 The path of the money: investor, intermediary and bank

The relationship in this case involves three parties. On one side is the investor who wanted to carry out leveraged currency trades; on the other is the brokerage, named in the decision as ODL Securities Ltd. and described as established in the United Kingdom; in the middle is the bank where that brokerage opened accounts in Türkiye. According to the text of the decision, a deposit account agreement with a start date of 04.07.2008 was signed between the bank and the brokerage, and USD and TL accounts were opened in the brokerage's name at the bank's head office branch.

According to the defendant bank, the claimant sent money to these accounts several times between 10.10.2008 and 28.04.2009. According to the findings of the court of first instance, the claimant used this money to carry out forex and leveraged trades through the claimant's account with the brokerage.

The case was filed before the Istanbul 10th Commercial Court of First Instance for an initial amount of 1,500 TL. By a petition of amendment dated 06.06.2017, the claimant increased the claim to 395,600 TL and 60,000 USD and requested rediscount interest from the date the notice was served.

📌 The claims made against the bank

The points on which the claimant relied to hold the bank responsible can be summarised as follows:

  • The brokerage has no place of business or representative in Türkiye; even so, money was collected from investors in Türkiye through a "central pool account" opened at the bank.
  • The bank caused the intermediary to collect money in breach of the ban on collecting deposits.
  • In its declaration to the tax office, the brokerage gave the bank's head office address as its business address.
  • The brokerage operated like an agency within the bank's own structure.

According to the claimant, this picture shows that the bank was not an ordinary institution opening an account, that it had an organic link with the brokerage and that it should be liable for the investor's loss.

🏦 The bank's defence

The defendant bank argued that it provided ordinary banking services and merely acted as an intermediary in the transfer of money between the claimant and the brokerage. According to the bank, the brokerage's accounts were normal commercial deposit accounts based on a commercial customer agreement, and the bank carried out no derivative transactions.

The defence also stated that the brokerage operated under the supervision of the UK authorities, that on the dates the claimant sent the money there was no SPK regulation governing forex trading in Türkiye, and that such a regulation was introduced about two and a half years later. As to the address in the tax record, the bank argued that its address was entered by mistake when the tax number was obtained, and that there was no actual contact between the bank and the brokerage beyond the account relationship.

⚖️ The first-instance reasoning and the Court of Cassation's approval

The Istanbul 10th Commercial Court of First Instance dismissed the claim in its decision of 22.11.2017, Docket No. (E.) 2012/314, Decision No. (K.) 2017/1422, relying on expert reports and the whole case file. The main lines of the reasoning are as follows:

  • The bank did not carry out the trades: The derivative transactions took place between the claimant and the brokerage; the bank was not the institution carrying them out.
  • The bank's only act was opening an account: A deposit account agreement, that is a central pool account agreement, was concluded between the bank and the brokerage; all the bank did was open an account in that company's name.
  • A similar address is not an organic link: The fact that the address of the business centre where the bank is located was written on the form given to the tax office does not show an organic link between the bank and the intermediary, particularly given that different addresses appear in the incorporation documents, the board resolution and the tax office's other records. The decision also stresses that the business centre consists of several blocks and that many companies other than the bank have their address there.
  • The leverage risk is within the investor's knowledge: It was stated that those who trade in forex markets must be investors who know these markets, and that because of the leverage effect, small movements in currency pairs can lead to large losses as well as large gains.
  • There is no causal link: There is no adequate causal link between the claimant's loss and the act or omission of the bank that could give rise to liability, with or without fault; the loss resulted from the claimant's own trades and the acts of the brokerage.

The claimant's appeal was rejected on the merits by the 13th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal in its decision of 24.09.2020, Docket No. (E.) 2019/89, Decision No. (K.) 2020/939. On 31.05.2022, after hearing the counsel of the claimant and the defendant, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation found no error in the first-instance decision, held that rejecting the appeal on the merits under Article 353/1-b-1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) was in accordance with procedure and the law, and upheld the decision under Article 370/1 of the HMK. An attorney's fee of 3,815 TL for the hearing was awarded in favour of the defendant.

📎 Full text of the decision: The decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 01.06.2022, Docket No. (E.) 2020/7461, Decision No. (K.) 2022/4330, can be read as a PDF here.

🔍 The criteria for the bank's liability

The most instructive part of the decision is that it limits the circumstances in which a bank's status as an "institution of trust" comes into play. According to the first-instance reasoning, the concept of an institution of trust and the rules of liability without fault apply where an unlawful act is carried out on deposit accounts held with the bank itself, either directly through the bank's legal entity or through its employees. In this case, however, the account to which the money was sent belonged to the brokerage, not to the claimant, and no unlawful act by the bank was alleged on the claimant's own account.

The decision indicates two routes to the bank's liability:

  • Liability for fault: There must be a faulty act by bank employees that caused the loss.
  • Employer's liability: As an employer, the bank must have breached the objective duty of care that applies to ordinary-cause liability. This liability is set out in Article 66 of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK); a business owner is liable for loss caused by the business's activities unless it proves that its organisation was adequate to prevent the loss.

The common condition on both routes is that an adequate causal link can be established between the bank's act and the loss. According to the court, opening an account is not, on its own, an adequate cause of the loss arising from the investor's forex trades. The finding that the bank had made no "contribution" to the forex transactions between the claimant and the intermediary determined this result.

The claimant based the organic link claim only on the similarity of addresses in the tax record. Under Article 49 of the TBK, the general rule for tort, the injured party is expected to show the unlawful act, the fault, the loss and the causal link; in this case that burden was not met.

For a broader assessment of banks' duty of care in the context of fraud, see our article on the bank's liability in forex fraudTR; for a different aspect of the receiving bank's duty of care, see the ruling on bank liability for an IBAN–name mismatchTR.

🧭 What it means under today's rules

The money transfers in this case date from 2008-2009. The defendant bank argued that there was no SPK regulation governing forex trading in Türkiye at that time; the court's decision was based not on that argument but on the absence of a causal link. Today, leveraged transactions can be carried out under Capital Markets Law No. 6362 only through authorised institutions, and unauthorised capital markets activity is a criminal offence under Article 109 of the same Law. If a similar relationship were set up today, the legal character of the intermediary's activity could therefore be assessed differently.

However, the core criterion of the decision concerning the bank keeps its importance regardless of the change in legislation:

  • The fact that a deposit account was opened for a company does not by itself make the bank liable to that company's customers.
  • For the bank to be liable, a fault by bank staff or a lack of care in the bank's organisation must be shown concretely.
  • A claim of an "organic link" between the bank and the intermediary must rest on mutually supporting evidence, not on a single indication such as a similar address.
  • Where the real source of the loss is the transactions between the investor and the intermediary, the fact that the bank was merely the place the money passed through is not enough to establish a causal link.

For the criminal law side of sending money to platforms based abroad, see the article on the criminal aspects of overseas forex tradingTR; for ways of getting money back, see refunds in forex fraudTR. A claim to annul an objection brought against an intermediary in a similar case is also covered separately in the ruling on a claim against an overseas platform's intermediary.

🙋 Frequently Asked Questions

Is a bank that opens an account for a forex company based abroad liable for the investor's loss?

Not in this decision. The courts found that the bank only opened a commercial deposit account in the company's name, took no part in forex trades and that there was no adequate causal link between the loss and the bank. The assessment could have been different had fault by bank employees or a lack of care in the bank's organisation been shown concretely.

Does the bank's address in the tax record not prove a connection?

It did not in this case. The court noted that the business centre where the address is located consists of several blocks, that many companies are located there and that the tax office's other records show a different address, and decided that the address on a single form was not enough for an organic link.

How much did the claimant claim and what was the outcome?

The case was filed for 1,500 TL, and by amendment on 06.06.2017 the claim was raised to 395,600 TL and 60,000 USD. The court of first instance dismissed the case, the Regional Court of Appeal rejected the appeal on the merits and the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld the decision on 01.06.2022.

Does the decision mean the bank is never liable?

No. The decision itself accepts that liability can arise where an unlawful act is carried out on deposit accounts through the bank or its employees, and where the bank as an employer breaches the objective duty of care. The result rests on the fact that these conditions could not be proven in this case.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page; other decisions on investment disputes are listed on the Precedent DecisionsTR page.

This article is for general information only; its content was compiled from the decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation published in the Court of Cassation's decision search system and from the first-instance reasoning quoted in that decision. The party names in the decision text are anonymised. The money transfers assessed in the decision date from 2008-2009, and the result rests on the evidence in the specific case and the assessment of the causal link. In a case that looks similar, the result may differ depending on the date of the transactions, the legislation applicable, the bank's actual conduct and the evidence submitted. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Forex Havuz Hesabında Banka – Yargıtay 11. HD 2022/4330.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp