TR

SIM Swap Fraud: Which Court Hears the Bank's Recourse Action?

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 17 November 2026

SIM Swap Fraud: Which Court Hears the Bank's Recourse Action?

A new SIM card issued with a forged identity leads to the accounts of a person on a crypto-asset platform and at a brokerage firm being emptied on the same day; the money goes first to the victim's bank account and from there to the account of an unknown person. The bank settles the loss through mediation with its customer and then brings a recourse action against the mobile operator, its dealer, the crypto platform, the brokerage firm and the bank that received the money. Which court hears this action: the consumer court, because of the subscription relationship between the victim and the operator, or the commercial court of first instance, because the dispute is between merchants?

In its decision of 11.06.2026, Docket No. (E.) 2026/288, Decision No. (K.) 2026/1098, the 12th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal set aside the first-instance ruling that treated the consumer court as competent and held that the action must be heard by the commercial court of first instance. The decision is final.

In short: On 25.07.2025 unidentified persons used the victim's identity details and a forged identity document to obtain a new SIM card from a mobile dealer. A total of TL 371,804.32 was moved from the victim's accounts at two separate institutions to an account opened in the victim's name at the claimant bank; TL 300,000 of this was sent on the same day, in three transfers, to a third-party account at another bank. The bank that covered the loss seeks recovery of the TL 300,000 from the defendants jointly and severally. The 6th Commercial Court of First Instance of Istanbul ruled that it lacked jurisdiction, finding that there was a single loss and that the consumer court was competent because of the relationship between the victim and the operator. The Chamber set that ruling aside, noting that the action is a recourse action concerning the bank's own loss and is heard between merchants.

📱 Accounts emptied in one day

According to the allegations reflected in the decision, the events unfolded as follows:

  1. On 25.07.2025 fraudsters used the victim's identity details and a forged identity document to obtain a new SIM card in the victim's name from a dealer of the mobile operator.
  2. The victim's line was cut off, and the verification messages sent to the victim's phone number reached the fraudsters.
  3. The victim's accounts at the two defendant institutions were accessed; a total of TL 371,804.32, namely TL 360,591 from one and TL 11,213.32 from the other, was transferred to an account opened in the victim's name at the claimant bank.
  4. On the same day TL 300,000 of this amount was sent, in three separate transactions, to an account at another defendant bank that is considered to belong to the fraudsters.
  5. The claimant bank reached a settlement with the victim through voluntary mediation and compensated the loss under an assignment and settlement protocol. An investigation file concerning the incident is also pending at the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office.

Institution names are masked in the decision text, but the grounds of appeal show that one of the defendants from which the money was withdrawn is described as a "... crypto-asset service provider", while the other is a brokerage firm whose liability is asserted under capital markets legislation.

🔗 The faults the bank attributes to the defendants

The claimant bank argued that there was a separate fault at each link of the chain:

  • The mobile operator and its dealer: They issued the SIM card without taking the necessary security measures, and the fraudulent transactions were carried out with messages sent to the line registered on this card.
  • The crypto-asset platform and the brokerage firm: Although the accounts were accessed from a different device and a different IP address, they took no additional security measures and failed to prevent the withdrawal of the money.
  • The bank that received the money: It opened an account for persons committing a crime without fulfilling its customer due diligence and suspicious transaction reporting obligations under the Banking Law No. 5411 and the Law No. 5549 on the Prevention of Laundering of Proceeds of Crime.

On these grounds the bank requested recovery of the TL 300,000 from the defendants jointly and severally, together with advance interest from the date of the incident. Because the court disposed of the case at the preliminary review stage, the defendants never reached the stage of filing a statement of defence. The allegations of fault have therefore not yet been examined by any court.

🏛️ First instance: "a single loss, a specialised court"

In its decision of 01.12.2025 the 6th Commercial Court of First Instance of Istanbul followed a two-step line of reasoning. First, it held that disputes arising from these assets, which are regulated under capital markets legislation, fall within the jurisdiction of the commercial court of first instance under Article 4/1-f of the Turkish Commercial Code (TTK). It then relied on the following principle: where, in the same action, a general court is competent for some defendants and a specialised court for others, and the dispute arises from the same event, there is a single loss and there is no substantial difference between the procedures, the case must be heard in the specialised court in respect of all parties.

The court stated that the relationship between the victim and the mobile operator should be heard by the consumer court and that, since there was a single loss, the whole action should be heard in the consumer court; it dismissed the action on procedural grounds for lack of a procedural requirement under Articles 114/1-c and 115/2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) and issued a ruling of lack of jurisdiction.

⚖️ Three separate appeals and the Chamber's decision

One of the interesting aspects of the case is that both the defendants and the claimant objected to the ruling of lack of jurisdiction. The defendant that appears to be the crypto-asset service provider argued that the parties were not consumers, that the merchant bank was seeking recourse from merchant defendants for the amount it had paid to its customer, and that the action was an absolute commercial case as far as it was concerned. The brokerage firm argued that claims under capital markets legislation had been directed at it and that there was not a single event and a single loss. The claimant bank, in a cross-appeal, stated that it had brought the action not as a consumer but as a creditor that had paid the victim and taken an assignment of the claim.

The Chamber found these objections well founded. The essence of its reasoning is as follows: the action is a recourse action for damages brought by a bank, which paid by way of a mediation agreement the amount withdrawn from its customer's account through an internet banking transaction, against the companies it holds responsible for the incident. Since the bank is obliged to return deposits to the depositor, the loss arising from the loss of the deposit is the bank's own loss. The relationship between the customer, to whom the claimant made the payment, and the mobile operator cannot be extended to this action. The 43rd Civil Chamber decision relied on by the first-instance court cannot be applied to this dispute either.

As a result, the ruling of lack of jurisdiction was set aside under Article 353/1-a-3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the case was sent back to the 6th Commercial Court of First Instance of Istanbul to be heard again.

📎 Decision text: The decision of the 12th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal has been compiled as published on Bedesten (mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr) and checked against the Court of Cassation decision search system. Party and institution names are masked in the source.

📜 Article 4 of the Commercial Code and the nature of the recourse action

The first paragraph of Article 4 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 defines a commercial case in two ways. The first covers civil actions arising from matters relating to the commercial enterprises of both parties. The second covers actions arising from the provisions listed in the Code, regardless of whether the parties are merchants; these include, under sub-paragraph (f), provisions on banks, other credit institutions, financial institutions and lending.

The Chamber based its decision on the first route: the claimant and all the defendants are merchants, and the dispute concerns the commercial enterprises of the claimant bank and the defendant companies. The Chamber found it mistaken that the ruling of lack of jurisdiction was based on the relationship between the victim and the operator. The distinction that emerges from the reasoning can be summarised as follows:

  • The first-instance court took as its basis the subscription relationship between the victim and the mobile operator.
  • In the case at hand, however, the claimant is the bank that paid the loss, and it seeks compensation for the reduction in its own assets. The dispute is no longer between a customer and an institution, but between merchants.

The decision does not reject the principle of "a single loss, a specialised court" itself; the Chamber found the first-instance court's conclusion mistaken because the ground required for applying that principle, namely the carrying over of the victim-operator relationship into the action, was absent.

💡 What it means for crypto and brokerage accounts

This site has addressed SIM card change fraud from other angles. The article on SIM cloning and a crypto accountTR examined a compensation action brought by the victim directly against the mobile operator, and the article on a loan taken by SMS on an unauthorised lineTR examined the bank's liability towards its customer. This decision concerns the next link in the chain: in which court can the bank that covered the loss bring claims against the other institutions it considers responsible?

In practical terms:

  • A bank that has paid its customer's loss through a mediation agreement pursues the recourse action in its own capacity as a merchant; the victim's status as a consumer is not carried over into this action.
  • The fact that different institutions, such as a crypto-asset service provider, a brokerage firm, a mobile operator and a bank, are defendants in the same action does not, on its own, take the case to the consumer court.
  • The discussion of fault and causation will take place before the commercial court of first instance. At that stage it will be examined whether the crypto platform and the brokerage firm carried out additional verification despite the connection from a different device and IP address, how careful the operator was in the SIM issuing process, and whether the receiving bank complied with its customer due diligence obligation.

The scope of the decision should also be understood: the Chamber resolved only the question of jurisdiction. It made no assessment of whether the defendants are liable, of any proportions of fault, or of the amount of compensation.

❓ Questions and answers

Why did the first-instance court treat the consumer court as competent?

The court found that the incident caused a single loss and that the subscription relationship between the victim and the mobile operator falls within the jurisdiction of the consumer court. It issued a ruling of lack of jurisdiction on the principle that, where a specialised court is competent for some of the defendants in an action arising from the same event, the whole action must be heard there.

Why did the Chamber not accept this approach?

According to the Chamber, the action is a recourse action in which a bank that paid its customer's loss seeks its own loss from the companies it holds responsible. The loss arising from the loss of the deposit is the bank's loss, and the relationship between the customer and the operator cannot be extended to this action. Because the parties are merchants and the dispute concerns their commercial enterprises, the commercial court of first instance is competent under Article 4 of the Commercial Code.

Does the decision say that the crypto platform or the brokerage firm is liable?

No. The decision concerns only which court is competent. The allegations of lack of security and care made against the defendants will be examined by the commercial court of first instance to which the case was sent back.

Can this decision be appealed to the Court of Cassation?

The decision text states that the decision was given as final under Article 362/1-g of the Code of Civil Procedure. This decision of setting aside on the question of jurisdiction is therefore not open to review by the Court of Cassation.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page, and the other articles in the series are in the Precedent DecisionsTR archive.

The information in this article is provided for general information purposes and may not be up to date; the summary is compiled from the decision of the 12th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal published on Bedesten. The assessment is based on a single case concerning only the question of the competent court in a recourse action brought by a bank that paid its customer's loss after a SIM card change; cases in which the claimant's capacity, the parties and the claim differ may reach different results. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article SIM Değişikliğinde Rücu ve Görev – İst. BAM 12. HD 2026/1098.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp