Forex Loss Above Margin: Court of Cassation 2025/3733

If a leveraged account swings overnight from profit to a negative balance of millions of dollars, can the brokerage cover that gap from the client's deposit at another bank? And after the client has lost the margin in the account, is the client also liable for the loss that exceeds it? The Court of Cassation (11th Civil Chamber) upheld a ruling in a case where, after leveraged positions were closed on 15.01.2015, the investor's bank deposits and bonds were transferred to the brokerage. The ruling ordered the transferred assets returned and rejected the brokerage's claim for the loss exceeding the margin.
In its decision of 27.05.2025, Docket No. (E.) 2024/3925, Decision No. (K.) 2025/3733, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld the ruling of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal (43rd Civil Chamber), which had dismissed the appeals on the merits against the Istanbul 9th Consumer Court's judgment. That judgment had accepted the investor's action to annul the objection to enforcement and rejected the brokerage's counterclaim.
🌙 The Night Between Two E-mails
The events described in the statement of claim are as follows: the claimant had an account with one of the defendants, an investment firm, that is, a brokerage. An e-mail sent to the claimant at about 10.30 on 15.01.2015 stated that the leveraged trading position had been closed and that the account held assets of USD 132,261.03. A second e-mail the next day, 16.01.2015 at 00.00.33, stated that the account had a negative balance of USD 7,649,895.33.
The claimant learned that the deposits and bonds held at the other defendant, a bank, had been transferred to the brokerage, although the claimant had given no instruction to withdraw money from the account at the bank or to transfer it to another account. Following this:
- On 22.01.2015 the claimant sent a notice to both defendants stating that the transactions were not accepted.
- On 06.02.2015 the claimant applied to the Capital Markets Board (SPK) about the defendants.
- As the assets were not returned, the claimant started enforcement proceedings without a court judgment against the defendants, and the defendants objected to the proceedings.
The claimant sought annulment of the objection, relying on the provision of Capital Markets Board Communiqué No. III-37.1 that a client cannot be made to incur a loss exceeding the deposited margin in leveraged transactions and that a loss exceeding the margin because of market conditions cannot be claimed from the investor. The action was filed on 04.03.2015.
🛡️ The Defences of the Bank and the Brokerage
The defendant bank argued that all transactions on the account were carried out within the contracts between the parties and the claimant's instructions, that it had met its obligations under banking legislation, and asked for the action to be dismissed.
The defendant brokerage first argued that no claim could be directed against it because the transactions took place in accounts at the other defendant, the bank. On the merits, it argued that the transactions complied with the contracts and the legislation, and that the leveraged trading service was provided under a framework intermediary agreement and a framework agreement for leveraged trading transactions.
The brokerage also filed a counterclaim. In it, the brokerage argued that the claimant's positions were closed automatically by the system because of developments on 15.01.2015, that a loss exceeding the margin in the account arose on that date, and, reserving its rights for any greater amount, it asked for TRY 10,000.00 to be collected.
🔍 Expert Reports and the First-Instance Ruling
The Istanbul 9th Consumer Court (2018/186 E., 2020/673 K.) based its judgment on the reports of two separate expert panels. The main findings in the reports and the judgment are as follows:
- Transferring the claimant's bank deposits and bonds to the brokerage without the claimant's approval and instruction is not in line with procedure and the law.
- These transfers could not be made under the deposit pledge agreement and the automatic transfer instruction.
- On 09.07.2015, after the action was filed, the defendants paid TRY 2,838,324.62 into the claimant's bank account; the outstanding debt on the cover sheet of the enforcement file of the same date is TRY 2,914,601.54.
- For the principal claim of TRY 2,594,200.00 subject to enforcement, the request for statutory interest from 16.01.2015, when the deposits and bonds were transferred, to the enforcement date of 20.02.2015 is justified.
- Under Article 19(d) of Communiqué No. III-37.1, in force when the account was closed, the brokerage cannot claim from the client a loss greater than the client's margin.
On these grounds the court accepted the main claim and ordered the payment of TRY 2,838,324.62 to be taken into account at the enforcement stage, provided that the claimant does not collect twice. It found the claim to be liquid and the objection unjustified, awarded enforcement denial compensation at 20% of the principal claim, and rejected the counterclaim.
The basis of enforcement denial compensation is Article 67 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004. Under this article, if the debtor's objection is found unjustified in an action to annul the objection, the debtor is ordered, at the creditor's request, to pay compensation of not less than twenty per cent of the amount awarded.
🏛️ The Appeal and Court of Cassation Stage
The Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 43rd Civil Chamber (2021/464 E., 2024/477 K.), found the first-instance decision lawful in procedure and substance and dismissed the parties' appeals on the merits. The brokerage and the bank appealed this decision to the Court of Cassation.
The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation characterised the dispute as an action to annul the objection in the main case and a claim for receivables in the counterclaim. The Chamber found no error in the first-instance decision, stated that dismissal of the appeal on the merits under Article 353/1-b(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) was in line with procedure and law, and upheld the decision under Article 370/1 of the HMK. The defendants were ordered to pay the claimant TRY 28,000.00 as attorney's fees for the hearing. The decision was final and unanimous.
📉 The Rule on Loss Exceeding the Margin
In leveraged transactions an investor can open positions many times larger than the margin deposited. In sudden, sharp price moves, if positions cannot be closed at stop-loss levels, the loss may exceed the margin and the account may fall into a negative balance. In this case the brokerage's counterclaim aimed precisely at collecting this negative balance.
The decision refers to two provisions on this point:
- The claimant relied on the provision of Article 24 of Communiqué No. III-37.1 that a client cannot be made to incur a loss exceeding the margin and that a loss exceeding the margin arising from market conditions cannot be claimed from the investor.
- The first-instance court rejected the counterclaim on the basis of Article 19(d) of the same Communiqué, in force when the account was closed.
Both references point to the same principle: in leveraged trading, the brokerage cannot ask the investor for a loss exceeding the margin that arose from market conditions. In the text of the decision the article relied on by the claimant and the article applied by the court are cited with different numbers; the Court of Cassation found no error in the first-instance reasoning on which the judgment rests.
This rule is different from futures and options contracts traded on the exchange. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation has also upheld a decision that a brokerage which pays a margin shortfall to the clearing institution in Borsa Istanbul derivatives market (VİOP) transactions may claim that amount from the client; for this distinction, see the article on margin shortfall in leveraged transactionsTR. For a regional court of appeal decision on the debate over closing positions during sudden price moves, see the article on stop-out during negative oil pricesTR.
🏦 The Limit of a Pledge and Automatic Transfer Instruction
The second important aspect of the decision is that the brokerage reached for the investor's assets at another bank to close the negative balance. The defendant bank argued that the transactions complied with the contracts and instructions, while the brokerage objected that the transactions were carried out in accounts at the bank and that it was not the right defendant. These defences had no effect.
The expert panels found that the transfers could not be made under the deposit pledge agreement and the automatic transfer instruction; the first-instance court based its judgment on this finding. As a result, both the bank and the brokerage were the addressees of the ruling annulling the objection regarding the return of the transferred assets, and the ruling was upheld by the Court of Cassation. The conclusion from the decision is this: if a loss exceeding the margin cannot be claimed from the investor, collecting that loss from the investor's assets at another institution through a pledge or an automatic transfer was also not found lawful on the facts of the decision.
The scope of the decision should also be read correctly. The Court of Cassation's brief reasoning for upholding does not contain an assessment of the general validity of pledge agreements; the assessment rests on the expert findings about the content of the contracts and instructions in this case. For another aspect of a negative balance in a brokerage account, see the article on transactions continuing in a negative balanceTR.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Why was the brokerage's counterclaim rejected?
What happened to the payment made during the case?
From which date was interest calculated?
Did the claimant's application to the SPK affect the case?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page, and similar decisions are in the Precedent DecisionsTR archive.
This article is for general information; its content is compiled from the decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation published in the Court of Cassation decision search system. The decision is a brief upholding decision; findings of fact rest on the first-instance court's judgment and the expert reports. The Communiqué provisions cited in the decision are the texts in force on the date of the events and may have changed since. Different results may be reached in cases where the content of the contract, the pledge and automatic transfer instructions, or the type of transaction differ. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made on the basis of this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Teminatı Aşan Forex Zararı – Yargıtay 11. HD 2025/3733.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Forex Stop-Out and Spread Claim: Court of Cassation 2025/4543
- Telegram Share Transfer Case: Sakarya Court of Appeal 2026/461
- Brokerage Liability for Leveraged Trading Loss: Court of Cassation
- Cloned Investment Site Access Ban Denied: Istanbul 2025/788
- Share Purchase Deception: One-Year Limit in a Turkish Appeal Ruling
- Court Resists Cassation Reversal on Limitation, Ankara 2026/1327