Brokerage Liability for Leveraged Trading Loss: Court of Cassation

Can a brokerage firm be held responsible for a loss when an investor has had an account opened for leveraged currency trading managed by someone else under a notarised power of attorney, and millions of lira are lost? Does an allegation that the attorney was acting as an unauthorised portfolio manager place a separate notification duty on the brokerage firm? Can a claim be brought against a second institution that has no contract with the account holder but stood on the other side of the trades? A compensation case opened eleven years ago has received a final answer to these questions after a hearing before the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation.
In its decision of 4 June 2026, Docket No. (E.) 2025/4003, Decision No. (K.) 2026/3254, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld, unanimously and as final, the decision of the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, which had rejected on the merits the appeal against the first instance judgment dismissing a case brought to recover losses from leveraged trading from brokerage firms.
🔑 Opening the Account and the Power of Attorney
According to the case summarised in the regional court of appeal decision, the claimant opened an account with the defendant brokerage firm on 16 July 2013 and signed a series of documents the same day: the "Risk Disclosure Form for Leveraged Asset Trading", the "Leveraged Trading Notification Form", the "Leverage Ratios Applicable in Leveraged Trading" and the "Pre-Contract Information and Agreement Form". All agreements were signed and the account was opened with this brokerage firm.
On 14 January 2014 the claimant authorised a person, by notarised power of attorney, to trade on his accounts at the defendant brokerage firm. Another fact that appears in the case is that the claimant held a 49.5% share in a company trading foreign currency and gold and worked as one of its managers. In addition, by a protocol dated 29 May 2014 the claimant accepted, declared and undertook that he knew the structure of the market and the instrument in leveraged trading and the risks involved, that sudden price swings in extraordinary market conditions fall within force majeure, and that he was aware of platform, technology, market and product risks.
📣 The Investor's Four Main Claims
The claimant's allegations in the petition can be grouped under four headings:
- Suitability: Leveraged trading was not among the preferred transactions in the customer profile form, and the form was not updated as the legislation requires. A customer who only wanted to trade shares was made to sign a high-risk leveraged trading agreement.
- Information: No written or verbal warning was given, no declaration that the form had been read and understood was taken, and an ordinary document was signed within an agreement set of about 50 pages.
- Unauthorised portfolio management: The fact that the trades were carried out by an unauthorised portfolio manager was ignored, and the claimant's lack of knowledge and experience was exploited.
- Margin and loss: No margin call was ever sent to the claimant; the situation of 26 May 2014 was repeated on 15 January 2015, and the cash in the account was allegedly lost in 11 seconds. The total loss was stated as 8,409,962 TL.
The petition also states that the authority to regulate leveraged trading was given to the SPK by a provision added to Article 30 of the former Capital Markets Law No. 2499 on 13 February 2011, and that the maximum leverage ratio permitted under the Communiqué Series V, No. 125 in force at the time and the Communiqué No. III-37.1, which entered into force on 1 July 2014, was 100:1. The claimant also joined to the case the second brokerage firm, which he alleged was on the other side of the trades, and sought collection of 100,000 TL with statutory interest from the defendants for the time being.
🛡️ The Defence of the Two Brokerage Firms
The brokerage firm with which the account was opened argued that the claimant had stated his loss as 9,436,884.30 TL and 21,000 USD, that the court fee had to be completed, that the claimant had been fully informed of all risks before and after the agreement, and that it had acted in line with capital markets legislation. The firm also argued that there was no causal link between the alleged breaches of legislation and the loss, that no fault could be attributed either to the trading platform or to itself, and that it could not be held responsible for the commissions the claimant paid to his attorney.
The second brokerage firm stated that it had no contract with the claimant, that the claimant was not its customer and that the allegations were abstract, and asked for the case to be dismissed.
🔍 The Reasoning of the Lower Courts
| Issue in dispute | Findings of the courts |
|---|---|
| Agreement and forms | An agreement and forms complying with SPK legislation were drawn up between the claimant and the brokerage firm with which the account was opened |
| Appointment of the attorney | The claimant appointed an attorney through a notary within the limits permitted by SPK legislation |
| Notification of unauthorised portfolio management | The brokerage firm cannot be held responsible for failing to notify the SPK of the attorney's unauthorised portfolio management; in any case, the notification duty entered into force on 1 July 2014 |
| Margin and platform | The trades were margined in line with market practice, the practice does not breach the mandatory provisions of the SPK, and the programme used is the most widely preferred one for this type of trading |
| The second brokerage firm | It is not a party to the agreement, no direct transaction with the claimant could be identified, and it was not held responsible under the representation relationship either |
The 16th Commercial Court of First Instance of Istanbul (E.2015/288, K.2021/253) dismissed the case on these grounds. The 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal (E.2021/1831, K.2025/724) added two important findings to the first instance decision. First, the position of the brokerage firm with which the account was opened in the trades in question is "transaction intermediation", not "intermediation in order transmission"; the second firm is a broad-authority brokerage firm holding a portfolio intermediation licence. Second, the SPK report of 8 February 2018 on which the claimant's lawyer relied as evidence made no finding on practices of the second firm that breached legislation and saw no need for any action. For this reason, the ground of appeal that the second firm should be held responsible because of the agreement it signed with the other brokerage firm and the representation relationship was found unfounded.
⚖️ Court of Cassation Review and Outcome
The regional court of appeal decision was appealed on points of law by the claimant's lawyer with a request for a hearing, and the Chamber heard the lawyers of the parties on 2 June 2026. The Chamber characterised the case as "a claim for recovery of a loss suffered from an investment made under a leveraged trading agreement".
In its assessment, the Chamber stated that, considering the legal rules to be applied to the proceedings conducted and the specific dispute established, there was no error in the first instance decision, and that the regional court of appeal decision rejecting the appeal on the merits under Article 353/1-b(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) was in line with procedure and the law. The decision was upheld under Article 370/1 of the HMK; a hearing attorney's fee of 40,000 TL was ordered to be collected from the claimant and given to the defendants, and the decision was given as final and unanimous on 4 June 2026.
🧭 The Limit of Brokerage Firm Liability
The lower court reasoning that became final with the decision of affirmation sets out several criteria on where a brokerage firm's liability begins and ends in leveraged trading disputes:
- Compliance of the documents with legislation: That the risk disclosure form, the leverage ratios and the pre-contract information documents were signed was seen as decisive in assessing the allegation of a breach of the information duty.
- The attorney the investor appointed: The trades of the person managing the account under a notarised power of attorney took place within the limits the legislation allows, so they were not turned into a fault of the brokerage firm.
- Timing of the notification duty: It was stressed that the notification duty on unauthorised portfolio management entered into force on 1 July 2014; no liability was placed on the brokerage firm for the period before the duty arose.
- The investor's profile and declarations: The claimant's shareholding and management role in a company trading foreign currency and gold, and the risk declaration of 29 May 2014, were among the facts in the case in assessing the allegation of lack of knowledge and experience.
- Position of an institution outside the contract: For the liability of an institution on the other side of the trades that had no contract with the investor, a concrete breach of legislation or a direct transaction relationship was required.
The distinction the courts drew between "intermediation in order transmission" and "transaction intermediation" also matches the list of investment services in Article 37 of Capital Markets Law No. 6362, which is in force today: that article treats the receipt and transmission of orders (sub-paragraph a), the execution of orders in the name and on account of the customer or in one's own name and on the customer's account (sub-paragraph b) and portfolio management (sub-paragraph ç) as separate services.
On the different aspects of brokerage firm liability in leveraged trading, the articles on the loss of an investor who failed the suitability testTR and, on the relationship between attorney and account holder, losses in stock exchange trades made under power of attorneyTR can also be examined.
💡 Questions People Ask
Did the Court of Cassation give its own reasoning separately?
The Chamber gave a decision of affirmation, stating that there was no error in the first instance decision and that the regional court of appeal decision rejecting the appeal on the merits was in line with procedure and the law. For this reason, the detailed assessments on the merits of the dispute are found in the reasoning of the first instance and regional court of appeal decisions that were upheld.
Did the leveraged trading box not being ticked in the customer profile form change the result?
The claimant raised this point, but the lower courts, assessing the expert reports, concluded that the agreement and forms were drawn up in line with SPK legislation. That the risk disclosure and leverage ratio forms specific to leveraged trading were signed when the account was opened, and the risk declaration protocol the claimant signed later, are among the facts in the case in this assessment.
Why could a claim not be brought against the second institution, which had no direct connection with the account?
According to the courts, this institution did not sign a contract with the claimant, no direct transaction with the claimant could be identified, and the SPK report of 8 February 2018 found no practice of this institution that breached legislation. The agreement and representation relationship with the other brokerage firm was also not seen as sufficient for liability.
Is the decision final, and what happened to the legal costs?
The decision of affirmation was given as final. The case file was sent to the first instance court to be dealt with under Article 372 of the HMK, and it was ordered that the assessed hearing attorney's fee of 40,000 TL be collected from the claimant and given to the defendants and that the appeal costs be borne by the appellant.
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are available on the contact page, and other decisions on capital markets and investment disputes can be reached in the Precedent DecisionsTR archive.
This article is for general information only; the summary is compiled from the decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation published in the Court of Cassation Decision Search system. The assessment rests on a single case concerning the leveraged trading loss of an investor who had his account managed by another person under a notarised power of attorney; different results may be reached in cases where the signed documents, the investor's profile, the period of the trades and the legislation applied differ. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made using this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Kaldıraçlı İşlemde Vekil Zararı – Yargıtay 11. HD 2026/3254.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Cloned Investment Site Access Ban Denied: Istanbul 2025/788
- Share Purchase Deception: One-Year Limit in a Turkish Appeal Ruling
- Court Resists Cassation Reversal on Limitation, Ankara 2026/1327
- Forex 'Licensed Guarantee' Ad Fined: Council of State 2023/4732
- 1:400 Forex Leverage Claim: Court of Cassation 2024/9133
- Bank Pledge over Client Shares: Court of Cassation 2024/2923