Forex Stop-Out and Spread Claim: Court of Cassation 2025/4543

If a leveraged trading agreement says "the maintenance margin is 50% of the initial margin", must the investor's positions be closed at exactly that level? If the brokerage keeps positions open until the margin falls to 10% or 20% and only then closes them, who bears the loss in between? In the same case the investor also complains about the spread: he alleges that he was told the spread was 15 units, but 27 units were applied to his account. In a compensation claim filed two years later, the contract clause requiring "written objection within one business day" becomes decisive. In this dispute arising from leveraged trading, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld the lower courts' dismissal of the claim.
By its decision of 25 June 2025, Docket No. (E.) 2024/5085, Decision No. (K.) 2025/4543, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation unanimously upheld the decision of the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, which had dismissed on the merits the appeal against the Istanbul 5th Commercial Court of First Instance's judgment rejecting a compensation claim against a brokerage. Three points were decisive: the contract placed margin monitoring on the investor, it made closing positions a right of the brokerage rather than an obligation, and the objection period provided for spread changes was not used.
- The investor's three separate claims
- The brokerage's defence: dynamic spread and liquidity provider
- First instance, appeal and Court of Cassation
- Maintenance margin: an obligation or a right?
- Spread changes and the one-business-day objection period
- The price slippage claim and the SPK report
- The limits of the decision
- Frequently Asked Questions
📉 The investor's three separate claims
The claimant investor stated that he noticed slippage in the pricing and orders of the trades made in his account with the brokerage. According to his review, there was slippage in all of his positions closed by stop-out and stop-loss, while there was no slippage in any position that ended in his favour (take profit). In one example given in the statement of claim, a 10-lot gold position sold at 1297.30 was stopped out at 1308.29 at 17:09 on 14 July 2014; according to the claimant, gold never reached this level on that day and at that time. In another example, a position in an index contract was closed at 16,221 on 8 August 2014, and the claimant stated that he found the lowest price at another brokerage the same day to be 16,256.
The second claim concerns Article 33 of the contract. Under this article, the maintenance margin equals 50% of the initial margin amount. The claimant argued that his positions were closed not at this level but at 20% or 10% of the initial margin, and that the brokerage was liable for the resulting loss.
The third claim is the spread difference. According to the claimant, the USD/TRY spread for his group should have been at most 15, but 27 was applied; in a telephone call on 30 July 2014 a brokerage official accepted that the group's spread was 15, and an e-mail dated 2 May 2014 announced a campaign with a spread of 8 on USD/TRY trades.
🏦 The brokerage's defence: dynamic spread and liquidity provider
The brokerage argued that the contract regulated the principles of leveraged trading in detail and that, under Article 72 of the contract, the investor had been informed through the risk disclosure form attached to it. According to the defence, prices are obtained from the brokerage's liquidity provider, and neither the Capital Markets Law nor the regulations of the Capital Markets Board (SPK) require it to quote the same price as other institutions.
On the spread, the brokerage stated that the spread is the difference between the bid and ask price, is not a commission, and may change depending on liquidity, especially during major data releases. The defence also stated that a "dynamic spread", not a fixed one, applied to the products the claimant traded, and that Article 41 of the contract expressly provides that the brokerage may change swap and spread rates at any time.
⚖️ First instance, appeal and Court of Cassation
| Stage | Outcome and basis |
|---|---|
| Istanbul 5th Commercial Court of First Instance (E.2019/482, K.2021/994) | Dismissed. According to the report of a panel of experts with knowledge of the capital markets field and a banking expert, applying different spreads is normal, there is no legal limit on the spread range, and the applied spread is consistent with the liquidity firm; on stop-out, the investor granted authority by contract. |
| Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 14th Civil Chamber (E.2023/1489, K.2024/1107) | Appeal dismissed on the merits (Article 353/1-b(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, HMK). |
| Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber (E.2024/5085, K.2025/4543) | Hearing on 24 June 2025; on 25 June 2025, upheld under Article 370/1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK), unanimously. |
The Court of Cassation characterised the case as "an indeterminate-claim action for loss and loss of profit, based on the allegations that trades were not made at correct market prices, that positions were closed at 10-20% despite the stop-out level stated as 50% in the contract, and that a high spread was applied". The chamber concluded that the first-instance decision contained no error and that the dismissal of the appeal on the merits complied with procedure and law.
🧮 Maintenance margin: an obligation or a right?
The most striking aspect of the case is how the 50% ratio in the contract is read. The claimant saw this ratio as a closing threshold that the brokerage had to observe. The regional court of appeal, however, assessed Article 33 not on its own but together with the articles that follow it:
- Article 32: The initial margin is the minimum amount required to open a new position.
- Article 33: The maintenance margin is the amount that must be held to keep open positions, equal to 50% of the initial margin.
- Article 34: If the margin falls to or below this level, the brokerage, "without being under any obligation", has the right to liquidate all or part of the open positions; monitoring the margin is the investor's task, and the investor is liable for any resulting loss.
- Article 35: Monitoring the margin limits and topping them up when necessary is the investor's obligation; the brokerage may request that a margin shortfall be made good.
On the basis of these provisions, the regional court of appeal found that the contract placed margin monitoring and top-up on the investor, and that although the brokerage had the authority to request that a margin shortfall be made good, it had no obligation to do so. Taking into account freedom of contract and the signed risk disclosure form, closing positions at 20% or 10% of the initial margin was not regarded as a breach of contract; it was also stated that these provisions did not conflict with the relevant SPK communiqués.
As a result, the 50% threshold was treated in this case as the lower limit giving the brokerage the right to close; it was not read as a provision creating a duty to close positions immediately once the threshold was crossed. A different dispute on the consequences of a margin shortfall for the investor is examined in the article on a margin shortfall in leveraged tradingTR.
⏱️ Spread changes and the one-business-day objection period
On the spread claim, the regional court of appeal relied on the following provision in Article 41 of the contract: the brokerage may change swap and spread rates at any time; the change is notified to the investor, and if the investor does not object in writing within 1 business day from the date the notice is received, the change applies to the transactions between the parties.
The expert reports established that the brokerage sent account statements and the trade prices obtained from the liquidity provider to the claimant by e-mail. It was emphasised that the claimant did not object within the period set by the contract; that instead of objecting and asking for correction as soon as he noticed a loss caused by the higher spread, he filed the case about two years later; and that in the meantime he continued making new trades without raising any reservation. The court found it contrary to the contract to seek compensation for the loss in this way.
🔎 The price slippage claim and the SPK report
The claimant complained to the Capital Markets Board (SPK) and also relied on a report dated 31 July 2015 of the SPK Intermediary Activities Department as evidence. According to the claimant, this report accepted that closing positions at the 10-20% level despite the 50% maintenance margin was contrary to Article 33 of the contract. Relying on the same report and the expert reports, the regional court of appeal made the following findings:
- The brokerage has no obligation to quote the same price as other brokerages.
- The prices given in the trades the claimant mentioned are consistent with the prices the brokerage obtained from its liquidity provider.
- Neither the framework agreement nor SPK legislation requires a brokerage to disclose its liquidity provider and the price information it receives to its customers.
- Account statements were sent by e-mail, as the contract provides.
The court of first instance also stated that no fault attributable to the brokerage could be established as to the loss, and that the conditions for compensation were not met. A similar discussion on platform prices, in the context of a sudden price drop, is covered in the article on the price claim in a flash crashTR.
🧭 The limits of the decision
A few points need to be underlined to define the scope of the decision correctly. First, the Court of Cassation did not build its own reasoning; it found the lower courts' assessment correct. The reading of the 50% threshold therefore rests on the wording "without being under any obligation" and "monitoring is the investor's task" in Articles 34 and 35 of this particular contract. It cannot be said that the same result would follow under a differently drafted contract.
Second, on the spread, what was decisive was the short objection period in the contract and the claimant's continuing to trade without any reservation. The decision does not separately discuss the validity of this period or whether it is a general transaction condition; the court relied on the principle of freedom of contract and on the finding that the provisions did not conflict with SPK communiqués.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between stop-out, maintenance margin and initial margin?
Why did the court not regard closing at the 10-20% level as a breach of contract?
Does a brokerage have to quote the prices of other institutions?
Is the decision final, and how long did the case take?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page, and other decisions on capital markets and leveraged trading are in the Precedent DecisionsTR archive.
This article is for general information only; its content is compiled from the decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation published in the Court of Cassation decision search system. The decision upholding the judgment rests on the reasoning of the lower courts. Different outcomes may be reached in cases with different contract provisions, objection periods, expert findings and price records. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Forex'te Stop-Out ve Spread – Yargıtay 11. HD 2025/4543.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Telegram Share Transfer Case: Sakarya Court of Appeal 2026/461
- Brokerage Liability for Leveraged Trading Loss: Court of Cassation
- Cloned Investment Site Access Ban Denied: Istanbul 2025/788
- Share Purchase Deception: One-Year Limit in a Turkish Appeal Ruling
- Court Resists Cassation Reversal on Limitation, Ankara 2026/1327
- Forex 'Licensed Guarantee' Ad Fined: Council of State 2023/4732