TR

Telegram Share Transfer Case: Sakarya Court of Appeal 2026/461

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 16 November 2026

Telegram Share Transfer Case: Sakarya Court of Appeal 2026/461

Small investors in a share whose value has fallen quickly are gathered in a social media group with the call: "if we act together, we gain strength against the major shareholders." The proposed route is simple: the shares will be collected in the account of a few people who "know the business", and the group will have a say at the general meeting. The shares are transferred, but the promised steps are never taken and the shares do not come back. The lawsuit filed for their return then stops at a preliminary question before reaching the merits: when the return of shares traded on the stock exchange is requested, does the case go to the commercial court or to the civil court of general jurisdiction?

By its decision of 05.03.2026, Docket No. (E.) 2025/2141, Decision No. (K.) 2026/461, the 7th Civil Chamber of the Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal found the first-instance commercial court's ruling of lack of jurisdiction correct in an action to annul an objection concerning the return of shares transferred free of charge through a Telegram group, and rejected the claimant's appeal on the merits, unanimously and with final effect.

In short: In 2022 the claimant bought shares of a listed company that soon lost value. Following a call in a Telegram group set up by the defendant to "organise as small shareholders", the claimant transferred 54,000 lots to the defendant free of charge by an instruction to the brokerage firm. According to the claimant, the defendant had a pledge placed on the collected shares, traded on the stock exchange for his own account and did not return the shares. After an objection to the enforcement proceedings started at the Gebze Enforcement Office, the Gebze Commercial Court of First Instance declined jurisdiction in the action to annul the objection. The regional court of appeal accepted that the transactions were not stock exchange transactions, that the claim arose from a personal tort between the parties, and that under Article 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) the civil court of general jurisdiction is competent.

📉 Loss of Value, the Telegram Group and the Free Transfer

According to the statement of claim, in 2022 the claimant bought shares of an electrical contracting company traded on Borsa Istanbul at a price band of 12–15 TL per lot. The claimant alleged that, as a result of manipulative acts by the major shareholders who held the company's management, the shares fell to a band of 3–4 TL within a month or two.

At this stage the defendant, who said he had suffered in the same way, set up a Telegram group under a nickname. According to the claimant's account, the group urged small shareholders to unite against the major shareholders and organise to carry out "certain transactions"; for these to be possible, it was agreed that the small investors' shares would be transferred to a few people who were said to know the subject and to have a say.

By an instruction given to a brokerage firm branch on 24.10.2022, the claimant transferred 54,000 lots to the defendant on 26.10.2022 without receiving any payment, and also passed a part of the shares to another person who is not a party to the case. Some time later it became clear that the defendant had not taken the company to an extraordinary general meeting and had not kept the commitments given in the group. According to the claimant, the investigation showed that the defendant had a pledge placed on the shares collected in this way and carried out stock exchange transactions in his own name and for his own account. The claimant stated that some people had been given their shares back, but his own had not been returned.

🗂️ From the Enforcement Proceedings to the Ruling of Lack of Jurisdiction

The claimant started enforcement proceedings under file no. 2025/22955 of the Gebze Enforcement Office and, after the defendant objected, filed an action to annul the objection on 24.10.2025. The court records describe the case as "Annulment of Objection (arising from a loan agreement)". Arguing that the claim is liquid and that value is lost in an inflationary environment, the claimant also requested a 100 per cent enforcement denial compensation.

Stage Date and number Result
Share transfer Instruction 24.10.2022, transfer 26.10.2022 54,000 lots transferred to the defendant free of charge
Enforcement proceedings Gebze Enforcement Office 2025/22955 E. Stopped by the defendant's objection
First instance Gebze Commercial Court of First Instance, 27.10.2025, E.2025/1089 Lack of jurisdiction; dismissed on procedural grounds under HMK 114/1-c and 115/2
Appeal Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal, 7th Civil Chamber, 05.03.2026, E.2025/2141, K.2026/461 Rejected on the merits (unanimous, final)

The first-instance court stated that under Article 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) the civil court of general jurisdiction is competent to hear the case, and ordered that, once the decision became final and if requested in time, the case be sent to the Gebze Duty Civil Court of First Instance. The case was filed on 24.10.2025 and the ruling on jurisdiction was given on 27.10.2025.

📎 Text of the decision: The decision of the 7th Civil Chamber of the Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal has been compiled as published on Bedesten (mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr); the party names are anonymised in the source.

📨 The Claimant's Appeal

The claimant's lawyer argued that a claim and a compensation request arising from the transfer of shares are a commercial matter under the Turkish Commercial Code (TTK) and that the commercial court is therefore competent. In support, reference was made to the decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 03.04.2018, Docket No. (E.) 2016/12218, Decision No. (K.) 2018/2358. According to the claimant, because the subject is shares traded on the stock exchange and their transfer, the dispute is commercial in nature.

⚖️ Why Did the Chamber Hold the Civil Court Competent?

The chamber first characterised the dispute as "a claim arising from a tort". It then recalled the framework set by Article 4 of the TTK: for a case to count as commercial, either the matter in dispute must relate to the commercial enterprise of both parties, or, regardless of whether the parties are merchants, the TTK or another law must provide that the commercial court hears that case. Article 4/1 of the TTK also treats as absolutely commercial cases those arising from matters provided for, for example, in "the special provisions on stock exchanges, fairs, markets, warehouses and other places specific to trade".

In the case at hand the chamber made the following findings:

  • No stock exchange transaction: The transactions in the case are not stock exchange transactions; even though the shares are traded on the exchange, the dispute does not arise from the special provisions on the exchange.
  • Personal nature: The claim is a receivable of a personal nature between the parties, arising from a tort concerning the value of the shares.
  • General rule on jurisdiction: Under Article 2 of the HMK, in cases concerning property rights, regardless of the value and amount of the subject matter, the competent court is the civil court of general jurisdiction unless otherwise provided.

For these reasons no procedural or legal error was found in the ruling of lack of jurisdiction. The chamber also described as a material error the fact that the first-instance court, although it ruled on lack of jurisdiction in the operative part, spoke of a "negative conflict of jurisdiction" in its reasoning; since this did not affect the outcome, it limited itself to criticising the point. The appeal was rejected on the merits under HMK 353/1-b.1; of the appeal decision fee of 732.00 TL, the 615.40 TL paid in advance was set off and the remaining 116.60 TL was to be collected from the claimant. Under Article 362 of the HMK the decision is final.

🔍 Reading It Together with the Share Loan Decision

Cases in which shares traded on the stock exchange are passed from one person to another and not returned come before the courts in different forms. The 12th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal had treated an action for the return of shares allegedly lent by a transfer described as "Lending" as an absolutely commercial case; that decision is examined in the article on lent stock exchange sharesTR.

The Sakarya decision, by contrast, rests on a different factual basis:

  1. In the Istanbul case the relationship was a share loan clearly set up between the parties as "lending"; in the Sakarya case the shares were transferred free of charge following a call to organise made in a social media group.
  2. The Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal characterised the claim, which appears in the records as "arising from a loan agreement", as a tort and based its result on that characterisation.
  3. In both decisions the deciding question is whether the dispute rests on a matter that the TTK or a special law counts as a commercial case; the answer the chambers gave to this question differed according to the facts of each case.

This difference shows that in disputes over the return of shares, the way the relationship was set up (loan, agency, fiduciary transfer or tort) can directly affect the question of jurisdiction. Other decisions on similar disputes are in the Precedent DecisionsTR archive.

🧩 What the Decision Leaves Open

The regional court of appeal examined only the question of jurisdiction. Whether the defendant really had the shares pledged and traded for his own account, on which legal relationship the transfer was based, the scope of the duty to return, the date by reference to which the value of the shares will be determined, and the request for enforcement denial compensation all concern the merits and will be dealt with by the civil court of general jurisdiction. The manipulation allegations directed at the major shareholders in the statement of claim are also not the subject of this case; the decision contains no finding on those allegations.

The principle the decision sets out can be summarised as follows: according to the 7th Civil Chamber of the Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal, a claim based on shares traded on the stock exchange being taken over free of charge through a social media group and not returned is a receivable arising from a tort of a personal nature between the parties, which is not a stock exchange transaction, and therefore falls within the jurisdiction of the civil court of general jurisdiction.

❓ Questions and Answers

Did the chamber decide that the defendant must return the shares?

No. The decision concerns only which court is competent. Whether the shares must be returned or their value paid will be assessed in the proceedings before the civil court of general jurisdiction to which the case will be sent.

Why was the case not treated as commercial although the shares are traded on the exchange?

The chamber did not find it sufficient on its own that the shares are traded on the exchange. It held that the transfer and return claim in dispute is not a stock exchange transaction, that it arises from a tort of a personal nature between the parties, and that the conditions for a commercial case under Article 4 of the TTK were not met.

Why did the Court of Cassation decision relied on by the claimant not change the result?

The decision does not separately discuss the 11th Civil Chamber decision cited by the claimant. The chamber found that the claim arose from a tort and was not based on a stock exchange transaction, and applied the general rule on jurisdiction in Article 2 of the HMK.

What does the material error mentioned in the decision mean?

The first-instance court ruled on lack of jurisdiction in the operative part, but in its reasoning spoke of a negative conflict of jurisdiction. The chamber treated this inconsistency as a material error, did not set the decision aside because it did not affect the outcome, and only criticised it.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page.

The information in this article may not be up to date. This article is for general information only; the summary is compiled from the decision of the 7th Civil Chamber of the Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal published on Bedesten. The assessment rests on a single appeal decision that examined only the question of jurisdiction in a case on the return of shares transferred through a social media group; the allegations in the statement of claim were not examined on the merits by the court, and different results may be reached in cases with different facts. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made by relying on this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Telegram'da Toplanan Hisseler – Sakarya BAM 7. HD 2026/461.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp