Money Sent to a Real Estate Agent for an Investment: Refund Ruling

The case of an investor came before the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation: he trusted a real estate consultant who said that high-margin properties periodically came into his portfolio and that income could be made by buying and selling, sent two separate transfers several years apart, and in the end received neither a title deed nor his money back. The defendant was a person who presented himself as a real estate consultant and argued that part of the payments was commission and part was renovation expense. The Court of Cassation, however, resolved the matter on a single detail: what was written in the description field of the transfers.
In its decision of 15.04.2026, Docket No. (E.) 2025/5207, Decision No. (K.) 2026/2177, the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld unanimously the decision of the 13th Civil Chamber of the Izmir Regional Court of Appeal concerning the return of a total of TL 260,000 sent to the defendant's account for the purpose of a real estate investment.
🏘️ The "let's buy and sell" promise and two transfers
According to the account in the statement of claim, the defendant presented himself to the claimant as a real estate consultant; he said that low-cost, high-margin properties periodically came into his portfolio and that, if the claimant wished to invest, they could work together. The claimant was persuaded that he could earn income by buying and selling properties in this way.
Two payments stand out in the case:
| Date | Amount | Purpose according to the claimant |
|---|---|---|
| 10.10.2013 | TL 60,000 | Described as "deposit", for the purchase of a property |
| 14.09.2015 | TL 200,000 | Following an offer to buy a new property |
| Total | TL 260,000 | No property was transferred |
The claimant requested that the title deed for a property share registered in the defendant's name on a parcel in Muğla be cancelled and registered in his own name; if the property was not registered in the defendant's name, he requested a refund of TL 60,000 with interest from 10.10.2013 and of TL 200,000 with interest from 14.09.2015. The claims were put forward in succession, that is, as alternative claims.
🧾 The commission and renovation defence
The defendant argued that not all of the money sent by the claimant had been sent for the purchase of property. The main points of the defence are as follows:
- The defendant had acted as an intermediary in a real estate purchase made in the name of the claimant's spouse; the commission of TL 500,000 agreed for this had not been paid to him.
- The parties had agreed on the renovation of the purchased property; the expenses the defendant incurred for the renovation had not been fully reimbursed.
- Part of the money sent related to renovation expenses; the defendant had also paid the electricity and water bills of this property.
- Another property had also been registered in the claimant's name, and no commission had been paid for that sale either.
This defence reflects a picture that is common in practice: in cases where money is alleged to have been sent for investment, the other side tries to present the payments as consideration for another legal relationship (intermediation, commission, expenses). The dispute then becomes one of proving the purpose for which the money was sent.
⚖️ First instance, appeal and cassation stages
- Milas 2nd Civil Court of First Instance (E.2021/142, K.2023/200): It upheld the action in part; it ruled that there was no need to decide on the claim for cancellation of the title deed and registration, and upheld the monetary claim, ordering the defendant to pay TL 260,000 with statutory interest from the date of the action.
- Izmir Regional Court of Appeal, 13th Civil Chamber (E.2024/454, K.2025/1597): It partly upheld the defendant's appeal. According to the Chamber, in an action with alternative claims the rejection of one of the claims does not require attorney's fees in favour of the other party unless all of the successive claims are rejected; however, it was wrong to calculate the attorney's fees on the value of the property rather than on the amount of the accepted claim. Stating, on the basis of the expert report and the case file, that the action concerned a monetary claim and was subject to a 10-year limitation period, the Chamber set aside the first-instance decision and upheld the action again with respect to the monetary claim.
- Court of Cassation, 3rd Civil Chamber (E.2025/5207, K.2026/2177): The defendant's counsel argued that an intermediary role had been played in a purchase in the claimant's name in return for the payments and that part of the transfers had been sent for renovation. The Chamber rejected these objections and upheld the Regional Court of Appeal decision under Article 370/1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK).
🔍 The decisive role of the transfer description
The Court of Cassation's reasoning consists of one short but dense sentence: it is stated in the description field of the transfers that the money the claimant sent to the defendant's bank account was sent for the purpose of buying property. Starting from this fact, the Chamber found the defendant's objections on appeal to be unfounded.
The practical side of the decision can be summarised as follows:
- The description is a statement of purpose: A word such as "deposit" or another expression pointing to a property purchase on the transfer or EFT receipt is a written trace showing the purpose for which the money was sent.
- A counter-defence needs proof: The defendant argued that the payments were in return for commission or renovation; but in light of the purpose written in the description, this defence did not change the outcome.
- Refund if the performance does not take place: Where no property was transferred in return for money sent for a property purchase, the courts ordered the amount sent to be returned.
What is striking here is that the Court of Cassation did not separately discuss the personal relationship between the parties, the content of the oral promises or the "profit margin" story. What is decisive is the description attached to the money transfer itself. This approach shows how important payment receipt descriptions can be as evidence in investment relationships without a written contract.
📐 Alternative claims, attorney's fees and limitation
Two procedural points of the decision are at least as instructive as the merits.
Attorney's fees in an action with alternative claims: The claimant first requested cancellation of the title deed and registration and, if this was not possible, a refund of the price. According to the Regional Court of Appeal, in such successive claims the rejection of one or several of them does not require attorney's fees in favour of the other party unless all of the claims are rejected. However, the attorney's fees in favour of the claimant must be calculated on the amount of the accepted claim, not on the value of the property. The defendant's appeal was found justified on this point.
The ten-year limitation period: The first transfer dates from 2013 and the second from 2015; the first-instance file bears a 2021 docket number. The Regional Court of Appeal stated that the action concerned a monetary claim and was subject to a 10-year limitation period. Under Article 146 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, every claim is subject to a ten-year limitation period unless the law provides otherwise. Although the decision contains no detailed calculation on the limitation objection, the application of the general period to restitution claims of a contractual nature is an important yardstick in investment refund actions brought years later.
There is also a detail regarding the start of interest: the claimant requested interest from the dates of the transfers, while the first-instance court applied statutory interest from the date of the action. The Court of Cassation's decision to uphold did not change this outcome.
🧩 Reading it together with similar cases
This decision becomes more meaningful when read together with other decisions on money sent for investment purposes. In the 3rd Civil Chamber decision discussed in the article on the investment defence and a receipt marked as a loanTR, the word "loan" on the receipt prevailed over the argument that the money had been given for investment. In the present decision, the purpose of buying property stated on the receipt prevailed over the argument that the money was in return for commission or expenses. The two decisions show that a description on a receipt can be binding evidence for both sides.
On the criminal law side, the decision discussed in the article on deception in a land investment promiseTR raised the point that a dispute involving a real estate investment promise may be regarded as a civil law dispute. The present case is also an example of a similar relationship being resolved in a civil court through a monetary claim.
The general points that the decision indicates are as follows:
- In investment relationships without a written contract, the description attached to the money transfer may be decisive in proving the purpose.
- The other side's claim of commission, expenses or another receivable does not remove the obligation to return the money unless it is separately proved.
- In an action with alternative claims, attorney's fees are determined on the value of the accepted claim.
- Claims for the return of money are, as a rule, subject to the ten-year period in Article 146 of the Code of Obligations.
❓ Frequently asked questions
Did the Court of Cassation accept the claim for cancellation of the title deed?
Why did the defendant's claim of a commission receivable not change the outcome?
Was the action not considered time-barred for money sent in 2013?
On which point was the defendant found right at the appeal stage?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page, and the other articles in the series are in the Precedent DecisionsTR archive.
The information in this article is provided for general information purposes and may not be up to date; the summary is compiled from the decision of the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upholding the judgment, as published on the Court of Cassation decision search system. The assessment is based on a single case concerning the return of money sent for a real estate investment; cases in which the transfer descriptions, the correspondence between the parties, the payment dates and the other evidence differ may reach different results. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Yatırım Vaadiyle Emlakçıya Para – Yargıtay 3. HD 2025/5207.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Refund of Fund-Sourcing Consultancy Fees: İzmir Appeal 2026/581
- Forex Fraud: Account Holder Liability After the 12th Judicial Package
- SPK Crypto Licence (KVHS) in Türkiye: Is a Platform Authorised?
- Forex Loss Above Margin: Court of Cassation 2025/3733
- Forex Stop-Out and Spread Claim: Court of Cassation 2025/4543
- Telegram Share Transfer Case: Sakarya Court of Appeal 2026/461