Refund of Fund-Sourcing Consultancy Fees: İzmir Appeal 2026/581

Taking up-front payments from companies on the promise of finding a loan or funds abroad is a common model in the finance world. When the paying company does not receive the expected financing, its first move is to ask for every lira back. The case examined by the 17th Civil Chamber of the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal shows clearly why two payments under the same contract met different legal fates: one stayed as a "consultancy fee", while the other was treated as a "limit performance fee" and ordered to be refunded.
In its decision of 05.03.2026, Docket No. E.2022/1887, Decision No. K.2026/581, the 17th Civil Chamber of the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal found correct the dismissal of the main action for refund of the consultancy fee and the acceptance of the joined action for refund of the limit performance fee. It dismissed both parties' appeals on the merits, unanimously.
- The contract, two payments and the expected financing
- The company's claim and the consultant's objections
- The expert panel and the first-instance decision
- The assessment of the regional court of appeal
- Why was the consultancy fee not refunded?
- Why was the limit performance fee refunded?
- Points reflected in practice
- Questions and answers
🌍 The Contract, Two Payments and the Expected Financing
According to the decision, a "Financial Consultancy Service Agreement" was signed on 10.07.2015 between the claimant company and the defendant company. Under the contract, the defendant undertook to provide the claimant with advisory and financial consultancy services, in particular support in procuring funds and obtaining financing. The claimant's obligation was to pay EUR 15,000 + VAT.
The case involves two separate money movements:
| Payment | Date and amount | Nature under the contract |
|---|---|---|
| First payment (main action) | 10.07.2015 – TRY 44,575.50 for EUR 15,000 and an additional TRY 7,912.08; total TRY 52,487.58 | Financial consultancy service fee |
| Second payment (joined action) | 22.09.2015 – TRY 45,075 for USD 15,000 | Limit performance fee; to be refunded if no financial resources are obtained |
The TRY 7,912.08 part of the first payment is an exchange-rate difference according to the claimant and the VAT amount according to the defendant. According to the claimant, the second payment was sent as a guarantee to be deposited in an account to be opened at a bank abroad for the loans to be provided. When the expected financing did not arrive, the claimant demanded refund of the payments by a notice dated 13.12.2016; receiving no result, it filed two separate actions for receivables. Because the same contract provisions would be examined, the action before the İzmir 4th Commercial Court of First Instance was joined with the main action before the İzmir 3rd Commercial Court of First Instance.
📑 The Company's Claim and the Consultant's Objections
The claimant company argued that the defendant never performed the obligations it undertook under the contract, did not even make an attempt in this respect, yet did not refund the amounts received and was unjustly enriched.
The defence of the defendant consultancy company centred on the following points:
- Under Article 7 of the contract, no guarantee of success was given; the contract contains no result-based undertaking.
- The fee section of the contract also states that the consultancy fee is not subject to refund if no investor interest is obtained.
- The services required by the nature of the work were provided, while the claimant failed to meet its duty to supply current information and documents.
- The second payment was transferred to a third party outside the case about 37 minutes later, with the claimant's knowledge and instruction; the defendant is not a party to the contract governing that relationship. The refund claim should therefore be addressed to the person to whom the money was actually sent.
🔍 The Expert Panel and the First-Instance Decision
The first-instance court based its judgment on the report of 26.01.2022 and the supplementary report of 12.05.2022 of a three-member panel of experts in financial advisory, banking transactions and accounts. The court stated that it relied on this report, in which the contract articles were closely examined.
By the decision of the İzmir 3rd Commercial Court of First Instance dated 31.05.2022, Docket No. 2017/763 E., Decision No. 2022/432 K.:
- The main action was dismissed. Article 7 of the contract gives no guarantee of obtaining funds; the amount paid is a fee given to cover expenses, and the defendant made attempts to obtain loans from abroad for the claimant and for companies outside the case.
- The joined action was accepted. The defendant was ordered to pay TRY 45,075 with advance interest running from 22.09.2015. According to the court, this amount was described in the contract as a limit performance fee, Article 7 of the supplementary agreement provides for its refund if no financial resources are obtained, and the parties also accepted that no resources were obtained.
The court held that the later sending of the money to a third person does not release the defendant company from the duty to refund, that the contract was signed between the parties, and that the defendant was unjustly enriched at the claimant's expense as to this amount.
🏛️ The Assessment of the Regional Court of Appeal
Both parties appealed the decision. The claimant argued that the entry of the invoice in the defendant's books does not show that the work was done, and that the absence of a loan guarantee does not justify keeping the fee without performing the service. The defendant argued that the working capital management account (WCMA) credit agreement was not taken into account and that the payment was made indirectly to a third person on the claimant's instruction.
The Chamber set out the general framework on the burden of proof through Article 6 of the Turkish Civil Code (TMK) and Articles 190 and 200 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK). As a rule, each party must prove the facts on which its right rests; a party who fails to meet the burden of proof loses the case. In this context the Chamber also referred to the decision of the General Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation dated 28.09.2021, Docket No. 2017/(19)11-936 E., Decision No. 2021/1090 K.
In conclusion, stating that the decision followed an expert panel report capable of review, the Chamber dismissed both parties' appeals on the merits under Article 353/1-b-1 of the HMK. The route to the Court of Cassation was left open within two weeks of service of the decision.
📉 Why Was the Consultancy Fee Not Refunded?
What was decisive in rejecting the main action is that the contract promised "effort", not a "result". The Chamber found the following findings of the first-instance court correct:
- The defendant company made attempts to obtain a loan,
- It identified the investor,
- It followed up the transactions,
- In this way it performed its obligations under the contract and was not unjustly enriched.
Under Article 77 of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK), for there to be unjust enrichment, the enrichment must lack a valid ground. In this case the consultancy fee was seen as the consideration for a service contract accepted as performed. The fact that financing was in the end not obtained did not by itself lead to a refund in a contract with no guarantee of obtaining funds.
💱 Why Was the Limit Performance Fee Refunded?
For the second payment the picture is different. Here the condition for refund is written in the contract itself: if financial resources cannot be obtained, the amount is to be refunded. As to the joined action, the Chamber stressed that three facts were present together:
- The amount was described in the contract as a limit performance fee.
- The parties agreed that it would be refunded if no financial resources were obtained.
- It is accepted by the parties that no financial resources were obtained, and no refund was made.
The defendant's argument that the money was transferred to a third person within a short time and that this person was the real addressee did not change the result. In the words of the first-instance court, the contract was signed between the parties, and the later sending of the money to another person does not release the defendant company from the duty to refund.
🧭 Points Reflected in Practice
The decision shows the decisive role of the contract text in disputes over refund of payments made on the promise of loans or funds from abroad:
- The name of the payment matters: A "consultancy fee" and a "limit performance fee" in the same contract led to different results.
- Without a guarantee, no result can be expected: In a consultancy contract with no guarantee of obtaining funds, proof of the effort shown may prevent refund of the fee.
- A written refund condition is strong: Where the refund condition is clearly set out in the contract and the condition has occurred, the later transfer of the money to a third person did not release the other side from liability.
- The weight of the expert report: Both the first-instance court and the regional court of appeal relied on the panel report capable of review.
Nowhere in the decision is there a finding of fraud against the consultancy company; the dispute was resolved entirely within the framework of contract and unjust enrichment provisions. For a different dispute based on a consultancy fee in financing and investment processes, see the article on an IPO adviser and a promissory noteTR.
❔ Questions and Answers
If no loan was found, is the consultancy fee automatically refunded?
On what ground will the limit performance fee be paid back?
Did the transfer of the money to a third person change the result?
Is the decision final?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page, and other articles in the series are in the Case LawTR archive.
This article is for general information; the summary is compiled from the decision of the 17th Civil Chamber of the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal published in the Bedesten system. The assessment concerns the refund of two payments under a consultancy contract made to obtain financing from abroad, and the route to the Court of Cassation was left open against the decision; where the contract provisions, refund conditions and evidence on performance of the service differ, the result may change. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, actions and defences made on the basis of this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Fon Temini Ücreti İadesi – İzmir BAM 17. HD 2026/581.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Forex Fraud: Account Holder Liability After the 12th Judicial Package
- SPK Crypto Licence (KVHS) in Türkiye: Is a Platform Authorised?
- Forex Loss Above Margin: Court of Cassation 2025/3733
- Forex Stop-Out and Spread Claim: Court of Cassation 2025/4543
- Telegram Share Transfer Case: Sakarya Court of Appeal 2026/461
- Brokerage Liability for Leveraged Trading Loss: Court of Cassation