TR

Bank Reversed a Deposit Without Consent: Court of Cassation 2023

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 17 November 2026

Bank Reversed a Deposit Without Consent: Court of Cassation 2023

An investor who hands over money with the promise that it will be "put to work on forex and money markets" is often left with only a few promissory notes or a signed sheet of paper. In this case, the closest the investor came to getting the money back was at a bank branch: the person who had collected the money had 150,000 US dollars paid in at the counter into the creditor's account and an account statement was printed; a few minutes later the same amount was withdrawn by a reversal entry without the account holder's consent and returned to that person. The bank argued that the transaction had been "fictitious" from the start and that no real money existed. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) nevertheless upheld a ruling accepting that the bank is liable when money credited to an account is withdrawn without the account holder's consent.

In its decision of 21 March 2023, Docket No. (E.) 2021/6463, Decision No. (K.) 2023/1737, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation rejected the appeals of the defendant bank and of the claimant (filed as a cross-appeal) and unanimously upheld the ruling of the 11th Civil Chamber of the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal, which, following the earlier quashing decision, had granted the claim.

In short: A former bank employee had taken 150,000 USD from an investor to work on forex and money markets, giving three collateral promissory notes of 50,000 USD each in return. When the investor asked for the money back, they met at the branch on 18 June 2015, and 150,000 USD appeared to be deposited into the investor's account; however, the same amount was withdrawn without the investor's instruction and returned to the former employee. The consumer court granted the claim, the regional court of appeal dismissed it for lack of a causal link, and the Court of Cassation quashed that ruling. The regional court's judgment granting the claim, rendered in line with the quashing decision, was upheld in 2023.

🏦 Ten Minutes at the Branch

According to the decision, the claimant was persuaded by a former employee of the defendant bank, who said the money would be put to work on forex and money markets, and handed this person 150,000 US dollars. In return the claimant received three collateral promissory notes of 50,000 USD each. When the claimant asked for the money back, the former employee said to be present on 18 June 2015 at a branch of the bank in İzmir, where he would deposit the 150,000 USD into the claimant's account and take the notes back.

The sequence described in the petition is as follows: the claimant went to the branch, the former employee arrived too, and 150,000 USD was deposited at the counter into the claimant's account. Just as the claimant was about to return the notes, the claimant became suspicious of a conversation between the teller and the former employee, went to the branch manager's office and asked whether the money was in the account. At that point the claimant learned that the money had been withdrawn from the account and returned to the former employee. The person who had collected the money later disappeared and did not pay the amounts on the notes either.

The claimant argued that money deposited into the account could not be withdrawn and transferred to another account without a written or oral instruction, that the bank had breached its duty of care under the banking contract and that it is responsible for its employees' wrongful transactions; the claimant sought collection of 150,000 USD with the highest foreign-currency deposit interest from 18 June 2015.

🧾 The Bank's "Fictitious Transaction" Defence

The defendant bank described the event differently. According to its response, the former employee and the claimant came to the branch without cash and persuaded the teller by saying that money needed to be deposited into the claimant's account and withdrawn "on paper" for a visa application. Trusting the former employee because he had previously worked at the bank, the teller printed an account statement showing that 150,000 USD had been transferred into the claimant's account through the cash desk without physically collecting any money, and then removed the amount from the account by a reversal entry.

The bank also put forward the following points:

  • The claimant approved the outgoing transaction and did not object at the time.
  • No money actually entered the account; the account holder's approval is not needed to cancel the record of money that does not exist.
  • The claimant is trying to obtain from the bank, in this way, the money given to the former employee; opposing the cancellation of a fictitious record amounts to seeking unjust enrichment.

The regional court of appeal's first ruling also noted that the camera footage showed no sign of the former employee entering the branch with cash, that there was no cash deposit receipt, and that a decision not to prosecute had been issued on the complaint that was filed.

⚖️ The Four Stages of the Case

The dispute reached the Court of Cassation twice, and the outcome changed at each stage:

  • İzmir 3rd Consumer Court (6 July 2017, E. 2015/2696, K. 2017/526): Stating that under the Code of Obligations and banking legislation a bank cannot carry out a fictitious transaction, and that the bank was therefore liable both legally and financially, it granted the claim.
  • İzmir Regional Court of Appeal, 11th Civil Chamber (16 July 2019, E. 2017/2003, K. 2019/1125): It accepted the bank's appeal, set aside the first-instance ruling under Article 353/1-b-2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) and dismissed the claim. Reasoning: no real money was credited to the account; the claimant's loss arose from the former employee absconding and not paying the notes; the notes were still in the claimant's hands, so there was no causal link between the fictitious transaction and the loss.
  • Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber (16 March 2021, E. 2019/3549, K. 2021/2493): On the claimant's appeal, it quashed the regional court of appeal's ruling.
  • İzmir Regional Court of Appeal, 11th Civil Chamber (E. 2021/1006, K. 2021/803) and Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber (21 March 2023): The regional court of appeal, following the quashing decision, granted the claim, and the Court of Cassation upheld that ruling after a hearing.

📎 Full text of the decision: The decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 21 March 2023, E. 2021/6463, K. 2023/1737 can be read here as a PDF.

🔐 Who Owns Money Credited to an Account?

The core of the decision is the principle the Chamber set out in its 2021 quashing decision. Because the upholding decision refers back to that quashing decision, its reasoning is worth setting out as it stands. According to the Chamber:

  • The bank's cancellation of the cash payment made by the former employee for the transfer, and of the transfer that followed, does not make the withdrawal of the money from the claimant's account justified or lawful.
  • The bank having been deceived by the former employee, a cash receipt having been issued although no cash was paid, and non-existent money having been transferred, that is, the fictitious nature of the transaction, gives rise to an open credit relationship between the bank and the former employee.
  • The nature of the debt-and-credit relationship between the claimant and the former employee does not remove the bank's liability either.

The regional court of appeal, following the quashing decision, stayed on the same line: it stated that money received into the claimant's account by transfer could not be paid to anyone other than the claimant, and that the bank would be liable to the claimant if it made such a payment.

The practical result of this approach is as follows: whether real money stood behind the transaction at the counter is the bank's own internal matter. If the bank issued a deposit receipt without receiving cash, it must resolve that risk with the person who had the transaction made; as against the account holder, an amount credited to the account is the account holder's claim and cannot be taken back without consent. Although the decision does not rely on a specific statutory provision, this result is consistent with the general law of obligations, under which a bank is liable to its customer for its employees' acts.

🔗 The Causal Link Debate

The regional court of appeal's first ruling rested on an interesting reasoning: had the claimant relied on the fictitious entry and returned the notes to the former employee, the loss would have arisen from the bank's transaction; but since the notes stayed with the claimant, the claimant's loss came from the debtor's flight and not from the bank's transaction.

The Court of Cassation did not adopt this approach. According to the Chamber, the nature of the relationship between the claimant and the former employee does not remove the bank's liability to the account holder. In other words, the fact that the account holder holds notes against another debtor does not push into the background the liability arising from the bank's reversal entry made without consent. The bank may claim from the former employee what it paid, but this does not affect its debt to the account holder.

In its final appeal the defendant bank again argued that no money had actually been deposited and that the burden of proof lay with the claimant; the claimant, by way of cross-appeal, argued that the attorney's fee had been miscalculated. The Chamber rejected both appeals, stating that the decision complied with the quashing decision and that, once the quashing decision was followed, the procedurally vested right arising for the other party could not be reopened.

📌 What It Means for People Who Hand Over Money on an Investment Promise

People who collect money by saying "I will put your money to work on forex or the market" often use bank branches, receipts and account statements to inspire trust at the stage of returning it. This decision matters because it clarifies the legal consequences of such a scene:

  • An amount recorded as a credit to an account cannot be withdrawn back by the bank without the account holder's instruction; the absence of money behind the transaction is the bank's own risk.
  • The bank having been deceived by a former or current employee does not remove its liability to the account holder; the Chamber characterised this as a credit relationship between the bank and the person who had the transaction made.
  • The account holder holding a note against the person who collected the money did not break the causal link in the claim against the bank.
  • The criminal investigation ending in a decision not to prosecute did not prevent the bank's liability in this civil case.

Our site also covers decisions that deal with a bank's liability from other angles: for a return promise made by a bank officer outside the branch, see Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber 2025/6304TR; for a transfer to a closed account, the decision on a transfer to a closed accountTR; and for a payment made on a forged-signature instruction, the article on a forged-signature transfer instructionTR. What sets this decision apart from them is that the money had been credited to the account once, and the reversal entry was made in the account holder's presence, without the account holder's consent.

💬 Frequently Asked Questions

Can a bank take back on its own an amount it thinks was credited to an account by mistake?

In this case the Court of Cassation held that the bank's cancellation of the cash payment and transfer made by the former employee does not make the withdrawal of the money from the claimant's account justified or lawful. In the case at hand there was no written or oral instruction from the account holder for the money to be taken back. Other situations involving the correction of erroneous entries are assessed separately.

Did the fact that no money was actually deposited at the counter not change the outcome?

It did not. According to the Chamber, a receipt being issued although no cash was paid, and non-existent money being transferred, gives rise to an open credit relationship between the bank and the former employee who had the transaction made. This concerns the bank's right of claim against that person; it does not remove its liability to the account holder.

Did the collateral notes held by the claimant affect the bank's liability?

In its first ruling the regional court of appeal had used the fact that the notes stayed with the claimant as grounds for the absence of a causal link. The Court of Cassation quashed that ruling, stating that the nature of the debt-and-credit relationship between the claimant and the former employee does not remove the bank's liability, and the judgment granting the claim that followed the quashing decision was upheld.

Which court heard the case?

The first-instance proceedings took place at the İzmir 3rd Consumer Court; the appeal review was carried out by the 11th Civil Chamber of the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal and the cassation review by the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation. The final cassation review was conducted at a hearing.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page; other decisions on investment disputes and bank liability are on the Precedent DecisionsTR page.

This article is for general information only; its content is compiled from the upholding decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation published in the Court of Cassation decision search system. The decision text does not contain the names of the parties or the employee. The quashing reasoning cited in the decision rests on the bank records, camera review and statements of the parties in the specific case. In a case that looks similar, the outcome may differ depending on how the transaction was carried out, whether the account holder consented, the evidence and the court's assessment. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Fiktif Havalenin Geri Alınması – Yargıtay 11. HD 2023/1737.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp