TR

Forex Profit Deleted: Court of Cassation 2025/6996

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 20 November 2026

Forex Profit Deleted: Court of Cassation 2025/6996

In leveraged trading, the main dispute usually arises over lost money. In this case it was the opposite: an investor who entered trades with a deposit of USD 11,600 made hundreds of thousands of dollars in profit, and a single e-mail received the same morning deleted that profit. The decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) dated 24.11.2025, Docket No. (E.) 2025/1248 and Decision No. (K.) 2025/6996, by majority vote sets the limit of a brokerage firm's power to cancel an executed order.

In short: The claimant stated that on 01.05.2015 he deposited a total of USD 11,600.00 into his account at the defendant brokerage firm and made a profit of USD 183,807.77 from the trades opened the same day; that the profit was deleted by a message saying "your orders from 3:56 onwards, which were not executed at prices in line with the market because of a problem in the system, have been deleted"; and he sought cancellation of the objection to the enforcement proceedings. The first-instance court dismissed the case, finding that the orders had been cancelled by the liquidity provider institution with an "invalid price" explanation and that the brokerage firm's action complied with paragraph 29/(c) of the Capital Markets Board (SPK) Communiqué No. III-37.1. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld the decision by majority vote and finally, under Article 370/1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK). The dissenting opinion takes the view that executed customer orders cannot be cancelled.

📉 How Does the Order Chain Work in a Leveraged Trade?

Article 37 of Capital Markets Law No. 6362, in listing investment services and activities, puts first "receiving and transmitting orders concerning capital markets instruments" and "executing orders in the name and on the account of the customer, or in its own name and on the account of the customer". A brokerage firm is an investment institution that carries out these activities with the permission of the Board.

In leveraged trading this chain often has two links. The customer's order reaches the brokerage firm; to cover the risk of the position it has taken, the firm opens a hedging counter-position with a liquidity provider institution abroad. Although the screen the customer sees shows a single trade, in the background there are two separate, linked legal relationships. This is exactly where the dispute starts: can a cancellation arising in the second link of the chain also remove the customer's order in the first link?

As recalled in the dissenting opinion, leveraged trading came within the duties and powers of the Capital Markets Board on 31.08.2011; the communiqués regulating these activities were published in the Official Gazette on 27.08.2011 and came into force the same day.

⏱️ A Deposit of USD 11,600, a Deleted Profit

The claimant stated that he held an account at the defendant company. On 01.05.2015 he deposited a total of USD 11,600.00 into his account and claimed that he made a profit of USD 183,807.77 from the trades opened the same day. (In the text of the dissenting opinion the same profit is given as USD 188,807.70.)

On the morning of the same day the following message arrived at the claimant's e-mail address: "your orders from 3:56 onwards, which were not executed at prices in line with the market because of a problem in the system, have been deleted." The claimant, arguing that the deletion of the money he had earned was contrary to legislation, started enforcement proceedings to collect the receivable; the proceedings were stayed on the defendant's objection and an action for cancellation of the objection was brought.

In its defence the defendant brokerage firm sought dismissal of the case, stating that leverage was used in these trades, that 80 per cent of customers lost all their money, whereas the claimant had profited, that only the claimant's trades had been cancelled, that the trades were carried out in a Polish currency and that 208 trades were made, which it said was contrary to the ordinary course of life.

⚖️ The Assessment of the Court and the Chamber

The case had previously gone through a stage of quashing. At the end of the retrial held in compliance with the quashing decision, the first-instance court made the following findings: the leveraged trades in dispute were sent by the defendant brokerage firm, for hedging purposes, to the liquidity provider with which it had a written contract. The liquidity provider institution stated that these trades had reached its own system at a price that did not exist in the market, showed its log records, and cancelled them with an "invalid price" explanation. The brokerage firm then cancelled the claimant's orders.

The court dismissed the case on the ground that both the order cancellation and the cancellation notice given to the customer complied with paragraph 29/(c) and the following provisions of the Capital Markets Board Communiqué No. III-37.1.

The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, in view of the documents in the file, the fact that the judgment had been given in line with the quashing decision followed by the first-instance court under Article 373/4 of the HMK, and the absence of any error in the assessment of the evidence, did not find any of the claimant's appeal objections well founded; it upheld the decision finally and by majority vote on 24.11.2025, under Article 370/1 of the HMK. Following the appeal review held at a hearing, it ordered the hearing attorney's fee of TRY 40,000.00 to be collected from the claimant and given to the defendant.

📎 Full text of the decision: The decision has been verified by docket and decision number in the Case Law Search system of the Presidency of the Court of Cassation.

✍️ The Dissenting Opinion: "An Executed Order Cannot Be Cancelled"

The most instructive part of the decision is the dissenting opinion. The members who wrote it clearly defined the point on which they differed from the majority: whether it was in accordance with legislation for the defendant brokerage firm to delete the profit that the claimant, who carried out leveraged trades, had made as a result of those trades.

According to the dissenting opinion, the facts not in dispute in the case are these: a framework agreement on leveraged trades and additional protocols were signed between the parties; the claimant carried out leveraged trades under this agreement; he made a profit as a result of 208 trades; and the defendant deleted the profit by cancelling these trades.

The dissenting opinion stressed that, under Article 29 of Communiqué No. III-37.1, Article 10 of Communiqué Series: V No: 125 and Articles 8 and 11 of the agreement between the parties, executed customer orders cannot be cancelled or changed by brokerage firms. The expert reports in the file also state that executed customer orders cannot be cancelled and that there was no reason justifying the cancellation of the trades made in line with the claimant's orders. The dissenting opinion further takes the view that the complaint made by the defendant to the Board and the review carried out by the Board do not bind the claimant.

📚 The Three Exceptions to Order Cancellation

Article 10, titled "Order Cancellation", of the Communiqué on the Principles Regarding Leveraged Trading Transactions and the Institutions That May Carry Out Them (Series: V, No: 125), whose text is quoted word for word in the dissenting opinion, sets out the rule and its exceptions as follows:

  • General rule: Executed customer orders cannot be cancelled or changed by brokerage firms,
  • Paragraph (a): cancellation is possible, on objection, for the purpose of making an improvement for the customer,
  • Paragraph (b): cancellation is possible for the purpose of remedying customer losses arising from a technical problem on the trading platform,
  • Paragraph (c): if a hedging position that the institution has taken with another institution in relation to a customer order is cancelled by the counterparty, or its price is changed, the order may be cancelled or the price changed,
  • Procedural obligation: if action is taken under paragraph (b), it is applied for all customers adversely affected by the technical problem; for a cancellation or price change under paragraph (c), the customers concerned are given notice, together with the reasons, by the fastest means of communication.

As can be seen, paragraph (c) allows the brokerage firm to pass on to the customer a cancellation that occurred at the institution where it covers its own risk. The first-instance decision upheld by the majority placed the case under this paragraph; the dissenting opinion concluded, in view of the contract provisions and the expert findings, that there was no power of cancellation.

🛡️ The Exclusion-of-Liability Agreement and TBK 115/3

The second legal basis relied on by the dissenting opinion is the third paragraph of Article 115 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 (TBK). Under this provision, if a service, profession or art requiring expertise can be carried out only with permission granted by law or by the competent authorities, an advance agreement that the debtor will not be liable for slight fault is absolutely void. The first paragraph of the same article already treats an agreement excluding liability for gross fault as absolutely void.

Since brokerage activity is an activity carried out with the permission of the Board and requires expertise, broad exclusion-of-liability clauses placed in framework agreements are limited by this provision. The dissenting opinion also assessed that, given the settled decisions the Chamber has given in favour of banks and brokerage firms in disputes of this kind, a decision against the claimant, who this time stands on the other side, is not in line with the principles of equality and legal certainty.

🆕 What the Decision Means for Investors

The decision shows where proof sits in leveraged trading disputes. The elements that were decisive in the first-instance court's acceptance are the existence of a written contract with the liquidity provider, the showing that the position was sent for hedging purposes, the cancellation being documented by log records, and a cancellation notice having been given to the customer. Because the Communiqué separately makes notice mandatory for a cancellation under paragraph (c), this last element is not a matter of form but of substance.

On the other hand, the dissenting opinion recorded that a different conclusion could be reached from the same facts and that cancelling an executed order is an exceptional power. That the decision was given by majority vote shows that the issue has not yet become unanimous in case law. For a decision in which the obligations of a brokerage firm are discussed from another angle, the review of investor liability in a VİOP margin shortfall (VİOP: Borsa Istanbul derivatives market)TR can be read.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Other decisions in the series appear in the Precedent DecisionsTR section.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Can a brokerage firm cancel an executed order?

Under Article 10 of Communiqué Series: V, No: 125, as quoted in the dissenting opinion, the general rule is that executed customer orders cannot be cancelled or changed. The article provides three exceptions: an improvement in favour of the customer, a technical problem on the trading platform, and the cancellation, or change of the price, by the counterparty of a hedging position taken by the institution with another institution.

What does cancellation on the ground of an invalid price mean?

In the case covered by the decision, the trades were sent by the brokerage firm to the liquidity provider institution for hedging purposes; that institution stated that the trades reached its system at a price that did not exist in the market, showed its log records, and cancelled them. The first-instance court assessed this situation under paragraph 29/(c) of Communiqué No. III-37.1.

Is notice to the customer mandatory?

Under the second paragraph of Article 10 of the Communiqué, for an order cancellation made on account of the cancellation or price change of a hedging position, the customers concerned are given notice, together with the reasons, by the fastest means of communication. Where the application is made on the ground of a technical problem, the action is carried out for all customers adversely affected by the problem.

Is the exclusion-of-liability clause in a framework agreement unlimited?

The third paragraph of Article 115 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, cited in the dissenting opinion, treats as absolutely void an advance agreement that the debtor will not be liable for slight fault in services requiring expertise that are carried out with permission of the law or a competent authority. For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy.

The information in this article is for general information purposes; the summary of the decision is taken from the published text of the relevant Court of Cassation decision, and each case is assessed on its own evidence. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, complaints and defences made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Forex Kazancının Silinmesi – Yargıtay 11. HD 2025/6996.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp