TR

Crypto Token Screen Value Is Not a Claim: Istanbul Court 2026

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 20 November 2026

Crypto Token Screen Value Is Not a Claim: Istanbul Court 2026

The amount shown next to a token balance in a crypto platform wallet often gives the investor the feeling that "my money is sitting right here". The price rises, the investor decides to sell, and at that very moment the order book stops and the figure on the screen suddenly loses its meaning. The question at this point is a simple one: is the amount shown on the screen a monetary claim that can be demanded from the platform through enforcement proceedings? In an action to annul an objection, brought by an investor who had bought a sports club's utility token against the crypto platform, the Istanbul 7th Commercial Court of First Instance answered this question in the negative.

By its decision of 29.09.2026, Docket No. (E.) 2025/356, Decision No. (K.) 2026/653, the Istanbul 7th Commercial Court of First Instance dismissed the request to annul the objection to a TRY 175,728.53 enforcement proceeding without a prior court judgment, which the investor had started on the basis of the market value of the token balance in his account. This is a first-instance decision, and an appeal to the Regional Court of Appeal remains open as of the date of the judgment.

In short: The investor deposited a total of TRY 101,000 with a crypto asset platform, first bought 4,664.04 USDT with it, and then 4,664,040 units of a sports club's utility token. He started the proceeding claiming that the token value had risen to TRY 175,645.88, that trading was halted when he wanted to sell, and that his balance was reset to zero. The expert examination found that the balance was still held in the account, that there was no specific rejected sale or transfer request, and that the claimed amount could not be verified as a realisable market value. The court dismissed the case, holding that the platform had no duty to warrant the market value and that neither the loss nor the causal link had been proven.

🪙 The Investor's Claim: A Rising Token, a Stalled Order Book

According to the text of the decision, the claimant opened a digital wallet on the crypto asset trading platform operated by the defendant joint-stock company and deposited a total of TRY 101,000 into his account. On 12.05.2023 he bought 4,664.04 USDT in three separate transactions, and on 17.05.2023 he used all of that USDT to buy a utility token issued in the name of a sports club. His account also held 100 units of another token credited as part of a campaign.

According to the claimant, as the market moved, the value of the tokens reached TRY 175,645.88 and the value of the other 100 tokens reached TRY 82.65. He alleged that when he wanted to convert this holding into Turkish lira and withdraw it, trading was stopped, the platform first rejected his withdrawal request and then reset the balance in the wallet to zero.

The claimant then started an enforcement proceeding without a prior court judgment for TRY 175,728.53, the total of the two values. The platform objected to the proceeding on 18.01.2024, and on 30.12.2024 the claimant filed an action seeking annulment of the objection, enforcement denial compensation and an interim injunction. The case was notified to the sports club that issued the token; the club stated that it was not a party to the proceeding and had no contract with the claimant.

🔍 Two Expert Reports, Two Different Focuses

The first report, dated 07.12.2025, focused mainly on why the market collapsed. According to the report, the issuer failed to transfer the full 400,000 USDT worth of crypto assets it was required to provide for market depth, which narrowed the order book and caused abnormal price volatility. The report stated that there were signs the platform had used its power to halt trading late after the breach, that fault could be shared between the issuer and the platform, but that the issuer should bear the larger share. The same report also expressed the view that the investor should have been aware of the high risk in the crypto market and could therefore be partly responsible.

The supplementary report, dated 15.06.2026, addressed the claim that was the subject of the enforcement proceeding directly. The following findings were made in this report:

  • A balance of 4,664,040 tokens is still recorded in the claimant's account; there is no record showing that the balance was reset to zero.
  • The platform stated that this balance could be transferred over the relevant network to a wallet designated by the claimant.
  • No specific sale or transfer request submitted by the claimant to the system and rejected by the platform could be identified.
  • The amount claimed in the proceeding could not be verified as a firm market value at which the tokens could be sold or converted into cash.
  • The exact date of the delisting process and the records of notification to the claimant could not be identified in the case file.
  • Law No. 7518, which places crypto asset service providers under SPK supervision, cannot be applied retroactively as a source of liability in this dispute.

🤝 Who Had a Contract with Whom?

The first step in the court's assessment was to separate the relationships between the parties. The decision identified three separate legal relationships:

The first is the relationship between the claimant and the platform. The court characterised it as a mixed-type platform user (service) agreement, covering account opening, balance record-keeping, order transmission, the trading screen, and wallet and transfer infrastructure.

The second is the token sale agreement between the claimant and the sports club. In this agreement the token was defined as a "utility token" and was stated to be non-refundable and non-cancellable. According to the court, the counterparty to this agreement is the club, not the platform.

The third is the listing agreement dated 30.03.2023 and its amendment protocol, which regulate the listing of the token, trading pairs, market depth, liquidity and lock-up processes. This agreement was made between the issuer and the platform; the claimant is not a party to it.

This distinction matters, because the liquidity obligation and market-making emphasised in the first expert report belong to the listing relationship, to which the claimant is not a party. What an investor can ask of the platform is limited to the scope of his own user agreement.

📋 What Does the Platform's Obligation Cover?

The court grouped the obligations of the platform operator towards the user under three headings:

  • Recording the assets in the user's account correctly,
  • Enabling the user to dispose of those assets (transfer, withdrawal and, where an open market exists, order transmission),
  • Informing the user about significant developments concerning the order book.

According to the decision, the contracts cannot be read as imposing on the platform an obligation to buy the user's assets from its own funds at a particular price or to warrant the market value of an asset. The court stated that a crypto asset losing value or liquidity is, as a rule, a market risk borne by the investor who acquired the asset, and pointed out that the sale agreement the claimant approved electronically also accepted that the tokens might not be sellable for lack of demand.

The duty to inform is also on the court's list. However, the decision made no separate finding of fault on whether the information was provided; it based the dismissal on the failure to prove the loss and the causal link.

📎 Full text of the decision: The decision of the Istanbul 7th Commercial Court of First Instance dated 29.09.2026, E.2025/356, K.2026/653, can be read as a PDF here.

💱 Why Was the Screen Value Not Treated as a Claim?

The case is an action to annul an objection based on Article 67 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK). The court recalled that in such an action it is examined whether the claim existed on the date of the proceeding, its amount and whether it had fallen due, and that under Article 6 of the Turkish Civil Code (TMK) and Article 190 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) the burden of proof lies on the claimant creditor. For compensation arising from breach of contract, three elements must be proven together: conduct in breach of the contract, an actual loss and an adequate causal link.

The court concluded that none of these elements had been proven, for the following reasons:

  • No rejected request: The case file contains no specific sale, cash-out, withdrawal or transfer request that the claimant submitted to the platform and that was rejected. The platform stated that there was no transfer lock on the balance; the claimant could not prove otherwise.
  • Ownership continues: The claimant retains ownership of the tokens and their record in the account.
  • The value is theoretical: Because the order book was closed, even the current market value of the token could not be determined. The court described the claimed amount as "a theoretical value shown on the screen whose realisation could not be proven".
  • Nature of the token: According to the expert, unlike freely traded crypto assets, this token is an in-platform record with the character of a private sale and a locked vesting entitlement.
  • Campaign token: As for the other 100 tokens, it was found that the claimant had paid nothing for them and that the record was in the nature of a campaign credit.
  • Type of claim: The TRY 101,000 deposited was converted first into USDT and then into the token on the claimant's own orders, and the counter-value was recorded in his account. The action is based not on the refund of the amount deposited but on the alleged value of the asset.

In conclusion, the court held that the claimant had not proven that, as of the date of the proceeding, he had a due, cash claim of TRY 175,728.53 against the platform and dismissed the case; since the conditions were not met, it did not award bad-faith compensation against the claimant. Attorney's fees of TRY 45,000.00 were awarded in favour of the defendant.

🧭 What Does It Mean for Crypto Investors?

The decision shows that, in crypto asset disputes, the way the claim is framed can directly affect the outcome. The points the court emphasised can be summarised as follows:

  • A token balance sitting in an account does not automatically turn into a monetary claim against the platform; the screen value and an actual loss are not the same thing.
  • When the platform's liability is discussed, the scope of the user agreement is determined first; obligations under the listing relationship between the issuer and the platform may not give the user a direct right to a claim.
  • Records showing that a sale or transfer request was submitted to the system and rejected can be decisive in the discussion of the causal link.
  • For transactions made before Law No. 7518, the expert report took the view that the new regulation cannot be applied retroactively as a source of liability.

This decision does not mean that a platform will never be liable. The first expert report discussed fault regarding the timing of the suspension of trading and the information given to the investor; the court, however, did not build its result on that discussion because, in this case, the amount and maturity of the loss were not proven. For examples where platform liability is approached from other angles in account security breaches, see the article on phishing loss on a crypto platform; for a dispute between the commercial parties of a similar club token project, see the article on unfair competition in a fan token agreementTR; and for a case about an identity verification block on a platform account, see the article on a KYC block and the commercial court.

💬 Frequently Asked Questions

Is a crypto platform responsible for the value of the tokens in an account?

In this decision, the court stated that the contracts could not be read as showing that the platform had undertaken to warrant the market value of the asset or to buy it from the user at a particular price. Loss of value and loss of liquidity were treated, as a rule, as a market risk borne by the investor.

How was the claim that the balance was reset assessed?

According to the balance, transaction and ledger records examined by the expert panel, the claimant's 4,664,040 tokens were still recorded in the account. Because no record showed that the balance had been reset or removed from the account, this claim was not accepted.

Was the sports club that issued the token held liable in the case?

The club took part not as a party to the case but as a notified third party. Because the case and the proceeding were directed only at the platform operator, no ruling was made on the club's liability. The court only found that the counterparty to the token sale agreement is the club, not the platform.

Is this decision final?

The decision was given by a court of first instance, the Istanbul 7th Commercial Court of First Instance, and the judgment states that an appeal to the Regional Court of Appeal is open within two weeks of notification. A different result may emerge at the Regional Court of Appeal stage.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are available on the contact page, and other decisions in the field of crypto assets and capital markets can be found on the Precedent DecisionsTR page.

This article is for general information purposes only; its content has been compiled from the first-instance decision of the Istanbul 7th Commercial Court of First Instance published through Bedesten (mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr). The party names in the decision text are anonymised at the source, and the name of the club that issued the token is also concealed in the PDF. The decision is open to appeal review. In a dispute that looks similar, the outcome may differ depending on the contract terms, the platform records, the requests the investor submitted, the transaction date and the court's assessment. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Tokenın Ekran Değeri Alacak mı? – İstanbul 7. ATM 2026/653.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp