Forex Case: Non-Prosecution Is Not Enough, Court of Cassation 2021/873

Many investors who lose money on leveraged trading first go to the prosecutor's office about the company employee who opened the account or steered the trades. When the investigation ends with a decision of non-prosecution, the company in the compensation claim filed for the same loss often relies on that decision: "No offence was found against the employee, so the company has no fault either." In a forex case heard in Antalya, the Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber held that this approach is not enough on its own, and that the civil court must itself examine the criminal investigation file and the telephone call recordings.
By its decision of 4 February 2021, Docket No. (E.) 2020/1357, Decision No. (K.) 2021/873, the Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber unanimously reversed the Regional Court of Appeal decision that had rejected on the merits the appeal against the first-instance judgment dismissing the investor's compensation claim, and sent the case back to the first-instance court.
📉 How was the account opened and how did the loss grow?
According to the text of the decision, the claimant met an employee of the defendant company at a time when he needed money. In the claimant's account, he began forex trading with the company on the employee's false and misleading guidance, and after the first losses he took out loans from various banks and credit cards to increase the amount invested in his account, but the loss kept growing.
The claimant argued that the contracts he signed remotely on behalf of the company on 13.11.2014 and 19.11.2015 contained unfair terms, that his total loss reached USD 24,529, and that the company was responsible for it. The case was filed as an indeterminate claim under Article 107 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) for 150,000.00 TL for the time being; the claim was raised to a total of 300,000.00 TL in the reply to the defence.
The claimant also filed a criminal complaint with the prosecutor's office against the company employee. As stated in the text of the decision, this investigation ended with a decision of non-prosecution.
🛡️ The three defences the company relied on
The defendant company stated that it is an institution subject to the Capital Markets Law and operating under SPK supervision, and asked for the case to be dismissed. The main lines of the defence are as follows:
- Risk information was given: The transactions are leveraged; positions of up to one hundred times the money deposited may be opened. The claimant was warned about the risks, a risk disclosure was made and a contract was drawn up.
- The loss resulted from the investor's own choices: The loss is the result of wrong investment decisions.
- There is no official finding: The investigation into the employee ended in non-prosecution; the SPK has imposed no administrative sanction concerning the claimant; and no misleading advertising was made.
The third of these defences is the core of the decision. The company used the outcome of the criminal investigation in the civil case as if it were evidence in its own favour.
🏛️ The consumer court and the appeal stage
The case was heard by the Antalya 3rd Consumer Court. By its decision of 28.11.2018, Docket No. (E.) 2017/312, Decision No. (K.) 2018/563, the court dismissed the claim. In summary, its reasoning was as follows:
- The account relationship began in line with the signed risk disclosure form.
- The leverage ratio and margin calls were carried out in accordance with the relevant provisions of the SPK communiqué.
- It could not be established that the company had made advertisements or announcements contrary to the SPK communiqué.
- The claimant also has cases of the same kind pending before other consumer courts in Antalya.
- Although he had no experience, knowledge or education, the claimant traded on leverage with the aim of high profit; since a defective or incomplete service on the company's part was not proven, he must bear the result of the transactions.
The Antalya Regional Court of Appeal 11th Civil Chamber, by its decision of 18.12.2019, Docket No. (E.) 2019/607, Decision No. (K.) 2019/2400, rejected the claimant's appeal on the merits. The case then reached the Court of Cassation on the claimant's further appeal.
⚖️ Why did the Court of Cassation reverse?
The Chamber structured its decision in two paragraphs. In the first paragraph, it rejected the appeal objections other than the ground of reversal below. In other words, the first-instance court's conclusion on the leverage ratio and margin calls was found to be correct.
In the second paragraph, the Chamber stated that the dispute concerned a claim arising from a leveraged trading (forex) contract and made the following findings:
- Law No. 6111 gave the Capital Markets Board the authority to regulate leveraged trading transactions.
- Article 19/a of the "Communiqué on the Principles Regarding Investment Services and Activities and Ancillary Services", in force on 14.11.2014 when the claimant opened the account, provides that investment firms accept and carry out client orders within the framework of the order execution policy, the framework agreement, the obligation to execute orders on the most favourable terms for the client, and the duty of care and loyalty.
- Although the reasoning on leverage and margin is correct, the investor's main allegation concerns the employee's guidance, and that allegation must be examined separately.
According to the Chamber, what the court should have done was to obtain the criminal investigation file that ended in non-prosecution; to examine the contract between the parties, the forex trading instructions and the telephone call recordings between the forex officials and the claimant; and to obtain a supplementary or new report from an expert panel that would assess as a whole whether the employee acted contrary to the regulations, first under the SPK communiqué and then under the general provisions. A dismissal issued without these steps was characterised as incomplete examination and investigation; the Regional Court of Appeal decision was reversed under Article 373/1 of the HMK and the case was sent back to the first-instance court.
🔎 What does a non-prosecution decision mean in a civil case?
The most striking aspect of the decision is that the outcome of the criminal investigation does not by itself settle the civil case. Although it knew of the non-prosecution decision, the Court of Cassation asked for the criminal file to be examined after being "called in" (obtained from the prosecutor's office). This means that the non-prosecution decision is treated not as a result, but as a source of evidence through the statements, documents and records it contains.
This approach is also consistent with the general principle in Article 74 of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK), which regulates the relationship with criminal law. Under Article 74 TBK, when deciding on the fault of the person causing the damage, the civil judge is not bound by the criminal law provisions on liability or by an acquittal from the criminal judge; nor is the civil judge bound by the criminal judge's decision on the assessment of fault and the determination of the damage. The Court of Cassation did not expressly cite Article 74 TBK in this decision; however, it is clear that a non-prosecution decision issued at the prosecutor's stage carries no stronger binding force than an acquittal.
A criminal investigation and a compensation claim answer different questions. The prosecutor examines whether the employee's act fits an offence definition. The civil court examines whether the investment firm complied with its duty of care and loyalty arising from the contract and the SPK regulations. Even if an act is not an offence, it may still amount to guidance contrary to the regulations or to careless service.
📂 The evidence ordered to be examined
The reversal also shows which documents matter in disputes over leveraged trading. The Chamber pointed to four groups of evidence:
- The criminal investigation file: The complaint petition, the statements taken and the documents collected in the investigation.
- The contract between the parties: The framework agreement and the risk disclosure form; the claimant argued that these contracts contained unfair terms.
- Forex trading instructions: On whose instruction and through which channel the positions were opened.
- Telephone call recordings: The conversations between the forex officials and the claimant; recordings that may be direct proof of the allegation of guidance.
The expert panel was asked to assess this evidence "as a whole". In other words, calculating the leverage ratio or the timing of margin calls alone is not enough; the employee's relationship with the claimant, the information given and whose will the transactions were carried out on must also be examined.
On our site, the question of separating guided transactions is covered through a decision of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal in the article on guided transactions in forex, and the formal requirement of the risk disclosure form in the article on formal violations of the risk disclosure formTR. For a decision of the Borsa Istanbul derivatives market (VİOP) on proving guidance by a brokerage firm, see the article on proving brokerage guidanceTR.
The limits of the decision should also be noted. The Court of Cassation did not decide that the claimant was right; it only found that the allegation had not been investigated as required. If the examination after the reversal shows that the employee did not act contrary to the regulations, the claim may be dismissed again. The claimant's other appeal objections, outside the ground of reversal, were rejected in the first paragraph.
💬 Frequently asked questions
If a non-prosecution decision was issued about the employee, is a forex compensation claim lost?
If the leverage ratio complies with the regulations, does the company's liability disappear?
Which regulation was applied in this case?
Does the reversal mean the investor's loss will be paid?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page; other decisions on leveraged trading and capital markets disputes are on the Precedent DecisionsTR page.
This article is for general information only; its content is compiled from the reversal decision of the Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber published in the Court of Cassation decision search system. The text of the decision does not contain the names of the parties or the employee. The SPK regulation applied in the decision is the legislation in force in 2014, when the account was opened; later changes in the regulations may lead to different results. In a case that looks similar, the outcome may differ depending on the contract terms, the trading records, the telephone calls and the expert examination. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made on the basis of this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Forex’te Takipsizlik Yetmez – Yargıtay 11. HD 2021/873.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- IBAN–Name Mismatch: Bank Liability, İzmir Appeal Court 2026
- Bank Liable for Employee's High-Return Promise: Court of Cassation
- Stock Tips Site Fundraising: Court of Cassation 2024/3604
- Crypto Gains and Legality in Tax: Council of State 2024/7487
- Fake Investment Ads: Platform Liability, Germany and Türkiye
- Bank Liability for Forex Pool Account: Court of Cassation Ruling