Bank Liable for Employee's High-Return Promise: Court of Cassation

When a long-known bank clerk at the counter promises high income through a “special pool”, who is the person handing over their savings considered to have entrusted the money to: the employee or the bank? In such cases banks often argue that the money never entered the bank's records, that the customer received no account passbook or receipt, and that the customer therefore trusted the employee personally. As time passes, a second defence also comes up: limitation.
In its decision of 16.10.2025, Docket No. E.2025/2228, Decision No. K.2025/6304, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld unanimously a first-instance judgment that held a bank fully at fault for money taken by an employee under a high-return promise and then misappropriated, and that rejected the limitation defence because of the extended limitation period under criminal law.
💼 The promise, the documents and the money handed over
According to the claim petition reproduced in the decision, one of the defendants is an employee of the other defendant, the bank. This person took money from the claimant by saying that he would earn high income if he had accounts opened on the banks' “special pool site”. The branch's account movements later drew the attention of the bank's management and an inspector's review was carried out. The facts put forward in the petition are as follows:
- the employee transferred money without the consent of the bank's customers;
- the employee issued a forged account passbook;
- criminal proceedings were conducted against the employee;
- the bank was alleged to be liable because it did not show the necessary care and control.
The case was initially filed for 1,000,000,000.00 old Turkish lira. With a petition of rectification dated 16.02.2018, the claimant's lawyer stated the loss as TRY 22,069.00 and asked for this amount to be collected from the bank with the highest deposit interest, taking purchasing power into account.
The first-instance judgment specifically referred to two documents on investment instruments in the case: a Treasury bill with a maturity date of 26.10.1999 and a document dated 02.07.2002 showing 1,597 units of a type B liquid fund. As will be seen below, these dates were the starting point of the limitation debate.
🏦 The bank's two defences
The lawyer of the defendant bank asked for the case to be dismissed and based the defence, in summary, on the following points:
- Trust was placed in the employee personally: The claimant handed the money to the bank employee and received no bank account passbook or receipt in return; this shows that the claimant trusted the employee himself, not the bank.
- The claimant is grossly at fault: There is no record belonging to the claimant in the bank's records, no contract made with the bank and no money entry at the bank.
The employee did not submit a statement of defence. The court's assessment also shows that the limitation defence was examined; the long time between the years in which the money was paid and the date of rectification made this debate unavoidable.
⏳ Limitation: why the criminal law period?
The court accepted that the maturity date of the Treasury bill was in 1999 and the liquid fund document was dated 2002, but it did not tie the start of limitation to those dates. The reasoning in the decision follows these steps:
- the criminal court showed the date of the offence as 2003 in the heading of its reasoned judgment and in its finality note;
- the bank employee's irregular and criminal acts continued in 2003 as well;
- according to the expert report in the criminal case, the transaction dates of the payments made to the claimant by transfers from another depositor's account fall between June and September 2003;
- limitation must be determined not under the general periods of Code of Obligations No. 818 but under the provisions of criminal law;
- for both dates, the 15-year extended limitation period had not passed as of the date of rectification.
With this finding the limitation defence was rejected. The decision shows that, in cases where money taken under an investment promise was misappropriated, the date of the offence in the criminal case and whether the acts were continuing may be decisive in calculating limitation. For how the same subject appears in criminal proceedings, see the article limitation in bank embezzlementTR.
⚖️ The bank's full fault and liability for auxiliary persons
In determining compensation, the court also discussed whether the claimant bore contributory fault and did not accept the bank's defence. The main lines of the reasoning are as follows:
- a bank must show the necessary attention and care in all its transactions; this obligation also covers the selection of the people it employs;
- the employee committed similar irregularities concerning the claimant and many other people, the bank stayed silent about this and did not supervise the employee's transactions;
- the bank did not act actively to prevent the loss; it is therefore fully at fault;
- banks carry out their contractual relations with depositors through the people they employ; there is no tort relationship between the depositor and the employee of the kind in Article 55 of Code No. 818;
- the bank is therefore liable under Article 100 of the Code, which provides no proof of exoneration; Articles 99/2 and 100/last of the same Code remove exoneration even for slight fault.
Thus the bank's defence that “no passbook or receipt was issued” was not seen as affecting the result as a fact showing the claimant's fault. What was decisive was that the money was handed to a bank officer under the appearance of a banking service, and the bank's duty to supervise its officer. The amount of the loss was set at TRY 22,069.00 on the basis of the finalised criminal case and the expert report.
In conclusion, the court held that the case against the employee was deemed not filed, accepted the case against the bank, and ordered TRY 22,069.00 to be collected from the bank with legal interest running from the date of filing, rejecting the claim for the excess. For another form of bank employee embezzlement, the signing of blank slips, the article bank employee embezzlement and blank slipsTR can be read together with this decision.
🔍 Court of Cassation review and outcome
Only the lawyer of the defendant bank appealed the judgment. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation characterised the case as “a compensation case based on the allegation that money given to the defendant bank's employee does not appear in the bank's records and was misappropriated by the defendant bank employee”.
The Chamber stated that the judgment was made in line with the order of reversal followed by the court and that there was no error in the assessment of evidence; it did not find any of the bank lawyer's appeal objections well founded and upheld the decision unanimously on 16.10.2025. Because the first-instance court gave its decision by following the reversal, the Chamber's short reasoning was limited to checking whether the framework drawn by the earlier reversal order had been applied; the assessments on the merits are found in the first-instance judgment.
📘 Comparison with current legislation
Because the events took place in the period of Code of Obligations No. 818, the court relied on the provisions of that Code. In Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, the counterparts of the same institutions are as follows:
| Subject | Relied on in the decision | Code No. 6098 (TBK) |
|---|---|---|
| Limitation in tort and criminal limitation | 15-year extended limitation period determined under criminal law provisions | TBK Art. 72/1: two-year and ten-year periods; where compensation arises from an act for which criminal laws provide a longer limitation period, that period applies. |
| Liability for the acts of auxiliary persons | Code No. 818, Art. 100 | TBK Art. 116: the debtor must make good the loss that auxiliary persons cause to the other party while carrying out the work. |
| Exclusion-of-liability agreement | Code No. 818, Art. 99/2 and Art. 100/last | TBK Art. 116/3: in services requiring expertise and carried out under a permit, an agreement removing liability for auxiliary persons is absolutely void. |
The provision in TBK Art. 116/3 clearly shows that, for banks whose activity is subject to a statutory permit, liability for auxiliary persons cannot be excluded by contract. The reasoning on which the decision rests therefore finds a counterpart under the new Code as well.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Can the bank still be held liable if the money never entered its records?
If the Treasury bill matured in 1999, why was the case not time-barred?
Was a separate ruling made about the employee?
How was the amount of the loss determined?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are available on the contact page, and the other articles in the series can be found in the Precedent DecisionsTR archive.
This article is for general information only; the summary is compiled from the affirming judgment published in the Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber's decision search system and from the first-instance court's reasoning reported in it. The assessment rests on a specific case that took place in the period of Code of Obligations No. 818, in which the criminal court had set the date of the offence and the decision was made following a reversal; the result may differ in cases where the event dates, the outcome of the criminal case and the parties' degree of fault are different. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made using this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Banka Çalışanının Getiri Vaadi – Yargıtay 11. HD 2025/6304.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Stock Tips Site Fundraising: Court of Cassation 2024/3604
- Crypto Gains and Legality in Tax: Council of State 2024/7487
- Fake Investment Ads: Platform Liability, Germany and Türkiye
- Bank Liability for Forex Pool Account: Court of Cassation Ruling
- Lawsuit Against a Dissolved Company: Istanbul Appeal Court 2025/513
- Bank Reversed a Deposit Without Consent: Court of Cassation 2023