Stock Tips Site Fundraising: Court of Cassation 2024/3604

A website publishing stock market commentary collects money from its readers with the promise that "your investment will be multiplied in a short time"; the money does not go into any investment but to the people running the site. This picture concerns not only capital markets legislation but also the fraud provisions of the Turkish Penal Code (TCK). In a case brought on such an allegation, the 7th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation answered three separate questions of procedure and substance together: can the Capital Markets Board (SPK) and the Treasury appeal a judgment in a fraud case, what happens to a capital markets offence for which the limitation period has expired, and which court has jurisdiction over this kind of online fundraising?
By its decision of 01.04.2024, Docket No. (E.) 2021/15789, Decision No. (K.) 2024/3604, the 7th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation rejected the appeals of the SPK and the Treasury, reversed the judgments on the offence of violating the repealed Capital Markets Law No. 2499 and ruled that the public prosecution was time-barred, and reversed the acquittals on the fraud charge on grounds of jurisdiction.
- The allegation: from a commentary site to an investment promise
- The judgments of the court of first instance
- Why could the SPK and the Treasury not appeal?
- Limitation period for a capital markets offence
- Jurisdiction in fraud: criminal court of first instance or High Criminal Court?
- Why it matters for investment fraud victims
- Questions and answers
💻 The Allegation: From a Commentary Site to an Investment Promise
According to the text of the decision, the public prosecution was brought on the allegation that the defendants gave stock market commentary on a website with a "www.....net" address, collected money from the people they got in touch with this way by promising to multiply their investments in a short time, and used that money themselves. The name of the site is anonymised in the decision.
Two different legal assessments are intertwined in this scheme. The first concerns collecting money from investors without authorisation and carrying out capital markets activity; in the case this aspect was treated as the offence of violating Capital Markets Law No. 2499, which was in force on the date of the events. The second is that people are deceived by the promise of high returns and made to part with their assets; this aspect concerns the offence of fraud. The case also contains a charge of laundering assets derived from an offence.
📄 The Judgments of the Court of First Instance
The criminal court of first instance that tried the case (E. 2014/701, K. 2016/550) reached a mixed result:
- One of the defendants was convicted of violating Law No. 2499, and two defendants were acquitted of the same offence.
- All defendants were acquitted of fraud.
- All defendants were acquitted of laundering assets derived from an offence.
The judgments were appealed by the representatives of the complainants who paid money, the representatives of the SPK and of the Treasury as complainant, and the convicted defendant. The written opinion of the prosecutor recommended upholding the judgments, but the 7th Criminal Chamber largely did not follow that opinion.
📎 The full text of the decision is available at the link below.
🏛️ Why Could the SPK and the Treasury Not Appeal?
The first important finding of the decision concerns who holds the right of appeal. Article 260/1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK) gives the right to apply to a higher court against judgments to the public prosecutor, the suspect or defendant, and persons who have become or may become intervening parties. The right to join the case belongs to those harmed by the offence.
Within this framework, the 7th Criminal Chamber drew the following distinction:
- Capital Markets Board: It was not directly harmed by the offences of fraud and laundering and therefore has no standing to appeal the judgments given on those offences.
- Treasury: It was not directly harmed by any of the offences of violating Law No. 2499, laundering and fraud; as it is not an intervening party, it has no standing to appeal.
For this reason the Chamber rejected the appeals of the representatives of the SPK and the Treasury under Article 298/1 of the CMK, contrary to the prosecutor's written opinion. As a result, the acquittals on the laundering charge fell outside the Court of Cassation's review, because they had not been properly appealed by a party with standing.
This finding does not limit the SPK's role in capital markets offences; in offences within its own field the Board is an important part of the criminal complaint and follow-up mechanism. The decision only shows that the loss suffered by investors is the investors' own loss rather than the Board's, and that in general offences such as fraud and laundering the Board is not counted as "directly harmed by the offence".
⏳ Limitation Period for a Capital Markets Offence
When it examined the appeals of the complainant's representative against the acquittal of two defendants and of the defendant against the conviction, the Chamber found a more fundamental problem in the case: the limitation period for the prosecution.
The decision states that, taking into account the type and upper limit of the penalty to be determined for the acts under trial, an 8-year ordinary limitation period under Article 66/1-e of the TCK and a 12-year extraordinary limitation period under Article 67/4 of the TCK apply. Once it was established that the 12-year extraordinary period had expired between the date of the offence and the date of the appeal review, the judgments were reversed.
Because no retrial was needed, the Chamber did not send the case back to the court of first instance; using the power given by Article 322/1 of the former Code of Criminal Procedure No. 1412, which applied on the date of the judgment, it decided itself, under Article 223/8 of the CMK, that the public prosecution was dropped. This outcome applies both to the two defendants who were acquitted and to the convicted defendant; the conviction fell away and the proceedings on the capital markets offence came to an end.
🔎 Jurisdiction in Fraud: Criminal Court of First Instance or High Criminal Court?
The most striking part of the decision for investment fraud concerns the acquittals on the fraud charge. Before going into the merits of the acquittal, the Court of Cassation examined whether the court had jurisdiction.
According to the Chamber, given the allegation that the defendants gave stock market commentary on a website, collected money from the people they got in touch with this way by promising to multiply their investments, the conduct is capable of constituting the offence regulated in Article 158/1-f of the TCK. This sub-paragraph treats fraud committed by using information systems, banks or credit institutions as a tool as a qualified form and provides for imprisonment from three to ten years; under sub-paragraph (f) the lower limit of imprisonment cannot be less than four years, and the judicial fine cannot be less than twice the benefit obtained from the offence.
The Chamber stated that the power to assess and discuss the evidence on whether the conduct constitutes qualified fraud, which carries a heavier sanction, belongs to the High Criminal Court, which has superior jurisdiction. The criminal court of first instance should have declared that it lacked jurisdiction; by continuing the trial and giving a judgment it acted unlawfully, and the acquittals were reversed on this ground.
The reversal does not mean that the defendants are guilty. The Court of Cassation said only that an investment promise run over the internet carries the possibility of qualified fraud and that the authority to assess this possibility is the High Criminal Court. The assessment of the merits will be made when the case is taken up again by the competent court.
🧩 Why It Matters for Investment Fraud Victims
The decision is notable for dealing with an early example of an investment fraud pattern that later became very widespread. A large part of the promises made today through social media accounts, messaging groups and fake trading platforms rests on a relationship of trust built online, as in this case.
- As to the route through the courts: People who paid money are in the position of those directly harmed by the offence; in a fraud charge the right to apply to a higher court as intervening parties belongs to them. The appeals of the SPK or the Treasury were not accepted for these offences.
- As to characterisation: According to the Court of Cassation, contact made through a website and an investment promise raise the possibility of Article 158/1-f of the TCK; in that case the competent court is the High Criminal Court.
- As to time: In offences against capital markets legislation, a trial that drags on can end with the case being dropped because of limitation. In this case the proceedings for the Law No. 2499 offence ended for that reason.
Other decisions in the same field also show how similar patterns are assessed in criminal proceedings. In this context one can read the decision no. 2026/1074 of the 11th Criminal ChamberTR on collecting money under the name of stock market investment with a promise of high monthly profit, and the reversal in the interest of the lawTR concerning a crypto investment promise run through a messaging group.
Meanwhile, Capital Markets Law No. 6362 replaced Law No. 2499 and regulates unauthorised capital markets activity as a separate offence. In a case being handled today, the provisions to be applied to the capital markets offence will therefore be determined by the date of the events and by a comparison of which law is more favourable.
❔ Questions and Answers
Can the SPK appeal a judgment in a case where investors were defrauded?
Why was the Treasury's appeal rejected?
What happened to the sentence of the convicted defendant?
Why was the acquittal on the fraud charge reversed?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page; other decisions on investment fraud and capital markets offences are listed on the Precedent DecisionsTR page.
This article is for general information only; its content is compiled from the 7th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation's decision, partly rejecting, partly reversing and dropping the case, published on the Court of Cassation's decision search system. The names of the defendants, the intervening parties and the website do not appear in the text of the decision. The reversal on the fraud charge rests on jurisdiction and contains no finding on the defendants' guilt. In a case that looks similar, the outcome may differ according to the date of the events, the law to be applied, the state of the evidence and the court's assessment. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made on the basis of this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Borsa Yorumuyla Para Toplama – Yargıtay 7. CD 2024/3604.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Crypto Gains and Legality in Tax: Council of State 2024/7487
- Fake Investment Ads: Platform Liability, Germany and Türkiye
- Bank Liability for Forex Pool Account: Court of Cassation Ruling
- Lawsuit Against a Dissolved Company: Istanbul Appeal Court 2025/513
- Bank Reversed a Deposit Without Consent: Court of Cassation 2023
- Recovery Scams: Warning Signs of Fake Fund Recovery Offers