TR

Fraud Claim and Attachment: Ankara Appeal Court Ruling 2026/563

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 19 November 2026

Fraud Claim and Attachment: Ankara Appeal Court Ruling 2026/563

Cases in which investors living abroad put their savings into a company in Türkiye as partners, only to find the company accounts empty a few years later, are no longer rare. When this picture emerges, the victims' first thought is to trace the money and freeze the other side's assets until the case ends. However, the legal system does not treat the statement "I was defrauded" as a ground for attachment on its own. Which interim protection route is chosen, and how far the claim is documented, directly determines the result.

In its decision of 30.04.2026, Docket No. E.2026/484, Decision No. K.2026/563, the 21st Civil Chamber of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal assessed requests for an interim injunction and a precautionary attachment based on the allegation that an investment of about EUR 17 million had been drained by the managing partner of a company. The Chamber stated that an interim injunction cannot be placed on the whole of the other party's assets for a money claim, and that a precautionary attachment requires the existence of the claim to be shown to an approximate degree of proof, a threshold not met in a case where the allegations require a full trial; it dismissed the appeal on the merits. Under Article 362/1-f of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK), the decision is final.

In short: Four dentists living in Germany took over 20% shares each in a limited company established in Türkiye and became partners alongside a fifth partner. According to the applicants, the partner who was the company's sole authorised representative moved a total of EUR 16,974,429.03 sent for investment into his own account and into another company wholly owned by him, and kept the partners waiting with false tables and a forged bank receipt. For EUR 20 million, the applicants first asked for an interim injunction without security and, failing that, a precautionary attachment. The Ankara 5th Commercial Court of First Instance rejected both requests on 13.02.2026; the Regional Court of Appeal found this interim decision correct.

🏢 An investment made through a partnership and the alleged draining of funds

According to the account in the decision, the applicants are four dentists living in Germany. They met the other side through the introduction of a long-standing colleague, and the other side presented himself as a successful entrepreneur. In the end, the applicants took over 20% shares each in a limited company operating in the medical and construction sectors, while the other side became the fifth partner with a 20% share and the company's sole authorised representative.

The applicants' allegations are summarised as follows:

  • A total of EUR 16,974,429.03 was paid for investment, by bank transfer and in cash; it is alleged that this money was moved, without commercial records or a general assembly resolution, into the manager's personal account or into another company wholly owned by him.
  • The partners were shown tables indicating that investments, together with profit, had reached about EUR 47 million in total and that the company's value had risen above EUR 56 million.
  • A bank receipt showing a transfer of EUR 4,783,126.45 into one partner's account turned out to be forged.
  • It was claimed that part of the money was moved to digital accounts and used to buy vehicles and gold.

According to the decision, in his statement to the law enforcement authorities the other side did not deny receiving the money; he argued, however, that it had been transferred to his own company as a "business advance", that there was a debit-credit relationship between the two companies and that the payments were made with the knowledge of the other partners. A criminal investigation into the matter is under way in Ankara, and a separate case for the removal of the company manager and the appointment of a trustee is also being heard.

🛡️ The interim protection requested: injunction first, then attachment

The applicants made a two-stage request, for the time being over EUR 20 million, to cover a principal claim of EUR 17 million and interest. The first request was for an interim injunction without security over the other side's bank accounts in Türkiye and abroad, movable and immovable property, company shares and receivables held by third parties. The second request was, should the injunction not be accepted, for a precautionary attachment over the same assets and the prevention of their transfer. It was also requested that the application be decided on the file, on the ground that the other side might be preparing to flee.

📂 The assessment of the court of first instance

The Ankara 5th Commercial Court of First Instance assessed together the documents attached to the application, the expert reports obtained in the criminal investigation and the suspect's statement. According to the court, the other side had a defence that "there is a debt relationship between the two companies and the payments were made as a business advance and with the knowledge of the partners"; the applicants had not been able to disprove this defence to an approximate degree of proof. Because the existence of a contractual relationship requires a trial, no injunction was granted that would in effect settle the merits of the dispute.

As for the precautionary attachment, the court accepted that conclusive proof is not required, but stated that the existence of the claim also required a trial, that there could therefore be no question of a due claim, and that sufficient evidence of preparations to hide assets had not been submitted. Both requests were rejected, and the decision was appealed.

⚖️ Why was the interim injunction refused for a money claim?

The Regional Court of Appeal began by recalling the conditions for an interim injunction in Article 389/1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK): if there is a concern that, because of a change in the existing situation, obtaining the right would become considerably harder or impossible, or that serious harm would arise from delay, an injunction may be granted "concerning the subject of the dispute". The points emphasised by the Chamber are as follows:

  • The subject of an injunction is the thing that is disputed between the parties; assets that are not the subject of the proceedings cannot be the subject of an injunction either.
  • No interim injunction is ordered in matters that fall within the field of other interim legal protections. For money claims, apart from special and exceptional situations, the main interim protection is the precautionary attachment.
  • As a rule, an interim injunction applies in cases concerning things other than money (rights, movable and immovable property), whereas a precautionary attachment applies to money and security claims.
  • Under Article 390/3 of the HMK, the party requesting an injunction must show to an approximate degree of proof that it is right on the merits of the case; because of the possibility of being found wrong, security is as a rule also taken.

In this case, the injunction requested concerned the other side's personal bank accounts and all of his movable and immovable assets. The Chamber stated that these assets were not the subject of the dispute and that an interim injunction can be placed only on things that are the subject of the case; referring to the decision of the General Assembly of the Civil Chambers dated 20.12.2013, Docket No. 2013/21-1791, Decision No. 2013/1676, and to decisions to the same effect of the 19th and 14th Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, it found the first-instance court's refusal of the injunction request consistent with procedure and law.

📎 Text of the decision: The full text of the Regional Court of Appeal decision has been compiled as published on Bedesten / mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr; the names of the parties and companies are anonymised in the source, and one personal name in the text and the doctrinal references in the reasoning have been removed.

🔒 Precautionary attachment and a claim that "requires a trial"

On precautionary attachment, the Chamber stated that under Article 257/1 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK), the creditor of a money debt that is not secured by a pledge and has fallen due may have the debtor's assets provisionally attached, and that under Article 258/1 of the İİK the creditor must show the court evidence that persuades it about the claim and, where necessary, the grounds for attachment. The standard sought here is not full and conclusive proof but approximate proof.

The notable part of the decision is its explanation on when a claim falls due. The Chamber accepted that, according to the Court of Cassation's settled practice, a loss arising from a wrongful act falls due on the date the act took place. In other words, an allegation of fraud is as a rule not caught by the "claim not yet due" obstacle. The request was nevertheless rejected, because according to the Chamber:

  • the applicants alleged that the money transferred to the company had been moved to the manager's personal account and to his own company, so that they had been harmed, that is, directly injured;
  • but in view of the other side's defence of a business advance and an inter-company debt relationship, these allegations require a trial;
  • for this reason, the existence of a due claim could not be shown even to an approximate degree of proof;
  • and sufficient evidence was not submitted that the other side was preparing to hide or remove assets, or to flee himself, in order to prevent collection of the claim.

In the end, no contradiction with procedure or law was found in the first-instance court's interim decision of 13.02.2026, and the appeal was dismissed on the merits under Article 353/1-b-1 of the HMK. The decision was given unanimously and is final.

🧭 What the decision means for investment disputes

This decision clearly shows that the size of the alleged loss does not by itself produce an interim protection order. Some findings that can be read between the lines of the decision are summarised as follows:

  • Choosing the right route: The Chamber did not, as a rule, accept a request for an interim injunction over the other side's general assets for a money claim; the interim protection tool in this field is the precautionary attachment.
  • The effect of the partnership scheme: When money is sent to a company in which one is a partner, it becomes arguable whether the loss is the partners' direct loss or the company's loss, and on what legal relationship the money was transferred. The Chamber treated the existence of this debate as an element that prevents approximate proof.
  • The weight of the other side's defence: The acceptance that the money was received was not regarded as sufficient on its own; the "business advance" defence led to the conclusion that the claim requires a trial.
  • Risk of removal: According to the Chamber, allegations of hiding or removing assets were not supported by sufficient evidence.

The limits of the decision should also be noted. This is an appeal review of an interim decision; the Chamber made no assessment of whether the applicants' allegation of being defrauded is true or false, and said only that the conditions for interim protection had not been met at this stage. The criminal investigation and the case on the removal of the company manager continue separately; the outcome on the merits will take shape according to the evidence gathered in those proceedings.

Similar problems also arise in capital markets and crypto asset disputes. Our article on a promissory note obtained by force after a crypto lossTR, which examines a precautionary attachment based on that note, and our article on a MASAK block on a crypto account, which addresses a precautionary attachment over an account under a MASAK block, can be read together with this decision.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Did the Chamber decide that the applicants were not defrauded?

No. The decision concerns an appeal against an interim decision rejecting the requests for an interim injunction and a precautionary attachment. The Chamber said only that the conditions for interim protection had not been met at this stage and that the allegations require a trial. The fraud allegation will be assessed separately in the criminal investigation, and the claim in the case to be heard.

Why did the difference between an interim injunction and a precautionary attachment matter in this decision?

According to the Chamber, an interim injunction is granted concerning the thing that is the subject of the dispute and as a rule applies to things other than money. For money claims, the main interim protection is the precautionary attachment. For this reason the applicants' request for an injunction over all the other side's assets, which were not the subject of the dispute, was not accepted.

Why was a precautionary attachment not granted even though a tort claim was treated as due?

The Chamber accepted that a loss arising from a wrongful act falls due on the date of the act. However, a precautionary attachment also requires the existence of the claim to be shown to an approximate degree of proof. Because, in view of the other side's defence that the money was transferred as a business advance and with the partners' knowledge, the existence of the claim requires a trial, this threshold was held not to have been crossed.

Can this decision be taken to the Court of Cassation?

No. The decision was given as final under Article 362/1-f of the HMK; appeal decisions of this kind on an interim injunction and a precautionary attachment cannot be taken to the Court of Cassation. However, because the case on the merits and the criminal investigation are continuing, the assessment of a new interim protection request with different evidence in future is a separate matter.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are available on the contact page, and the other articles in the series can be found in the Precedent DecisionsTR archive.

This article is for general information only. The summary is compiled from the final appeal decision of the 21st Civil Chamber of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal, published on Bedesten / mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr, concerning an interim decision on requests for an interim injunction and a precautionary attachment. The assessment is based on a specific case involving an investment made through a partnership and a defence of a business advance by the other side; the result may differ in cases where the evidence and the nature of the legal relationship are different. The information in this article may not be up to date, and Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made using this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Dolandırıcılık İddiasında Haciz – Ankara BAM 21. HD 2026/563.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp