Crypto Exchange Collapse: Suing the State, Council of State 2021

One evening at 8 pm, a "maintenance work" notice appears on the screen. The next day users cannot access their accounts; shortly afterwards it emerges that the company's founder has left the country with the "cold wallet" in which investors' crypto assets were stored. The first question of the investors who suffered losses is usually where the money is. The second is discussed less: do the public bodies that were expected to supervise this platform while it operated bear any responsibility, and in which court is such a claim brought? After a collapse of this kind in the spring of 2021, the 13th Chamber of the Council of State (Danıştay) decided the procedural side of the second question in a compensation case brought by three investors.
In its decision of 06.10.2021, Docket No. (E.) 2021/4252, Decision No. (K.) 2021/3189, the 13th Chamber of the Council of State held that a full remedy action filed against two ministries and a board, alleging service fault, cannot be heard by the Council of State as a first-instance court, rejected the case on the ground of jurisdiction and unanimously decided to send the case file to the Ankara Administrative Court.
- A "maintenance work" notice and the vanished wallet
- Whom did the investors sue, and for what?
- Why an administrative court, not the Council of State?
- What does a service fault claim mean?
- The 2024 regulation: crypto platforms now need SPK authorisation
- What the decision does not say
- Questions and answers
🧊 A "maintenance work" notice and the vanished wallet
The decision briefly summarises the events on the basis of the claimants' account. According to it, a technology joint-stock company offers crypto-asset trading services to investors through its website. On 20.04.2021 at 8 pm, the company announced that maintenance work would be carried out on the site. The same day it emerged that the company's founder had left the country with the device known as a "cold wallet", which held the investors' crypto assets; the fate of the crypto assets in the company's possession remained unknown.
A cold wallet is a method of keeping the private keys of crypto assets on a device that is not connected to the internet. Platforms may keep a significant part of users' assets this way for security. For the user, however, this means that the assets are in practice tied to a device under the platform's control. In the text of the decision the names of the company and the website are anonymised; for this reason the platform is not named in this article either.
🏛️ Whom did the investors sue, and for what?
The case was brought not against the company or its founder but against the state. The three claimants named two ministries and a board as defendants. In the text of the decision the names of these authorities are also anonymised. In summary, the claimants' argument is as follows:
- The company operated as a crypto-asset service provider.
- The defendant authorities did not use the supervisory and oversight powers that legislation gave them in respect of this company.
- The investors suffered losses because of this omission.
- A compensation application was first made to the defendant authorities, and the applications were rejected.
Reserving their right to claim more, the claimants requested for the time being TRY 1,500.00 in compensation, together with statutory interest running from the date of the application to the authorities. Small claims of this kind may be seen where the amount of the loss is not yet final or where the aim is first to establish liability. In administrative justice, this type of case, which aims to compensate damage arising from an administrative act or action, is called a full remedy action.
⚖️ Why an administrative court, not the Council of State?
The 13th Chamber of the Council of State examined the petition under Article 14 of the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577 (İYUK) as part of the preliminary examination and first assessed the question of jurisdiction. The rapporteur judge was also of the opinion that the case should be rejected on jurisdiction. The decision rests on the following provisions of law:
- Article 24 of the Council of State Law No. 2575: lists, in a limited way, the cases to be heard by the Council of State as a first-instance court.
- Articles 1 and 5 of Law No. 2576: administrative courts are courts of "general jurisdiction"; they hear cases other than those within the jurisdiction of tax courts and those to be resolved by the Council of State at first instance.
- Articles 14/3-a and 15/1-a of İYUK: the petition is examined as to jurisdiction and venue; where a case concerning a matter within administrative jurisdiction is filed in a court without jurisdiction, it is rejected on the ground of jurisdiction and the file is sent to the competent court.
- Article 36 of İYUK: in full remedy actions other than those arising from administrative contracts, the competent court is the court authorised to resolve the administrative dispute that caused the loss.
According to the Chamber, the claimants seek compensation for their losses on the ground that the defendant authorities did not perform the oversight and supervision duties assigned by legislation to protect investors' rights and interests. The acts taken by the authorities in relation to the company's activities, or omitted to be taken, are cited as the basis of the loss. Since such a full remedy action is not among the disputes that the Council of State hears as a first-instance court under Law No. 2575, it must be heard by the Ankara Administrative Court, which is competent to resolve the dispute that caused the loss.
As a result, the Chamber rejected the case on the ground of jurisdiction without examining the merits and sent the file to the Ankara Administrative Court. Although the case was rejected in the decision, this rejection does not mean that the claim was found unfounded; it only determines in which court the case will be heard.
🔍 What does a service fault claim mean?
In administrative law, service fault means holding the administration liable for losses arising because a public service did not function, functioned late or functioned badly. A failure to perform a supervisory and oversight duty may also be put forward within this scope. However, for such liability to be accepted, the following questions are generally important:
- At the date of the event, was there a clear regulation giving the authority concerned the power and duty to supervise that activity?
- Did the authority fail to perform this duty at all, or to perform it properly?
- Is there an adequate causal link between the loss and the authority's omission, or did the loss arise mainly from the act of a third party?
- Can the loss be proven concretely?
The decision of the 13th Chamber of the Council of State does not answer any of these questions; the case was not examined on the merits. For how the merits are assessed in compensation cases based on the supervisory duty of the Capital Markets Board, see our articles on the SPK's service fault in a forex loss and on a compensation case against the SPK over prospectus approvalTR.
🆕 The 2024 regulation: crypto platforms now need SPK authorisation
The event that is the subject of the decision took place at a time when there was no specific statutory regulation on crypto-asset service providers. This picture changed in 2024. With Law No. 7518 of 26.06.2024, provisions on crypto-asset service providers were added to Capital Markets Law No. 6362. Under provisional Article 11 added to the law:
- Crypto-asset service providers operating on the date the law entered into force must, within one month, apply to the Board and declare either that they will apply for an operating licence by meeting the conditions in the secondary legislation to be issued under Articles 35/B and 35/C, or that they will decide to liquidate within three months.
- Articles 99/A and 109/A of the law may be applied to those who do not meet these obligations.
- In institutions that go into liquidation or fail to apply in time, failing to carry out customers' transfer requests constitutes the offence of operating as an unauthorised crypto-asset service provider under Article 109/A.
- The activities of crypto-asset service providers resident abroad towards persons resident in Türkiye are to be ended within three months.
This regulation makes the question of which authority is competent to supervise crypto platforms clearer. Whether it would apply to an event dated 2021 is, however, a separate question; the liability of the administration is, as a rule, assessed under the legislation in force on the date of the event. For other administrative regulations on crypto assets, our article on the ban on payments with cryptoTR can also be read.
🚧 What the decision does not say
Because it is a short procedural decision, some limits should be kept in mind when reading it:
- The decision does not say that the defendant authorities were at fault or not at fault.
- The decision does not discuss which legislation the platform's activity was subject to.
- The decision does not examine whether the case was filed in time or whether the requirement of applying to the administration first was properly met.
- How the file ended at the Ankara Administrative Court is not the subject of this decision.
The decision's main contribution is to make clear that claims of inadequate supervision, brought against the state by investors who suffered losses from the collapse of a crypto platform, are heard not at the Council of State but at the administrative court of general jurisdiction.
❓ Questions and answers
Does a rejection on jurisdiction mean the case was lost?
Why did the claimants ask for only TRY 1,500?
Are the platform and the authorities named in the decision?
Which rules would apply if a similar collapse happened today?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page; other decisions on crypto assets, capital markets and administrative law can be found on the Precedent DecisionsTR page.
This article is for general information; its content is compiled from the jurisdictional rejection decision of the 13th Chamber of the Council of State published on mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr. In the text of the decision the names of the claimants, the company, the website and the defendant authorities are anonymised. The decision only determines the competent court and contains no assessment of the liability of the authorities. In a dispute that appears similar, the outcome may differ according to the date of the event, the applicable legislation, the time limits for applying to the administration and filing a case, and the court's assessment. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, cases and defences made on the basis of this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Kripto Borsası İçin Devlete Dava – Danıştay 13. D 2021/3189.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Forex Case: Non-Prosecution Is Not Enough, Court of Cassation 2021/873
- IBAN–Name Mismatch: Bank Liability, İzmir Appeal Court 2026
- Bank Liable for Employee's High-Return Promise: Court of Cassation
- Stock Tips Site Fundraising: Court of Cassation 2024/3604
- Crypto Gains and Legality in Tax: Council of State 2024/7487
- Fake Investment Ads: Platform Liability, Germany and Türkiye