Crypto Platform Sues User: Consumer Court Jurisdiction Ruling

Disputes between crypto asset platforms and their users are mostly discussed through lawsuits in which the user claims money from the platform. This time the picture is reversed: the platform went to court with a receivable claim, alleging that one of its users manipulated the system to create a balance with no backing and transferred that balance out. However, the dispute became stuck, before reaching the merits, on the question of which court should hear the case.
By its decision dated 14.07.2026, Docket No. E.2026/757, Decision No. K.2026/957, the 21st Civil Chamber of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal held that the consumer court has jurisdiction in an action to annul an objection brought by a crypto asset trading platform against a user who had no commercial or professional purpose, and dismissed on the merits the appeal against the commercial court's procedural dismissal for lack of jurisdiction.
- The platform's claim: a balance with no backing
- Two separate rounds of proceedings for the same receivable
- The reasoning of the regional court of appeal
- Why was the user treated as a consumer?
- The position of crypto platforms after Law No. 7518
- Procedural consequences of a decision on lack of jurisdiction
- Frequently asked questions
🪙 The platform's claim: a balance with no backing
According to the text of the decision, the defendant user opened an account with the claimant platform on 28.10.2021. In its petition, the platform made the following allegations:
- That the user manipulated the platform's system and created a fictitious (non-existent) balance in the account without depositing any Turkish lira or crypto assets,
- That this balance was transferred to the account of the other defendant on another platform,
- That an examination showed the transferred assets had been converted to cash and moved to a bank account,
- That as of 11.11.2021 transfers totalling TL 341,730.00 and 0.54775 units of crypto assets had been made.
The platform demanded payment by notarised notice and, receiving no result, started non-judgment enforcement proceedings. The defendants objected to the proceedings on 11.01.2022. In the petition, the claimant requested payment of the Turkish lira equivalent of the 0.54775 units of crypto assets on the actual payment date, the application of the principle of balancing justice if that equivalent falls below the value on the date of the proceedings, default interest and an enforcement denial compensation of at least 20%. According to the decision, the defendants' counsel only asked in the reply petition for the case to be dismissed.
🔁 Two separate rounds of proceedings for the same receivable
The decision also shows that the dispute made a long journey between courts. According to the process described in the petition:
- First round: After the objection, the platform first filed an action to annul the objection before the Ankara 45th Civil Court of First Instance; the case continued before the Ankara 10th Consumer Court.
- The mediation obstacle: By decision of the 36th Civil Chamber of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal, Docket No. 2024/1024 E., Decision No. 2024/1580 K., the case was dismissed on procedural grounds because of the absence of the mediation precondition to suit.
- Second round: After notification on 24.11.2025 of the enforcement office's decision to stop the proceedings, the platform applied to a mediator again and, following the failure-to-agree record dated 03.02.2026, filed a case on 23.02.2026, this time before the Ankara 8th Commercial Court of First Instance.
- Lack of jurisdiction: On 09.03.2026 (E.2026/158, K.2026/164), the commercial court of first instance dismissed the case on procedural grounds for lack of a precondition to suit, under Articles 114 and 115/2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK).
In its reasoning, the first-instance court also referred to the earlier regional court of appeal decision on the same dispute, stating that the relationship between the parties arose from a consumer transaction and that both defendants had consumer status.
⚖️ The reasoning of the regional court of appeal
In its appeal petition, the platform argued that it was a company providing services under the Capital Markets Law, that the case was commercial in nature and that the commercial court of first instance was the competent court. The 21st Civil Chamber of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal did not accept this objection. The Chamber's assessment consists of the following steps:
- Nature of the dispute: The case is a request to annul an objection to proceedings started to collect a receivable arising from a commission contract for crypto asset trading.
- Jurisdiction concerns public order: Under Article 1 of the HMK, jurisdiction is regulated by law and is considered by the court of its own motion at every stage of the proceedings.
- Consumer and consumer transaction: The definitions in Article 3 of Law No. 6502 cover every kind of contract and legal transaction between a consumer and a party acting for commercial purposes.
- A special regulation does not change jurisdiction: Under Article 83/2 of the Law, the fact that a transaction is regulated in another law does not prevent it from being treated as a consumer transaction or the jurisdiction provisions from applying. According to the Chamber, it also makes no difference that the dispute arises from a contract regarded as a commercial case under Articles 4 and 5 of the Turkish Commercial Code (TTK).
- Result: Because the defendant did not act for commercial or professional purposes, the defendant is in the position of a consumer; under Article 73/1 of Law No. 6502, the consumer court has jurisdiction.
On the point that the rule of jurisdiction is considered of the court's own motion, the Chamber also cited 2016 decisions of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation as precedent. The appeal was dismissed on the merits under Article 353/1-b.1 of the HMK; the decision was given unanimously, with the route of appeal on points of law open.
👤 Why was the user treated as a consumer?
The decisive point of the decision is the purpose for which the defendant user acted. Article 3/k of Law No. 6502 defines a consumer as "a natural or legal person acting for purposes that are not commercial or professional". The Chamber characterised the relationship between the platform and the user as a commission contract for crypto asset trading and accepted that the user had no commercial or professional purpose in this relationship.
A striking point is that the platform's receivable claim rests less on a breach of contract than on the allegation that the user abused the system. Even so, the Chamber saw the source of the dispute as the user relationship between the parties and took this relationship as the basis for jurisdiction. In other words, it was not the nature of the alleged act but the contractual position of the parties that was decisive.
In practice, consumer status in investment products is not always assessed in the same way; in particular, there are decisions that treat the commercial court as competent in leveraged or high-risk investment transactions on the ground that the investor acts for profit. This decision is an example of the approach that treats the consumer court as competent in the relationship between a crypto asset trading platform and an individual user. The jurisdiction assessment is made separately in each case, taking into account the nature of the transaction and the purpose of the user.
🆕 The position of crypto platforms after Law No. 7518
In its appeal petition the platform stressed that it operated under the Capital Markets Law. Indeed, Law No. 7518 of 26.06.2024 added definitions of crypto asset, wallet, platform and crypto asset service provider to Article 3 of Capital Markets Law No. 6362. Accordingly, a platform means an institution that carries out one or more of crypto asset trading, initial sale or distribution, clearing, transfer and the custody these require.
However, the Chamber's reasoning is that the fact a transaction is regulated in another law does not remove its character as a consumer transaction. Article 83/2 of Law No. 6502 expressly provides for this result. Therefore, in the decision, the platform being subject to capital markets legislation was not seen as a factor that changes the competent court in a dispute with an individual user.
On the other hand, under Article 73/A of Law No. 6502, in disputes heard before consumer courts, applying to a mediator before filing the case is a precondition to suit. In this case too, the platform's first action was dismissed for the absence of the mediation precondition. This shows that consumer disputes have a separate procedural discipline both for jurisdiction and for preconditions to suit.
🧭 Procedural consequences of a decision on lack of jurisdiction
A decision on lack of jurisdiction contains no assessment of whether the receivable claim is well founded; it only determines in which court the case will be heard. The aspects of the decision that carry over into practice can be summarised as follows:
- The merits were not examined: Matters such as the allegation that a fictitious balance was created, the amount of loss, or the date on which the crypto asset's value would be taken as the basis were not discussed in this decision.
- Sending the case file: Under Article 20 of the HMK, after a decision on lack of jurisdiction, if a legal remedy has been used, the case is deemed not filed unless a request to send the case file to the competent court is made within two weeks of notification of the decision rejecting the application.
- Route of appeal: The decision was given with the route of appeal on points of law open within two weeks of notification of the reasoned decision; whether it has become final cannot be understood from the text of the decision.
- Risk of lost time: In this case, proceedings started over a 2021 transaction are still at the stage of a jurisdiction debate in 2026.
For other procedural questions concerning crypto platforms, the series includes the decision on an arbitration clause at a crypto exchangeTR and the decision on the competent court for the refund of a crypto pre-purchase paymentTR; for the jurisdiction debate in actions against a bank, the decision on jurisdiction in a case against a bankTR can be examined.
❓ Frequently asked questions
Does the platform being the claimant change the competent court?
Not in this decision. Article 73/1 of Law No. 6502 makes consumer courts competent in disputes arising from consumer transactions. Although the platform filed the case, the Chamber took the defendant user's consumer status as the basis and held the consumer court competent.
Does being subject to the Capital Markets Law make a case a commercial case?
According to the Chamber's reasoning, not on its own. Article 83/2 of Law No. 6502 provides that the fact a transaction is regulated in another law does not prevent it from being treated as a consumer transaction or the jurisdiction provisions from applying.
Was it accepted that the user created a fictitious balance?
No. The decision concerns only the question of jurisdiction. Because the first-instance court dismissed the case on procedural grounds, the platform's allegations were not examined on the merits, and the regional court of appeal only assessed jurisdiction.
Is there a mediation requirement in the consumer court?
Under Article 73/A of Law No. 6502, in disputes heard before consumer courts, apart from the exceptions listed in the law, applying to a mediator before filing the case is a precondition to suit. In this case, the platform's first action was also dismissed on procedural grounds for the absence of this condition.
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Our contact details are on the contact page, and the other decisions in the series are in the Precedent DecisionsTR section.
This article is for general information; the summary is compiled from the text of the regional court of appeal decision published through Bedesten / mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr. The decision is an appeal-stage decision given with the route of appeal on points of law open, and whether it has passed Court of Cassation review cannot be understood from the text of the decision. The determination of the competent court may lead to a different result in each case depending on the capacity of the parties, the nature of the contract, the purpose of the transaction and the legislation in force on the date of filing. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made using this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Kripto Borsası Davasında Görev – Ankara BAM 21. HD 2026/957.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Negative Oil Price Stop-Out Ruling: Istanbul Appeal Court 2025
- Fraud Claim and Attachment: Ankara Appeal Court Ruling 2026/563
- Crypto Exchange Collapse: Suing the State, Council of State 2021
- Forex Case: Non-Prosecution Is Not Enough, Court of Cassation 2021/873
- IBAN–Name Mismatch: Bank Liability, İzmir Appeal Court 2026
- Bank Liable for Employee's High-Return Promise: Court of Cassation