Negative Oil Price Stop-Out Ruling: Istanbul Appeal Court 2025

On the afternoon of 20 April 2020, the price of the May WTI crude oil futures contract fell within one hour from 0.69 US dollars per barrel to minus 37.63 dollars. This had never been seen on world markets, and for investors trading futures with leverage it produced debit balances far above the margin they had deposited. When a brokerage's automatic position-closing (stop-out) system runs but no buyer can be found in the market, who bears the resulting negative balance? The 12th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal answered this question by examining the investor's negative declaratory action and the brokerage's action to annul the objection together.
In its decision of 18 September 2025 (Docket No. E.2022/1205, Decision No. K.2025/1372), the 12th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal examined an appeal against a first-instance judgment that had rejected the investor's claim for compensation and a declaration of no debt against the brokerage, and had partly annulled the objection to the enforcement proceedings the brokerage started for the negative balance. The chamber rejected the appeal on the merits. The decision was unanimous and the route of appeal to the Court of Cassation remains open.
- The day of the negative price: what happened hour by hour
- The investor's action and the brokerage's enforcement proceedings
- The chamber's reasoning: orders were sent, no buyer existed
- Is a stop-out a promise to stop the loss?
- The account figures and the half refund
- Enforcement denial compensation in a negative balance claim
- Questions and answers
🛢️ The day of the negative price: what happened hour by hour
The expert report in the case set out the background in detail. During the Covid-19 lockdowns oil demand dropped sharply and storage costs rose to extraordinary levels. This pushed prices of the nearest-expiry WTI contracts, those for delivery at the end of May 2020, into negative territory. According to the text of the decision, the price of a barrel of crude oil contract moved as follows:
- 07.04.2020 at 08:59 — 17.76 USD
- 19.04.2020 at 09:59 — 15.55 USD
- 20.04.2020 at 09:59 — 11.70 USD; 12:59 — 4.91 USD; 13:59 — 0.69 USD
- 20.04.2020 at 14:59 — minus 37.63 USD
The expert found that this collapse occurred only in the May 2020 WTI contracts; in the June and November contracts prices did not fall below the 23 USD level, and on other oil markets such as Brent, May delivery prices stayed above 20 USD. The positions in the investor's account were precisely these nearest-expiry WTI contracts.
The same day margin calls were sent to the investor by e-mail: at 20:31 and 20:55 the investor was told that 80% of the margin had been used, and at 21:43 that all of the margin had been used. According to the system records, automatic sell orders at market price were sent for the investor's three long positions in the QMK0 contract at 19:05:10, 19:33:45, 19:34:14 and 21:33:25; none of these orders was executed because there was no buyer and no suitable bid quotation.
📂 The investor's action and the brokerage's enforcement proceedings
The dispute began as two separate actions, which were later joined.
Main action (investor): The investor argued that under the agreement the brokerage had to close the positions immediately once the margin fell below the 150% level, that this was not done, and that the loss therefore multiplied. For the time being the investor claimed a refund of 1,000 USD for each of three items (32,667 USD withdrawn from the account, 14,990 USD deposited afterwards and 3,625 USD for the value of the shares sold), together with a declaration that nothing was owed under the enforcement proceedings started by the brokerage.
Joined action (brokerage): To collect the negative balance on the account, the brokerage started enforcement proceedings without a court judgment at the İskenderun Enforcement Office for 29,080.54 USD. After the investor objected, it filed an action to annul the objection with enforcement denial compensation before the İskenderun Commercial Court of First Instance. This case was joined to the main action pending before the 14th Commercial Court of First Instance in Istanbul.
By its decision of 28.03.2022 (E. 2020/612, K. 2022/223), the Istanbul 14th Commercial Court of First Instance rejected the main action; in the joined action it partly annulled the objection, allowed the enforcement proceedings to continue for 28,929.46 USD and awarded enforcement denial compensation of 39,691.21 TRY, calculated on 20% of the claim. The investor's lawyer appealed this decision.
⚖️ The chamber's reasoning: orders were sent, no buyer existed
The main objection in the investor's appeal petition was this: the expert had said only that orders were entered and not executed, but had not clarified at what margin level the account stood when they were entered, or whether they were entered in time; the number of orders is irrelevant if an order was not entered in time. The chamber answered this objection with the following findings:
- Agreement and information: The parties signed a general framework agreement dated 25.03.2020 and a set of pre-contract information documents, and an agreement for intermediation in foreign markets dated 26.03.2020; the investor also signed the risk disclosure form for foreign transactions and the suitability test.
- Content of the risk disclosure form: The form provides that, because of leverage, high gains and equally high losses may arise; that the first margin call is made at 80% and the second at 100%; that 47 hours are allowed after the second call; and that if the 150% level is reached at any moment within that period, all positions are closed automatically without waiting for the period to end.
- Margin calls not met: The investor did not respond to the margin calls notified to the investor.
- Application of the procedure: The brokerage applied the procedure stated in the form, and the system issued the position-closing orders automatically.
- No buyer: The orders were not executed because the product moved to a negative price at a speed not previously seen on global markets and no buyer appeared. According to the chamber, if no buyer appears for an investment product, the position cannot be closed.
On the basis of these findings, the chamber concluded that the brokerage was not at fault in the occurrence of the loss and therefore bore no liability for the claims in the main action. For the joined action, it accepted on the same grounds that the investor was liable for the negative balance on the account, and the appeal was rejected on the merits under Article 353/1-b-1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK).
🔍 Is a stop-out a promise to stop the loss?
The most debatable aspect of the decision concerns the legal nature of the automatic position-closing mechanism. The investor read the stop-out level as a commitment by the brokerage to stop the loss at a certain point. The first-instance court and the chamber, however, treated the mechanism as an obligation of the brokerage to send the order to the market at a certain margin level.
According to the expert opinion adopted by the first-instance court and found correct by the chamber, the brokerage has no obligation other than to send the investor's buy or sell order to the market; in extraordinary conditions there may be no buyer in the market. Two elements stand out as decisive in this approach:
- Whether the order was sent: The log records showed that four separate automatic sell orders were sent. The expert's supplementary report stated that the orders ended because of market conditions, such as the absence of a buyer, the absence of a suitable bid quotation or the expiry of the order's waiting period, and that the brokerage was not at fault.
- The source of the loss: The loss arose from the contracts the investor had bought of the investor's own will losing value because of an event unprecedented in history, and from the leverage effect inherent in derivative transactions.
The chamber's reasoning contains no separate comparison of the time and level at which the orders were sent against the moment the 150% threshold was reached; the chamber accepted from the information and documents in the case that the procedure was applied as stated in the form. Because the decision is open to appeal, this point may also be examined separately by the Court of Cassation.
For a different case on who bears a margin shortfall in leveraged transactions, see the series' decision on investor liability for a margin shortfall on the Borsa Istanbul derivatives market (VİOP)TR; for a brokerage's authority to sell ex officio, see the decision on ex officio sale in margin share tradingTR.
🧮 The account figures and the half refund
One notable detail of the case is that the brokerage side took on half of the loss of its own accord. In summary, the account movements in the decision are as follows:
- On 20.04.2020 the account stood at plus 55,454.11 USD; with a loss entry of 79,510 USD it fell to minus 24,055.89 USD, and with commission and additional loss entries to minus 28,476.68 USD.
- The three QMK0 positions that could not be closed were closed on 21.04.2020 at the settlement price at expiry, a further loss of 59,362.23 USD was booked to the account, and the balance reached minus 87,838.91 USD.
- The 4,000 shares in the account were sold for 3,599.93 USD and the investor deposited 14,990 USD into the account; the balance became minus 72,848.91 USD.
- Citing the extraordinary situation, the brokerage's correspondent paid 43,919.45 USD, half of the loss, into the investor's account on 30.04.2020 as a goodwill gesture.
- After this payment was set off, the negative balance determined by the expert is 28,929.46 USD.
The first-instance court did not take the 29,080.54 USD claimed in the enforcement proceedings as its basis, but the 28,929.46 USD calculated by the expert; it annulled the objection for that amount and rejected the claim for the excess. In the case, the refund of half the loss was characterised as a goodwill payment by the brokerage side, and this payment was taken into account as a set-off item when calculating the remaining debt.
📑 Enforcement denial compensation in a negative balance claim
The investor's lawyer also argued that, for the joined action, the acceptance decision was given without obtaining an expert report and without calculating the debt, and that the conditions for enforcement denial compensation were not met. The chamber did not find these objections well founded either. The following points stand out in the reasoning:
- By a notice dated 04.05.2020, the brokerage demanded that the negative balance be paid within 24 hours.
- The account statement records on which the negative balance is based had already been examined in the main action, and the loss had been determined.
- The allegations and claims in both actions are the same, and the expert's supplementary report obtained after the joinder also contains findings on the joined action.
- For these reasons the claim was accepted as determinable and liquid, and awarding enforcement denial compensation was found correct.
Under Article 67/2 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK), enforcement denial compensation is awarded in an action to annul an objection where the debtor's objection is found unjustified and the claim is liquid; it is set at not less than 20% of the claim. Even for a claim in foreign currency based on an account statement, it was considered sufficient for liquidity that the amount can be determined from the account records.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Does a stop-out level limit the investor's loss at that level?
Can an investor owe more than the margin deposited?
How was it established that the orders were actually sent?
Is this decision final?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page, and the other decisions in the series are in the Precedent DecisionsTR section.
The information in this article is provided for general information only; the summary is compiled from the regional court of appeal decision published on Bedesten / mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr. The decision belongs to the appeal stage and the route of appeal to the Court of Cassation is open. A brokerage's liability is assessed separately in each case according to the content of the agreement and risk disclosure forms, the type of product, the order records and market conditions. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made by relying on this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Negatif Petrolde Stop-Out – İstanbul BAM 12. HD 2025/1372.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Fraud Claim and Attachment: Ankara Appeal Court Ruling 2026/563
- Crypto Exchange Collapse: Suing the State, Council of State 2021
- Forex Case: Non-Prosecution Is Not Enough, Court of Cassation 2021/873
- IBAN–Name Mismatch: Bank Liability, İzmir Appeal Court 2026
- Bank Liable for Employee's High-Return Promise: Court of Cassation
- Stock Tips Site Fundraising: Court of Cassation 2024/3604