TR

SIM Swap Crypto Theft: Court of Cassation 2026/2209

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 20 November 2026

SIM Swap Crypto Theft: Court of Cassation 2026/2209

The gateway to a crypto asset account often runs through a mobile phone number: login, withdrawal and transfer transactions are verified with one-time passwords (OTP). So if the SIM card linked to that number is reissued at a mobile dealer without the subscriber's knowledge, and the balance in the crypto account is emptied the same day, who bears the loss? The decision of the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) dated 15.04.2026, Docket No. (E.) 2025/5307 and Decision No. (K.) 2026/2209, discusses in the same case both the operator's liability and the limit of a claim for "the present value of the crypto assets".

In short: The subscriber's SIM card was cancelled, without his consent or knowledge, by an authorised dealer of the mobile operator and a replacement SIM card was issued; the one-time password arriving on the issued line was used to enter the crypto money account, and the crypto assets in the account were converted into dollars and USD 7,990.71 was withdrawn. Relying on expert reports, the consumer court held that the mobile operator had performed its obligations on SIM duplication security negligently and at fault; it awarded USD 7,990.71 and TRY 25,000.00 in non-pecuniary damages, and rejected the claim for loss of profit based on the value later reached by the crypto assets. The 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation rejected all appeal objections on the merits and upheld the judgment with a correction only as to the attorney's fee.

📱 How Does SIM Card Duplication Affect a Crypto Account?

On crypto asset platforms, account security is mostly two-stage: a username and password, and then a one-time verification code sent to the mobile phone. In this arrangement the phone number becomes a key on its own. When the SIM card linked to the number falls into a third person's hands, the verification codes also land on that person's device.

This is exactly the point discussed in the dispute covered by the decision. According to the expert reports obtained in the case, the duplication was carried out with a digital signature, but it was established that the signing was not the work of the consumer. Login to the crypto account and the money transfer were carried out using the one-time password arriving on the duplicated SIM card. Thus the first link of the chain broke in the subscription service, and the last link in the crypto account.

📅 The Chronology of an Incident over Two Days

The picture emerging from the text of the decision is as follows. On 23.06.2023 a customer representative of the mobile operator called the subscriber and asked whether he had made any request to cancel the line. When the subscriber said he had given no such approval, the call was cut off; the subscriber then called customer services, reported the suspicious situation and asked for precautions to be taken.

On 24.06.2023 the subscriber noticed that his mobile data was off; when he reached customer services from another line, he was told that an update had been made in the system and that switching the phone off and on would be enough. When the problem was not resolved, he went to a dealer and learned that his SIM card had been cancelled, without his permission, approval or knowledge, by another authorised dealer of the company and that a replacement SIM card had been issued.

Through the replacement line issued, 7,990.710631 USDT was withdrawn from the crypto money account the same day. The subscriber claimed collection of this amount with interest running from 24.06.2023, USD 100 in pecuniary damages for the time being, pending an expert's determination of the rise in value of the crypto assets up to the date of the lawsuit, and TRY 300,000.00 in non-pecuniary damages.

In its defence the mobile operator argued that the dealer who carried out the transaction has an independent legal personality and acted in its own name and account, that due care was shown in selecting, training and supervising the dealer, that the forgery allegations were of a level requiring expert examination, and that there was no adequate causal link between the incident and the company's acts.

⚖️ The Findings of the Consumer Court and the Regional Court of Appeal

The Kayseri 1st Consumer Court characterised the dispute as pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages arising from a defective service. The court found that the line's SIM card had been duplicated at the defendant company's dealer, that the crypto account had been entered through the duplicated line and USD 7,990.71 withdrawn from the account by converting the crypto assets into dollars, and that the company had failed, through its negligent and faulty conduct, to perform its obligations on security measures for SIM duplication transactions.

The judgment was given for collection of USD 7,990.71 from 24.06.2023 at the annual default interest rate applied by the Central Bank of the Republic of Türkiye to USD deposits, rejection of the USD 100 claim, and collection of TRY 25,000.00 in non-pecuniary damages with statutory interest. The 6th Civil Chamber of the Kayseri Regional Court of Appeal rejected the applications on the ground that there was no procedural or legal error as regards the grounds of appeal.

📎 Full text of the decision: The decision has been verified by docket and decision number in the Case Law Search system of the Presidency of the Court of Cassation.

💱 Can the Later Rise in a Crypto Asset's Value Be Claimed?

This was the most contested heading in the case. The claimant side argued that the type and amount of the coins in the account were clear on the date of the incident, and that the expert report of 01.02.2025 had established the type and amounts of the coins and where they were transferred; it asked for the difference in value arising between the date of the incident and the date of the decision to be calculated.

This claim, which the first-instance court rejected, also passed the Court of Cassation review. The criteria on which the rejection rests are as follows:

  • Money was withdrawn from the claimant's crypto account in dollars; the loss became concrete on the foreign currency amount at the moment of withdrawal,
  • It was accepted that no evidence was submitted in time about the crypto assets in the account on the date of the incident,
  • Since, even if the crypto assets had not been converted into dollars by third persons, the claimant could have converted them into other assets in the time that had passed, the claim for loss in this scope was regarded as abstract,
  • For this reason, the claim based on the rise in value was not accepted as part of the direct loss,
  • By contrast, the claim for non-pecuniary damages for the distress the incident caused the claimant was found lawful.

In other words, the decision frames the loss suffered on crypto assets by reference to the value at the moment of actual withdrawal, and treats loss of profit based on later price movements as hypothetical. How a similar discipline of proof on the fate of digital assets is applied in criminal proceedings is discussed separately in the cassation-in-the-interest-of-the-law decision on an acquaintance who managed a crypto accountTR.

🔐 The Debate on the Obligations of a Crypto Asset Service Provider

While arguing that responsibility lay with the crypto asset platform, the defendant company relied on the second paragraph of Article 35/B of Capital Markets Law No. 6362. That paragraph obliges crypto asset service providers to make the necessary arrangements, take measures and set up internal control units and systems so that their systems can be managed securely. The company also argued that, under the relevant communiqué provisions, platforms must make agreements with operators in order to learn of SIM card changes instantly, and must require two-stage identity verification.

The 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation answered this defence on the ground that the relevant provisions were not in force on the date of the incident. Indeed, Articles 35/B and 35/C were added to the Capital Markets Law by an amendment dated 26.06.2024, while the incident took place in June 2023. The Chamber also found the expert report on which the judgment was based suitable for review and for giving a judgment.

This finding is important as it shows the time dimension of the decision's application: the security obligations now provided for crypto asset service providers cannot be used to apportion liability for incidents that occurred before they came into force.

🆕 The Cost of Not Attending a Mediation Meeting

The ground for quashing in the decision relates not to the merits but to litigation costs. The eleventh paragraph of Article 18/A of the Law on Mediation in Civil Disputes No. 6325 provides that a party that does not attend the first meeting without showing a valid excuse is liable for half of the other party's litigation costs even if it wins the case in part or in full, and that half of the attorney's fee determined under the tariff will be awarded in favour of that party. According to the final mediation record in the file, the defendant company did not attend the talks.

To this was added a recent change concerning non-pecuniary damages. By the Constitutional Court's decision of 25.12.2024, 2024/29 E., 2024/226 K., the second paragraph of Article 326 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK), which forms the basis for liability for litigation costs according to the degree of success as regards the rejected amount in cases claiming non-pecuniary damages, and the practice of paying the opposing attorney's fee, were annulled; the decision, published in the Official Gazette of 14.03.2025, came into force on 14.12.2025. The second paragraph of Article 10 of the Attorneyship Minimum Fee Tariff, which regulated the attorney's fee in favour of the other party where non-pecuniary damages cases are partly rejected, was also repealed by an amendment published in the Official Gazette of 08.01.2026.

The Chamber, stating that these bases had fallen away as of the date of the appeal review, found that no attorney's fee should be awarded in favour of the defendant as regards non-pecuniary damages, and that half of the fee determined under the tariff should be awarded as regards pecuniary damages, and upheld the judgment with a correction by adding an attorney's fee of TRY 1,516.97. For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Other decisions in the series appear in the Precedent DecisionsTR section.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Can a mobile operator be held liable for a SIM duplication carried out by its dealer?

In the case covered by the decision, it was. The court accepted that the duplication was carried out at the company's authorised dealer and that the company had failed, through its negligent and faulty conduct, to perform its obligations on security measures for SIM duplication transactions; the defence that the dealer has an independent legal personality was not accepted.

Can the present value of stolen crypto assets be claimed?

In this case it could not. In view of the withdrawal in dollars from the account, the acceptance that evidence about the crypto assets on the date of the incident was not submitted in time, and the fact that the assets could in any event have been converted by the claimant as well, the claim based on the rise in value was regarded as abstract and was not treated as direct loss.

From what date do the security obligations of crypto asset service providers apply?

Articles 35/B and 35/C of the Capital Markets Law were added to the Law by an amendment dated 26.06.2024. Since the incident covered by the decision took place in 2023, the Chamber stated that these provisions were not in force on the date of the incident and did not find the defendant's appeal objection on this point well founded.

Is an attorney's fee awarded in favour of a party that does not attend a mediation meeting?

Under the eleventh paragraph of Article 18/A of Law No. 6325, half of the attorney's fee determined under the Attorneyship Minimum Fee Tariff is awarded in favour of a party that does not attend the first meeting without a valid excuse; that party, even if it wins the case, is liable for half of the other party's litigation costs. For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy.

The information in this article is for general information purposes; the summary of the decision is taken from the published text of the relevant Court of Cassation decision, and each case is assessed on its own evidence. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, complaints and defences made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article SIM Kopyalama ve Kripto Hesabı – Yargıtay 3. HD 2026/2209.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp