Crypto Fraud Abroad Is No Bar: Court of Cassation 2025/10818

A "crypto investment" offer met on social media, users on Telegram presenting themselves as customer representatives, a foreign website and, in the end, a closed account… In complaints of this kind the first obstacle facing the investigating authorities is often the same: the perpetrators are invisible, the servers are abroad and the contact ran through foreign messaging apps. Is that picture enough of a reason to close a complaint without any investigation? The 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation answered this question in the negative when it quashed the rejection of an objection against a non-prosecution decision based on the reasoning that "there is no possibility of investigating because the matter originates abroad".
In its decision of 08.09.2025, Docket No. (E.) 2025/549, Decision No. (K.) 2025/10818, the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation unanimously quashed, in the interest of the law, a criminal judgeship of peace decision that had rejected the objection against a decision not to prosecute. The complaint concerned a total of 45,000.00 USD sent to a crypto investment promising a high profit share. The Chamber stated that the following should have been considered: requesting account activity and IP data from the crypto platform the complainant used, seeking judicial assistance through letters rogatory for the foreign messaging app, and, if the perpetrators could not be identified, placing the case under permanent search status for the duration of the limitation period.
- The subject of the complaint: Telegram, a crypto platform and 45,000 USD
- The prosecutor's reasoning: log records, data privacy and the USA
- Why did the Court of Cassation quash the decision?
- The investigation roadmap drawn by the Chamber
- The evidence debate: traces that remain in Türkiye
- Permanent search, limitation period and the limits of the decision
- Frequently asked questions
🌐 The subject of the complaint: Telegram, a crypto platform and 45,000 USD
The facts reflected in the decision are a typical example of the complaints that have been filed in recent years under the label of crypto investment. The facts set out in the request for quashing in the interest of the law and in the Chamber's assessment can be summarised as follows:
- Persons of unknown identity reached the complainant through social media and made an investment offer promising high profits.
- Directed through a website, the complainant was in contact on the Telegram app with three separate users who introduced themselves as customer service officers.
- Following the guidance of these users, a total of 45,000.00 USD was sent at different times to the addresses given.
- The complainant stated that the transactions were made through a crypto platform called "Binance".
- After a while, money was demanded again and again, and then access to the investment account and to the site was blocked.
The complaint became the subject of an investigation on the allegation of qualified fraud committed by using information systems, banks or credit institutions as a tool, regulated in Article 158/1-f of the Turkish Penal Code No. 5237. In the cases listed in this sub-paragraph, the lower limit of the prison sentence is four years, and the judicial fine cannot be less than twice the benefit obtained from the offence.
🧱 The prosecutor's reasoning: log records, data privacy and the USA
The Tutak Chief Public Prosecutor's Office decided not to prosecute in its decision of 29.01.2024, Investigation No. 2023/441, Decision No. 2024/48. As reported in the decision, the reasoning rests not on the merits of the complaint but on the view that investigating was technically and legally impossible:
- The URL concerned was located abroad,
- In cybercrime, the physical identity of perpetrators can only be reached through "log file" records held by service providers and through IP numbers,
- In transactions based abroad, this information cannot be obtained because of the legal framework of the countries concerned and the provisions on personal data privacy,
- According to a letter of the Ministry of Justice dated 20.01.2015, US law distinguishes between "serious crime / minor offence", and foreign judicial assistance requests concerning minor offences are not met; for this reason this route was never tried.
Starting from this assessment, the prosecutor's office concluded that there was no possibility of investigating and that no concrete finding could be made. The objection against this decision was rejected by the Patnos Criminal Judgeship of Peace in its decision of 16.02.2024, Miscellaneous Criminal File No. 2024/196; because the decision is final under Article 271/4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK), it became final on the same day.
What stands out is that, in the reasoning, no information was requested from the crypto platform the complainant actually used or from the accounts through which the money transfers passed. The prosecutor's office did not make a request, accepting in advance that a foreign assistance request would fail; and the traces that could be reached inside the country were not investigated at all.
🏛️ Why did the Court of Cassation quash the decision?
On the request of the Ministry of Justice dated 17.01.2025, the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Cassation sent the case to the Chamber with its written opinion of 04.02.2025, No. KYB-2025/9986. The written opinion referred to a decision of the 4th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation on a similar case, dated 15.03.2021, Docket No. 2021/1361, Decision No. 2021/9218, and stressed that non-prosecution decisions given without open-source research on the social media account and without an attempt at identification through the police do not satisfy the requirement of an effective investigation.
The Chamber considered Articles 160, 172 and 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK) together. As soon as a public prosecutor learns of a situation giving the impression that an offence has been committed, the prosecutor is obliged to investigate the truth and to collect evidence both in favour of and against the suspect. The criminal judgeship of peace examining the objection, in turn, may reject the objection if there is not enough evidence, may accept it if there is enough evidence, or may decide to widen the investigation because of an incomplete investigation.
In this case the Chamber expressly described the prosecutor's reasoning that "there is no possibility of investigating because the matter originates abroad" as a "wrong reasoning" and also found the investigation incomplete. Rejecting the objection, when a decision to widen the investigation should have been given, was seen as contrary to the law; the decision of the Patnos Criminal Judgeship of Peace was unanimously quashed in the interest of the law under Article 309/3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK), and the case was referred to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Cassation for action under Article 309/4-a.
🧭 The investigation roadmap drawn by the Chamber
The part of the decision that sheds the most light on practice is the section that sets out concretely which steps can be taken in a crypto complaint with a foreign link. According to the Chamber, the following actions should have been considered before reaching a conclusion:
- Crypto platform records: Obtaining from the crypto platform the complainant said was used the complainant's account activity on that site and the IP data of the logins to the account.
- Messaging app: Identifying the head office of the foreign Telegram app and making a letters rogatory (judicial assistance) request to the country concerned for the details of the users who contacted the complainant.
- Permanent search: Considering, depending on the results of these inquiries, continuing the investigation by placing the case under permanent search for the duration of the limitation period in order to identify the real perpetrators.
The importance of the list is that, against the prosecutor's acceptance that "there is no way", the Chamber shows that at least three different routes had not been tried. One of them is not directly tied to a foreign country: the activity and login records of the complainant's own crypto account are among the first sources to turn to for tracing the money. Letters rogatory, in turn, should not remain a route that is never used on the assumption that the result would be negative; the Chamber did not accept guessing in advance whether a request would be met as sufficient to close an investigation.
🔎 The evidence debate: traces that remain in Türkiye
Even though the perpetrators are invisible in allegations of investment fraud originating abroad, it is often not possible for the movement of money to take place without leaving any trace. The logic of the decision is that the investigation should start from these traces:
- Flow of money: To which accounts, by which route and on which dates the amounts sent by the complainant were transferred can be followed through the records of the crypto platform and, where they exist, bank records.
- Login records: The IP addresses that accessed the account may help identify not only the complainant but also possible access by third parties.
- Open-source research: As stressed in the decision of the 4th Criminal Chamber referred to in the written opinion, open-source research on the social media account and the website is among the first steps that can be taken for identification.
- Similar cases: Looking into whether other complaints exist under the same site or user names may bring together allegations that appear scattered.
The place of identity verification records on crypto platforms in an investigation is also discussed in the series' decision no. 2026/4543 on investigating the KYC trail. A quashing decision given for similar shortcomings in another token fraud allegation run through Telegram is examined in the article on decision no. 2026/1903TR. The distinguishing point of the present decision is that the prosecutor's reasoning was based not on "no deception" or "civil dispute" but directly on the acceptance that "investigation is impossible".
📌 Permanent search, limitation period and the limits of the decision
To read the consequences of the decision correctly, it is necessary to look at how quashing in the interest of the law works. Article 309 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK) is an extraordinary remedy, initiated at the request of the Ministry of Justice, against decisions and judgments that became final without going through appeal or cassation review. In this case the following points stand out:
- The quashed decision is a criminal judgeship of peace decision that does not resolve the merits of the case. Under Article 309/4-a, the authority that gave the decision will decide again after carrying out the necessary review and inquiry.
- Permanent search, in practice, means that cases in which the perpetrator cannot be identified are not closed but kept open for the duration of the limitation period. The Chamber pointed out that the finding "the perpetrator cannot be found" can be met with this method instead of a non-prosecution decision.
- The quashing decision contains no finding that any person committed an offence; it only shows that the investigation was conducted incompletely and that the reasoning relied upon was wrong.
- The timeline is notable: the criminal judgeship of peace decision became final on 16.02.2024, the Ministry's request was made on 17.01.2025, and the Chamber's decision was given on 08.09.2025. This route is not a remedy the complainant can apply to directly; it is an exceptional review mechanism that depends on a request of the Ministry.
The difficulty of investigating allegations of investment fraud with a foreign link is real; however, the decision shows that this difficulty cannot be used as a reason for never starting an investigation.
❓ Frequently asked questions
Does the site or app being abroad make an investigation impossible?
In this decision the Chamber found this reasoning wrong. A foreign link can make collecting evidence harder; however, it was stated that the conclusion "there is no possibility of investigating" cannot be reached without trying routes such as requesting records from the crypto platform, letters rogatory and permanent search.
Can it be accepted in advance that a letters rogatory request will fail?
The prosecutor's office made no request, relying on an old Ministry letter stating that the USA does not meet assistance requests for minor offences. The Chamber, however, stated that the head office of the app concerned should be identified and information requested from that country. The approach of the decision is that assuming the result of a request in advance does not justify not investigating.
How long does a case placed under permanent search stay open?
The decision states that placing the case under permanent search "for the duration of the limitation period" should be considered. This period is the prosecution limitation period determined by the statutory penalty of the alleged offence. If new information about the perpetrators is obtained within this period, the investigation can continue from where it stopped.
Does quashing in the interest of the law mean the money sent will be returned?
No. The quashing decision only set aside the criminal judgeship of peace decision rejecting the objection and opened the way for the investigation to be widened. What happens to the money, the identification of the perpetrators and any liability depend on the result of the new investigation; the decision itself contains no ruling on this.
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are available on the contact page, and the other decisions in the series can be found in the Precedent DecisionsTR section.
This article is for general information; the summary of the decision has been compiled from the published decision of the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation quashing in the interest of the law. The decision relates to the investigation stage and contains no finding that any person committed an offence; the presumption of innocence applies. Each case is assessed on its own evidence and concrete facts. Savun Law cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made using this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Kriptoda Yurt Dışı Engeli – Yargıtay 11. CD 2025/10818.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Tax Fee to Release Winnings: Court of Cassation 2026/3017
- Duplicate Complaint Non-Prosecution – Court of Cassation 2025/15028
- Arbitration Clause in Crypto Exchange – Court of Cassation 2025/6256
- Fake Brokerage Site Non-Prosecution – Court of Cassation 2026/4536
- Remote Access Investment Scam: Court of Cassation 2026/6495
- Crypto Fraud KYC Trail: Court of Cassation 2026/4543