TR

Crypto Fraud KYC Trail: Court of Cassation 2026/4543

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 20 November 2026

Crypto Fraud KYC Trail: Court of Cassation 2026/4543

One of the most common closing lines in investigation files is that the suspect could not be identified and therefore there is no possibility of prosecution. But after which inquiries can that finding be given? The cassation-in-the-interest-of-the-law (kanun yararına bozma) decision of the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) dated 27.04.2026, Docket No. (E.) 2025/5763, Decision No. (K.) 2026/4543, answers this question through concrete lines of inquiry, in an alleged investment fraud run through crypto assets.

The legal knot in the case was that the investigation had been closed on the ground of "technical impossibility". Relying on a cyber investigation report and the replies received from companies, the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office had decided not to prosecute, stating that identifying the suspect was impossible and that foreign authorities had also refused the letters rogatory; the objection to that decision had been rejected by the criminal judgeship of peace. The Chamber, however, concluded that the inquiries that could be made had not been exhausted, in view of the correspondence attached to the complaint petitions, the receipt samples and the information in the technical data assessment report.

In short: The objection to the decision not to prosecute of the Akyazı Chief Public Prosecutor's Office dated 02.10.2024 (Investigation No. 2024/533, Decision No. 2024/2659) was rejected by the Sakarya 1st Criminal Judgeship of Peace by its decision dated 25.11.2024, Miscellaneous Docket No. 2024/7874, and that decision became final on the same day. On the request of the Ministry of Justice dated 19.11.2025 and the written opinion of the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Cassation dated 08.12.2025 (KYB-2025/135630), the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation on 27.04.2026 accepted the request and unanimously quashed the decision of the authority in the interest of the law under Article 309/3 of Law No. 5271.

📲 The Facts of the Complaint: An Investment Link from a Messaging App

According to the complaint as recounted in the decision, the complainant joined a website on the direction of a person who had made contact through the WhatsApp application, who presented himself as an e-commerce expert and said he was also involved in crypto money business. This person conveyed that an investment could be made, and profit earned, by depositing money into the site's crypto money accounts; once trust was established, the complainant deposited some money into the account he had had opened and made transactions.

Some time later, when he wanted to withdraw money, his account was frozen; the persons contacted again told him that there were problems with the system and that money had to be deposited again to resolve them. Over a period of about two weeks the complainant deposited various amounts again into the accounts indicated, but he could neither obtain a refund of the money nor see the problem resolved. After that, in order to get the money back, he also sent money through a centralised crypto exchange account to a person who contacted him through another application and who said he had encountered a similar situation, and afterwards he could not reach this person again either. The case was conducted in respect of these two separate incidents.

🚫 The Prosecutor's Non-Prosecution Reasoning and the Rejection of the Objection

Relying on the cyber investigation report obtained and the replies received from the companies concerned, the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office decided not to prosecute, stating that identifying the suspect was not possible and that prosecution was impossible because foreign authorities had also refused the letters rogatory. The reasoning further stated that foreign-based service providers accept requests for information from Turkish judicial authorities only for certain offences such as terrorist incidents, murder, missing persons and child sexual abuse; that requests concerning other offences were refused as not in line with the mutual legal assistance agreement and on grounds of provisions on the confidentiality of personal data; and that the website concerned used servers based abroad and the IP records could not be obtained. For these reasons it was concluded that, were the investigation to continue, reaching new evidence was technically impossible.

The Sakarya 1st Criminal Judgeship of Peace, examining the complainant's objection, rejected it by its decision of 25.11.2024. Because the decision is final under Article 271/4 of Law No. 5271, it became final on the same date. This decision, which became final without going through appeal or cassation review, was made the subject of the cassation-in-the-interest-of-the-law route.

📘 The Framework of CMK Articles 160, 172 and 173

The decision first sets out the normative framework. Under Article 160 of the Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271 (CMK), as soon as a public prosecutor learns of a situation giving the impression that an offence has been committed, he begins immediately to investigate the truth of the matter in order to decide whether there is a ground for bringing a public prosecution; he is obliged to collect, through judicial law enforcement officers, the evidence in favour of and against the suspect so that the material truth can be investigated and a fair trial held. Article 172/1 provides that a decision not to prosecute is given where evidence establishing sufficient suspicion cannot be obtained or where there is no possibility of prosecution.

Article 173 sets out the objection route against a non-prosecution decision and the powers of the criminal judgeship of peace examining the objection. Under the third paragraph, if the judgeship considers it necessary to widen the investigation in order to give its decision, it may make a request to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office of that place, stating this expressly; if there is no sufficient ground for bringing a public prosecution, it rejects the request with reasons. Under the fourth paragraph, if it finds the request well founded, the public prosecutor prepares an indictment. In the text quoted in the decision the objection period appears as "fifteen days", whereas the current text of the article provides this period as "two weeks".

From these provisions the Chamber drew a three-way table of options: the criminal judgeship of peace examining the objection may decide to reject it where there is not enough evidence for a public prosecution, to accept it where there is enough evidence, or to order the investigation to be widened because it is incomplete.

🪙 The KYC Trail: The Lines of Inquiry Listed by the Chamber

The part of the decision most notable in practice is the listing, one by one, of the inquiries said to be necessary. The Chamber stated that the complainant's detailed statement should be taken and that the correspondence attached to the petitions, the receipt samples and the information in the report on the technical data assessment should be reassessed. After that, it stated that detailed information should be requested, directly or through letters rogatory abroad, about the transactions carried out at the institutions described as centralised exchanges, where it was established that transfers had been made through the identity verification method (KYC) from the crypto wallets to which the complainant sent money.

The logic of the decision here is this: centralised crypto exchanges obtain identity verification from their users; so if it can be established that a transfer passed through an institution of this kind, the anonymity on the chain does not apply to the whole chain. The Chamber also listed obtaining a technical report from an expert in information technology and the crypto money market, establishing to whom the messaging account used in the conversations belongs, and, by also asking the relevant department, investigating nationwide whether there are mobile numbers that contacted the complainant and similar fraud acts carried out using the website in question.

As for the second incident, it was stated that the clear identity and address details of the person contacted should be obtained from the IP and port information to be obtained through the mobile phone number in the technical data assessment report or from the website concerned, that this information should where necessary be obtained through the Information and Communication Technologies Authority and, through letters rogatory abroad, from the institutions operating the platforms, and that the detailed statements of all suspects about the incident should then be taken.

🧑‍⚖️ Cassation in the Interest of the Law and the Chamber's Conclusion

Article 309 of Law No. 5271 gives the Ministry of Justice, on learning of an unlawful aspect of a decision or judgment given by a judge or court and finalised without going through appeal or cassation review, the power to communicate a request for quashing to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Cassation. The Chief Public Prosecutor's Office writes out the grounds word for word and submits the request to the relevant criminal chamber; if the chamber finds the grounds put forward well founded, it quashes the decision in the interest of the law. In this case the route was set in motion by the Ministry of Justice document dated 19.11.2025, No. 2025/16840.

The Chamber found it contrary to law that, on an objection against a decision not to prosecute given as a result of an incomplete investigation and flawed reasoning, the objection was rejected when a decision to widen the investigation should have been given; it found the request for cassation in the interest of the law well founded. As a result, it decided to accept the request, to quash unanimously, in the interest of the law and under Article 309/3, the decision of the Sakarya 1st Criminal Judgeship of Peace dated 25.11.2024, Miscellaneous Docket No. 2024/7874, and, under Article 309/4-a, to hand the investigation file to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Cassation to be sent to its place of origin so that the necessary steps could be taken.

📎 Full text of the decision: The decision has been verified by docket and decision number in the Court of Cassation Case Law Search system of the Presidency of the Court of Cassation.

🕵️ The Limit of the "Suspect Could Not Be Identified" Reasoning

The basic idea the decision carries is that the failure to identify the perpetrator cannot in itself be treated as a ground for non-prosecution. The situation of "no possibility of prosecution" in Article 172/1 of Law No. 5271 is a result that can be reached only after the investigation duty has been properly performed. The request for cassation in the interest of the law also stressed that where the public prosecutor has not performed the investigation duty placed on him and there is no investigation in accordance with the Law, the conditions in Article 173/3 do not arise, and the authority examining the objection may give a decision in order to ensure that an investigation is carried out.

The second notable point in the decision is that it does not accept the assumption that the refusal of a letter rogatory abroad closes all lines of inquiry. It states that the case file contains other lines of inquiry that can be pursued under domestic law, such as the records of the centralised exchange that carried out identity verification, mobile number and IP data, an expert's examination and a nationwide search for similar acts. The decision on crypto investment through a messaging applicationTR, which shows a similar approach, and the decision on investment money sent to a crypto platform accountTR, which focuses on tracing the flow of money, can be read together with this article.

🎯 The Practical Reflection of the Decision

The decision is instructive in making concrete the lines along which an investigation can be run in alleged investment fraud through crypto assets. Among the inquiry points listed in the decision are the full submission to the file of wallet addresses and transfer records, receipts and correspondence; the requesting of identity verification records where the transfer passed through a centralised exchange; and the assessment of technical data through an expert. For examples in cases of this kind where similar channels operate through social media, the decision on forex investment through social mediaTR also offers a comparison.

As to procedure, the decision points to the third option in the hands of the criminal judgeship of peace examining an objection to non-prosecution, namely a request to widen the investigation. It states that in a non-prosecution decision based on an incomplete investigation, this route is to be used instead of directly rejecting the objection. For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Other decisions in the series appear in the Precedent DecisionsTR section.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Can a final non-prosecution decision be reviewed through cassation in the interest of the law?

Article 309 of Law No. 5271 regulates this route for decisions and judgments that have become final without going through appeal or cassation review. Because decisions of the criminal judgeship of peace rejecting an objection to non-prosecution are final under Article 271/4, the route was used in the case covered by the decision.

Why does the KYC record matter in an investigation?

The decision states that detailed information should be requested, directly or through letters rogatory abroad, from the institutions described as centralised exchanges, where it was established that transfers had been made through the identity verification method (KYC) from the crypto wallets to which money was sent. These records can make it possible to reach a link in the transfer chain where identity has been verified.

What decisions can the judgeship examining an objection to non-prosecution give?

The decision lists three options: rejecting the objection if there is not enough evidence for a public prosecution, accepting it if there is enough evidence, or widening the investigation because it is incomplete. Article 173/3 of Law No. 5271 provides that where widening the investigation is considered necessary, a request can be made to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office, stating this expressly.

Does a cassation-in-the-interest-of-the-law decision restart the investigation?

Under Article 309/4-a of Law No. 5271, the decision orders the investigation file to be sent to its place of origin so that the necessary steps can be taken. For decisions that do not resolve the merits of the case, this provision envisages that the judge or court that gave the decision will decide again after the necessary examination and inquiry.

The information in this article is for general information purposes; the summary of the decision is taken from the published text of the relevant decision of the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation, and each case is assessed on its own evidence. A decision of cassation in the interest of the law does not definitively conclude the dispute; the investigation continues accordingly. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Kriptoda KYC izi ve takipsizlik – Yargıtay 11. CD 2026/4543.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp