Arbitration Clause in Crypto Exchange – Court of Cassation 2025/6256

Before which authority can a crypto exchange user argue a loss after the account is suspended overnight and a token swap is reversed? The user agreement that many users tick “I accept” on without reading has often already decided the answer. By its decision of 15.10.2025, Docket No. (E.) 2025/1603, Decision No. (K.) 2025/6256, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation found it correct that a case brought before a state court was dismissed on procedural grounds because of the arbitration clause in a crypto asset platform’s user agreement, and affirmed the decision unanimously.
The ruling is a short affirmation; but the file behind it puts the question “which door must be knocked on” concretely before us in a dispute between a crypto platform and its user.
🪙 From a Token Swap to a Suspended Account
The sequence of events described in the petition is as follows: The defendant company set up an exchange platform where crypto assets are bought and sold. Users register on the platform through its internet address and can buy and sell crypto assets from their personal accounts. The claimant also had an actively used account on this exchange and bought a token there.
Before launching its own supporter token, the company promoted the project through its website and social media channels and announced that some tokens listed on the exchange could be swapped for the new token. Relying on these statements, the claimant exchanged the token he held for the new supporter token.
The development that caused the dispute came after this. According to the claimant’s account, right after the transaction the company suspended the account, then cancelled the swap and made a refund. The claimant argued that, because of this refund, he lost the profit he expected from the tokens received in the pre-sale; that because some transactions were refunded and others were not, demand for the token he held fell, its price suddenly dropped, and he suffered a loss because he could not sell it. The claim is payment, for now, of TRY 5,000.00 with default interest, out of the monetary value of the 320,000,000 tokens purchased on the date the notice reached the company.
The company’s view is the opposite. In the counterclaim the company argued that the user had used his crypto asset trades on the platform accounts as “a means of making unjust profit through unlawful acts” and also claimed, for now, TRY 5,000.00. In the Court of Cassation’s characterisation, the main claim rests on a loss alleged from “fraudulent transactions in breach of contract” and the counterclaim on “unjust enrichment through suspicious transactions”.
🏛️ The Same Result at Three Levels
In its response petition the defendant company raised a procedural objection before going into the merits. Under Article 8 of the “User Agreement” accepted by users, titled “Resolution of Disputes”, all disputes arising from the agreement or from use of the platforms, including claims arising from crypto asset trading, transfers and all other work and services offered by the platform, are to be resolved finally by arbitration under the Rules of the Istanbul Arbitration Centre.
The Istanbul 3rd Court of First Instance (civil) (2023/172 E., 2024/293 K.) found this objection well founded. The court stated that Article 8 of the agreement provides for arbitration to resolve disputes and that, for the validity of this provision, it does not matter whether the parties are merchants. It accordingly accepted the preliminary arbitration objection and decided, separately for the main claim and the counterclaim, that the court lacked jurisdiction and that the case be dismissed on procedural grounds.
The 19th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal (2024/2452 E., 2024/2236 K.) rejected the appeal on the merits, on the ground that the decision complied with procedure and the law.
The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that there was no error in the first instance court’s decision and that the decision rejecting the appeal on the merits under Article 353/1-b(1) HMK complied with procedure and the law, and it affirmed the decision under Article 370/1 HMK. The decision was given on 15.10.2025, finally and unanimously.
As a result, the loss alleged by the claimant, whether the platform’s practice of suspending accounts and cancelling transactions was lawful, and the unjust enrichment claim in the counterclaim were never debated before the state courts; all these questions were left to the arbitration route shown in the agreement.
🔍 The Legal Framework Behind the Decision
The Court of Cassation did not write detailed reasons in its affirmation and adopted the reasoning of the first instance court. Behind that reasoning are the arbitration provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 (HMK):
- Article 412/1-2 HMK: An arbitration agreement is an agreement to leave disputes that have arisen or may arise to an arbitrator or arbitral tribunal, and it can also be made as a term of the main contract. Article 8 of the user agreement is an “arbitration clause” of this kind.
- Article 413/1 HMK: If a case is brought on a dispute that is the subject of an arbitration agreement, the other party may raise a preliminary arbitration objection; unless the arbitration agreement is “void, ineffective or impossible to apply”, the court accepts the objection and dismisses the case on procedural grounds. This is what happened in this file.
- Article 408 HMK: Disputes arising from rights in rem over immovable property or from matters not subject to the parties’ free will are not arbitrable. Claims arising from crypto asset trading are not among these exceptions.
- No merchant requirement: The first instance court expressly stated that whether the parties are merchants is irrelevant to the validity of the arbitration provision. This is the sentence of the decision most likely to be reflected in practice.
- The counterclaim shares the same fate: The arbitration clause bound not only the user but also the platform; the company’s counterclaim based on unjust enrichment was dismissed on procedural grounds for the same reason.
An important detail: the arbitration objection is a preliminary objection. If the defendant had not raised it in time, the state court could have continued to hear the case. In this file the objection was raised together with the response petition.
📑 A Clause Accepted by Clicking, and Proof
On crypto platforms, user agreements are as a rule approved electronically during registration. Although Article 412/3 HMK requires an arbitration agreement to be in writing, it treats the agreement as having been put “in electronic form” as sufficient to meet the written form requirement. Under the same paragraph, an arbitration agreement is also deemed made where a document containing an arbitration clause is referred to with the aim of making it part of the main contract.
In this file it was not disputed that the claimant had accepted the user agreement and was actively using his account; the claim petition itself describes the claimant as a registered user of the platform. The dispute therefore turned less on the existence of the agreement than on whether the arbitration clause would apply.
Another point on proof is Article 412/4 HMK: an objection that “the main contract is not valid” cannot be raised against the arbitration agreement. In other words, an allegation that the platform acted fraudulently does not by itself remove the arbitration clause; that allegation is also a matter of substance to be examined before the arbitrator.
⚖️ The Open Question: Consumers and Unfair Terms
The text of the decision does not discuss whether the claimant carried out his crypto asset transactions as a consumer, or whether the arbitration clause was reviewed under the Consumer Protection Law No. 6502. The case was heard not in a consumer court but in a court of first instance (civil), and the Court of Cassation made no assessment in that direction.
Yet Article 5 of Law No. 6502 treats as “unfair terms” those terms inserted into a contract without negotiation with the consumer that create an imbalance against the consumer in breach of the principle of good faith, and provides that they are absolutely void. Under the same article, a term in a pre-drafted standard contract is deemed not negotiated if the consumer could not influence its content; this provision also applies to contracts drafted by organisations operating under a permit.
For this reason it would not be correct to read the decision as meaning that an arbitration clause will necessarily be held valid for every crypto platform user. Since no such objection arose in the file examined, the Court of Cassation also gave no answer to this question. In a specific case, the user’s capacity, the transaction volume and the way the contract was formed are factors that could change the result.
For a different example in which consumer disputes arising from crypto accounts were examined on the merits, the series’ decision on an unauthorised transfer in a crypto conversion serviceTR and decision on a crypto account emptied through SIM cloning may be read.
🆕 New Regulation for Crypto Platforms
The case examined was filed in 2023 (first instance docket number 2023/172). At that date no comprehensive statutory framework for crypto asset service providers was yet in force. In 2024, provisions on crypto asset service providers were added to the Capital Markets Law No. 6362; the activity of platforms was made subject to the permission of the Capital Markets Board, and a provisional Article 11 titled “Transitional provisions on crypto asset service providers” was inserted into the Law.
Although this change strengthened the obligations of platforms on permission, supervision and protection of customer assets, it does not by itself bring a solution on arbitration clauses in user agreements. The validity of an arbitration clause will again be assessed within the framework of the arbitration provisions of the HMK and, if the conditions exist, the unfair terms review under consumer legislation.
In practice, the decision shows this: in disputes such as account freezing, transaction cancellation or refund, the authority before which the case will be heard is often decisive even before the merits. The dispute examined ended without reaching the merits, after three levels of judicial process.
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. The other decisions in the series are on the Precedent DecisionsTR page.
💬 Common Questions
Did the Court of Cassation find the crypto platform right to suspend the account?
Must the user be a merchant for the arbitration clause to be valid?
Does the court take the arbitration clause into account by itself?
Is a case brought by the platform also caught by the arbitration clause?
The information in this article is for general information purposes; the summary of the decision is taken from the text published by the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation in the Court of Cassation Decision Search system, and each case is assessed within the framework of its own contract terms and evidence. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made by relying on this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Kripto Borsasında Tahkim Şartı – Yargıtay 11. HD 2025/6256.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Fake Brokerage Site Non-Prosecution – Court of Cassation 2026/4536
- Remote Access Investment Scam: Court of Cassation 2026/6495
- Crypto Fraud KYC Trail: Court of Cassation 2026/4543
- Forex Profit Deleted: Court of Cassation 2025/6996
- SIM Swap Crypto Theft: Court of Cassation 2026/2209
- Unauthorised Crypto Withdrawal: Court Splits Fault 70/30