Fake Brokerage Site Non-Prosecution – Court of Cassation 2026/4536

In an investigation file, the most decisive sentence is sometimes not the indictment but the reasoning of the non-prosecution decision. Once the sentence “a person who sends money to another for investment of his own free will does so at his own responsibility” is accepted, the file is closed; the investigation ends without the suspects giving statements and without the money trail ever being followed. In its decision of 27.04.2026, Docket No. (E.) 2026/257, Decision No. (K.) 2026/4536, the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation described this sentence as “faulty reasoning” and reversed the final decision in the interest of the law.
What distinguishes the file is that the scheme the victim encountered was not an ordinary social media account but a site that looked like an extension of a well-known bank’s internet address, together with the claim of being a “licensed brokerage backed by a state bank”.
🖥️ The Account Reflected in the File
According to the decision, on 11.12.2023 the complainant entered, through internet ads, a site that looked like an extension of a well-known bank’s internet address. On the site, contact was made with company staff who presented themselves as a subsidiary of that bank and, in this context, as a licensed brokerage backed by a state bank.
For the purpose of stock market investment, TRY 5,000.00 was sent to a payment services joint-stock company and a total of USD 10,000.00 to an information technology industry and trade limited company. One detail the decision draws attention to is that the complainant was urged to write nothing other than the sender’s first name and surname in the description field of the transfers.
When the complainant wanted to withdraw his money after some time, he was told that, “under the regulations”, the money could not be withdrawn for six months, that it could be withdrawn as USD 32,000.00 at the end of six months, and that if he wanted to withdraw immediately, a tax of TRY 157,800.00 had to be paid in advance. The decision also states that the payment services company’s address was closed and that it had the nature of a shell company, and that the firm was not a registered and licensed brokerage.
⚖️ The Reasoning for Non-Prosecution and the Chamber’s Characterisation
The Küçükçekmece Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office decided not to prosecute by its decision of 15.05.2024. The reasoning is reproduced verbatim in the Court of Cassation’s decision: that the complainant should have known there was a chance of loss in his act of seeking a high return with a small amount of money in a short time; that the suspect’s conduct therefore did not amount to a qualified lie reaching the level of deceit; that the parties invested in an unregistered system while taking into account that they could lose all the money; and that a person who sends money to another for investment of his own free will does so at his own responsibility.
The Küçükçekmece 1st Criminal Judgeship of Peace rejected the objection by its decision of 26.08.2024, Miscellaneous No. 2024/7516; since this decision is final in nature under Article 271/4 CMK, it became final the same day. The Chamber expressly described this reasoning in its decision as “faulty reasoning”.
📘 The Framework of Articles 160, 172 and 173 CMK
The Chamber based its assessment on three articles. Under Article 160 CMK, as soon as the public prosecutor learns of a situation giving the impression that an offence has been committed, he immediately begins investigating the truth of the matter; to establish the material truth, he collects and secures, through judicial police officers, the evidence both in favour of and against the suspect. Article 172 CMK provides that a decision of non-prosecution is given where no evidence creating sufficient suspicion for bringing a public case can be obtained.
Article 173 CMK sets out the powers of the reviewing authority. In the decision these powers are grouped under three heads: rejection of the objection where there is no sufficient evidence, acceptance of the objection where there is sufficient evidence, or expansion of the investigation because of an incomplete investigation. According to the Chamber, the third option comes into play when there is no investigation in accordance with the law.
🔍 The Investigations That Were Required
The Chamber listed concretely the investigations that were not carried out in the file:
- Taking the statements of the suspects.
- Obtaining the trade registry records and identifying the officers and partners of the companies.
- Establishing beyond doubt whether the companies are active and, if so, what their fields of activity are.
- Obtaining the bank account movements.
- Establishing the full identity and address details of the users of the phone lines used for calls.
- Examining the correspondence in the file.
The decision states that, according to the result of these investigations, it must be assessed and determined whether the elements of fraud or of the offence of acting contrary to Law No. 6362 are present in the specific case.
🏛️ Why Law No. 6362 at the Same Time?
In the decision, the subject of the investigation is given as “fraud through the use of information systems, banks or credit institutions as tools”. In addition, the Chamber asked that, depending on the result of the investigation, the offence of acting contrary to the Capital Markets Law No. 6362 also be assessed.
The reason is that the firm in the file presented itself as a licensed brokerage. Unauthorised activity in the capital markets is an offence separate from and independent of fraud; one act may concern both heads at the same time. For another decision showing the same approach, the series’ decision on unauthorised capital markets activityTR may be read.
📌 The Decision and Its Effect
By its letter of 25.12.2025 the Ministry of Justice requested reversal in the interest of the law under Article 309/1 CMK; the Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office at the Court of Cassation sent the file to the Chamber with its written opinion of 08.01.2026. The Chamber accepted the request, unanimously reversed the criminal judgeship of peace’s decision under Article 309/3 CMK and ordered the file to be sent back to its place of origin.
The criterion the decision carries is this: that an investment arrangement is unregistered and that the victim is regarded as having assumed the risk does not mean there was no deceit. The other side presenting itself as a licensed institution, money being collected through shell companies, and new payments being requested at the withdrawal stage show that the assessment of deceit can only be made after an investigation. For a similar framework, the decision on money collected with a monthly profit promiseTR may also be read.
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. The other decisions in the series are in the Precedent DecisionsTR section.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Why was the reasoning of "his own responsibility" rejected in the decision?
How did the request for additional payment to withdraw the money appear in the decision?
What can the criminal judgeship of peace do on an objection?
Does a reversal decision mean the suspects will be punished?
The information in this article is for general information purposes; the summary of the decision is taken from the published text of the relevant 11th Criminal Chamber decision of the Court of Cassation, and each case is assessed with its own evidence. A decision of reversal in the interest of the law does not conclusively end the investigation. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made by relying on this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Sahte Borsa Aracı Kurum Sitesi – Yargıtay 11. CD 2026/4536.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Remote Access Investment Scam: Court of Cassation 2026/6495
- Crypto Fraud KYC Trail: Court of Cassation 2026/4543
- Forex Profit Deleted: Court of Cassation 2025/6996
- SIM Swap Crypto Theft: Court of Cassation 2026/2209
- Unauthorised Crypto Withdrawal: Court Splits Fault 70/30
- Fake Investment Platform USDT: Crypto Exchange Liability Ruling