Qualified Fraud Court Change in Türkiye: Constitutional Court Ruling

Most fraud cases committed with promises of forex, cryptocurrency or high stock market returns are prosecuted as qualified fraud under Article 158 of the Turkish Penal Code (TCK), because computer systems or banks are used as instruments. For years these cases belonged to the high criminal courts, which sit with a panel of three judges. Law No. 7571 of 24 December 2025 changed this: qualified fraud was removed from the list of cases heard by the high criminal courts and given to the single-judge criminal courts of first instance (asliye ceza). Three of these courts considered the change contrary to the Constitution and took the question to the Constitutional Court; the Court rejected the objection unanimously.
In its decision of 13 May 2026, Docket No. (E.) 2026/10 and Decision No. (K.) 2026/111, the Constitutional Court held that removing the words “qualified fraud (Art. 158)” from Article 12 of Law No. 5235 through Article 12 of Law No. 7571 is not contrary to Articles 2, 36, 37 and 142 of the Constitution, and rejected the objection. The application concerning provisional Article 7, the transitional provision, was rejected for lack of jurisdiction, because the applicant court had no occasion to apply that provision. The decision was published in the Official Gazette No. 33333 of 7 August 2026.
- How did Law No. 7571 change the jurisdiction rule?
- The objections of the criminal courts of first instance
- Preliminary examination: why was provisional Article 7 not reviewed?
- The Constitutional Court's assessment on the merits
- Effect on investment fraud cases
- The transition period and jurisdiction objections
- The current picture under TCK Article 158
- Frequently asked questions
🏛️ How Did Law No. 7571 Change the Jurisdiction Rule?
Article 12 of Law No. 5235 on the Establishment, Duties and Powers of the First Instance Courts of the Judiciary and the Regional Courts of Appeal lists, one by one, the offences that the high criminal courts hear. Before the amendment, this list included robbery, extortion by an official, forgery of official documents (Art. 204/2) and fraudulent bankruptcy, as well as qualified fraud (Art. 158). Article 12 of Law No. 7571 removed these words from the text.
Under Article 11 of the same Law, the criminal courts of first instance are the courts of general jurisdiction, hearing all cases and matters that fall outside the duties of the criminal judgeship of peace and the high criminal court. As the Constitutional Court also stressed in its decision, once the words were removed, qualified fraud cases automatically came within the jurisdiction of the criminal courts of first instance.
The explanatory memorandum of the Law states two aims:
- to prevent jurisdiction disputes arising from the trial of simple fraud (TCK Art. 157) and qualified fraud (Art. 158) in different courts,
- to conclude trials for these offences within a reasonable time by building specialisation in the criminal courts of first instance, and to combat the offence more effectively.
Article 13 of the same Law added provisional Article 7 to Law No. 5235. Under this provision, in qualified fraud cases that are pending before the high criminal courts on the date of entry into force, or that are at the stage of appeal or cassation review, no decision of lack of jurisdiction or reversal may be made merely because the jurisdiction rule has changed; these cases continue to be heard under the old jurisdiction rules until a final judgment.
⚖️ The Objections of the Criminal Courts of First Instance
The three criminal courts of first instance that examined qualified fraud cases after the change stated that the jurisdiction rule is a precondition of the case and must therefore be treated as a “rule to be applied in the case”, and they applied to the Constitutional Court under Article 152 of the Constitution. The main arguments in their referral decisions were as follows:
- The balance between the gravity of the offence and trial safeguards: It was argued that, although the lower and upper limits of the penalty in TCK Article 158 did not change, assigning a single judge instead of a panel upset proportionality.
- The weakness of the jurisdiction dispute rationale: It was stressed that hearing the simple and qualified forms of the offence in different courts does not create a real jurisdiction dispute, and that the basic and qualified forms of TCK Article 204 are still heard in different courts.
- Reasonable time: One of the courts, referring to Ministry of Justice statistics, noted that in 2024 some 288,400 cases were opened before the high criminal courts and 1,874,556 before the criminal courts of first instance; it argued that adding these offences to already congested courts would prolong trials.
- The principle of the statutory judge: It was argued that the change of jurisdiction alters, after the date of the offence, the court to which a person is subject.
🔎 Preliminary Examination: Why Was Provisional Article 7 Not Reviewed?
The Istanbul Anadolu 90th Criminal Court of First Instance had included in its request for annulment not only the removal of the jurisdiction wording but also provisional Article 7. The Constitutional Court rejected this part without examining the merits. The reasoning is as follows: provisional Article 7 is a transitional provision concerning cases pending before the high criminal courts or at the appeal or cassation stage. Because that provision could not be applied in a case before a criminal court of first instance, the “rule to be applied in the case” condition required for concrete norm review was not met, and the application was rejected because of the Court's lack of jurisdiction.
📜 The Constitutional Court's Assessment on the Merits
The Court examined the rule in the light of Articles 2 (the rule of law), 36 (the right to a fair hearing), 37 (the safeguard of the statutory judge) and, of its own motion, 142 (the organisation and jurisdiction of courts) of the Constitution. The main steps of the decision are as follows:
The legislature's margin of discretion: Under Article 142 of the Constitution, the organisation, duties and powers of courts are regulated by law. The Court recalled that re-determining which court is to hear a case is a change in trial procedure and lies, within constitutional limits, in the discretion of the legislature. It accepted that the aims of removing jurisdiction disputes, speeding up trials and building specialisation serve the public interest.
A single judge does not mean fewer safeguards: Perhaps the most striking sentence of the decision is that a trial conducted by a single judge does not, by itself, mean a trial with weaker safeguards for the defendant. According to the Court, the basic fair trial safeguards also apply in criminal courts of first instance, and claims that they were not observed can be reviewed through the appeal routes.
The reasonable time balance: The Court described hearing similar offences in the same court so as to build specialisation as a requirement of the principle of trial within a reasonable time; it added, however, that measures taken for this purpose must not prevent a fair decision on the merits. It saw no such obstacle in the rule before it.
The principle of the statutory judge: Because the rule contains no transitional provision, it changes the competent court for cases that were at the investigation stage on the date of entry into force. The Court therefore also examined the rule from the angle of the statutory judge safeguard. In its view, this principle prohibits setting up a court specific to a person or event after the offence; it does not prohibit giving existing courts new duties in a general and abstract manner, nor those courts hearing earlier events. Because the rule is not specific to a particular dispute, it was not found contrary to the principle.
In the end, the rule was not found contrary to the Constitution, and the objection and the related request to suspend its effect were rejected unanimously.
🧭 Effect on Investment Fraud Cases
Acts committed through fake forex platforms, cryptocurrency “advisers” or stock market signal groups are mostly assessed under TCK Article 158/1-f (use of computer systems, banks or credit institutions as instruments) or Article 158/1-h (by persons who are merchants or company managers, during their commercial activities). With this decision, the following points have become clear for such cases:
- The competent court: In qualified fraud cases opened after Law No. 7571 entered into force, the competent court is the criminal court of first instance, which has general jurisdiction; the Constitutional Court found this arrangement consistent with the Constitution.
- The penalty limits did not change: The change of jurisdiction does not touch the penalty. The imprisonment of three to ten years and the judicial fine of up to five thousand days provided in TCK Article 158/1, and the four-year lower limit in sub-paragraph (f), apply as before.
- Review through appeal routes: In answer to concerns about safeguards in single-judge trials, the Court pointed to appeal and cassation review as a safeguard.
For one of the Court of Cassation assessments on the characterisation of fraud committed with investment promises, the decision in this series on a promise of 25% monthly profit on the stock marketTR may be consulted.
⏳ The Transition Period and Jurisdiction Objections
Jurisdiction is a procedural rule examined by the court of its own motion in criminal procedure; for this reason, which rule applies to cases in the transition period matters in practice:
- For cases pending before a high criminal court on the date of entry into force and cases at the appeal or cassation stage, provisional Article 7 provides that the old jurisdiction rules apply until a final judgment. In these cases no decision of lack of jurisdiction or reversal may be made solely on the ground of the change of jurisdiction.
- For cases at the investigation stage on the date of entry into force, there is no special transitional provision. In its decision the Constitutional Court also noted that the competent court changes for these cases, and did not find this contrary to the principle of the statutory judge.
- Provisional Article 7 itself was not examined on the merits as regards its conformity with the Constitution.
🆕 The Current Picture Under TCK Article 158
Two significant changes have entered into force in the area of qualified fraud within a short time:
- Jurisdiction (Law No. 7571, 24 December 2025): Qualified fraud was removed from the list of cases heard by the high criminal courts, and the Constitutional Court found this change consistent with the Constitution in its decision of 13 May 2026.
- Handing over an account or payment instrument (Law No. 7589, 16 July 2026): Under the fourth paragraph added to TCK Article 158, where participation in the offences in Articles 157 and 158 is limited to giving another person, for the purpose of unjust gain, payment instruments such as a bank or credit card belonging to oneself or to someone else, or the essential information or means that enable the use of an account held with a bank, an intermediary institution, payment service providers or crypto-asset service providers, the penalty is reduced by half.
The Constitutional Court's decision concerns only the jurisdiction rule; it contains no assessment of Article 158/4.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Did the decision reduce the penalty for qualified fraud?
Will old cases pending before a high criminal court be sent to the criminal court of first instance?
Why does single-judge trial not breach the right to a fair trial?
Does the decision contain any finding specific to investment or crypto fraud?
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page, and the other decisions in the series are in the Precedent DecisionsTR section.
This article is for general information only; the summary is compiled from the Constitutional Court's concrete norm review decision published in the Official Gazette. Norm review decisions examine in the abstract whether a legal provision conforms to the Constitution; they do not directly determine the outcome of an individual criminal case. The competent court is assessed separately in each case, according to the date on which the case and prosecution began and the transitional provisions. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Nitelikli Dolandırıcılık Asliyede – AYM 2026/111.
More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye
- Intervening Party in Investment Fraud Trials: Court of Cassation
- Churning Refund: Istanbul Court of Appeal on Excess Trading, 2026/1348
- Crypto Fraud Abroad Is No Bar: Court of Cassation 2025/10818
- Tax Fee to Release Winnings: Court of Cassation 2026/3017
- Duplicate Complaint Non-Prosecution – Court of Cassation 2025/15028
- Arbitration Clause in Crypto Exchange – Court of Cassation 2025/6256