TR

Churning Refund: Istanbul Court of Appeal on Excess Trading, 2026/1348

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 20 November 2026

Churning Refund: Istanbul Court of Appeal on Excess Trading, 2026/1348

Every time the phone rings, a share is bought or sold, and as the account statement grows longer, the commission and loan interest items grow with it. Even if the investor verbally approved every transaction, who was really initiating them? What the market calls “churning” (çalkalama) — getting a customer to trade more often than their needs require in order to earn commission and interest income — is listed in capital markets legislation among the things intermediary institutions may not do. The 13th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal assessed the legal consequence of this conduct in the case of an investor who was moved from deposits to leveraged share trading.

In its decision of 2 July 2026, Docket No. (E.) 2023/2250 and Decision No. (K.) 2026/1348, the 13th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal found well-founded the first instance decision ordering an intermediary institution, which had set up an arrangement leading to trading more often than the investor wanted, to refund 80% of the transaction commission and 50% of the loan interest income it earned in the 2013-2015 period; it rejected the intermediary institution's appeal on the merits, unanimously. The route of appeal to the Court of Cassation remains open against the decision.

In short: A bank customer who until 2013 used only time deposits began share trading on 29 January 2013 with a capital markets instruments credit agreement with a limit of TL 150,000; the limit was later raised to TL 1,500,000 and, on 30 September 2014, to TL 2,000,000. The investor claimed that the intermediary institution in the same group as the bank had misled him and pushed him into paying high loan interest and commission. The first instance court dismissed the case against the bank for lack of standing, on the ground that the bank acted as an agent; relying on voice recordings and expert reports, it accepted that the intermediary institution had paved the way for unnecessary and frequent trading. The Regional Court of Appeal affirmed the decision, stating that most transactions were made following calls and recommendations from the customer representative and that the investor only gave approval.

🏦 From Deposits to Leveraged Share Trading

The investor who brought the case died during the proceedings, and the case was continued by his heirs. The facts reflected in the statement of claim and the decision are as follows:

  • Starting profile: Until 2013 the investor had used no investment product other than time deposits; in the customer identification forms he filled in himself, he declared that he owned real estate and had a monthly income of TL 1,000-2,000.
  • 29 January 2013: A Capital Markets Instruments Credit Agreement with a limit of TL 150,000 was signed at a bank branch.
  • Limit increases: The limit was first raised to TL 1,500,000 and, on 30 September 2014, to TL 2,000,000. The investor claimed that he was made to sign backdated forms that he had not filled in himself.
  • Cost items: According to the bank's letter of 1 November 2016, TL 454,412.96 of loan interest was paid between 2013 and 2016. According to the intermediary institution's letter of 7 December 2015, TL 31,955.63 of transaction commission was collected between 5 January 2015 and 14 August 2015.
  • 2 January 2017: The bank refunded TL 15,212.02 to the account with the description “overdraft interest accrual cancellation”.
  • Pre-trial correspondence: In the reply of 7 March 2018 to the notice served on 16 February 2018, it was stated that TL 677,768.16 of loan interest was collected between 31 March 2013 and 11 September 2017, and TL 282,262.00 of transaction commission between 31 January 2013 and 11 September 2017.

Arguing that the bank was responsible for the period before 31 August 2015 and the intermediary institution for the period after, the investor sought, for the time being, TL 500,000 with commercial advance interest, to be collected from the defendants jointly and severally.

🛡️ The Defences of the Bank and the Intermediary Institution

The bank raised an objection of lack of standing, stating that there was no contract between it and the investor for buying and selling shares, that it had signed the framework agreement as the agent of the intermediary institution, and that all records and documents were with the intermediary institution.

The intermediary institution, for its part, relied on the following defences:

  • that the investor had stated in one of his petitions that he had been trading for 60 years, which contradicted his low income declaration,
  • that he followed daily transactions in person in the trading room and signed all the contracts himself,
  • that the possibility of loss was explained in the risk disclosure forms,
  • that most orders were given verbally and recorded in accordance with the legislation,
  • that the account statements were not objected to in time and that transactions continued for two years after the 2015 complaint.

📊 The First Instance Court's Allocation of Fault

The Istanbul 19th Commercial Court of First Instance (21 September 2023, Docket No. (E.) 2019/9, Decision No. (K.) 2023/579) relied on the reports of two expert panels dated 5 January 2022 and 24 January 2023. The court stated that the dispute was based on the agreements dated 25 December 2012, 29 January 2013, 7 January 2014, 11 September 2014 and 14 January 2015, and that although the bank had signed the framework agreement, it had done so as the agent of the intermediary institution; it therefore dismissed the case against the bank for lack of passive standing.

As to the intermediary institution, it based its decision on the voice recordings. According to the court, the investor was generally aware of the transactions on his account, took notes and asked questions; however, he was in the position of approving a decision already made, not of making the initial decision. Although it could not find that the investor's will had been impaired, the court accepted that the representatives, through their constant buying and selling conduct, had influenced the high number of trades on the account.

Earning commission and side income by making a customer carry out unnecessary transactions was found contrary to Articles 2 and 3 of the Turkish Civil Code (TMK). The court also found a breach of Article 58 of the repealed Communiqué on the Principles Regarding Intermediary Activities and Intermediary Institutions for the period before 1 July 2014, and, for the period after, of Article 56, titled “Acts and Transactions That Investment Institutions May Not Carry Out”, of Communiqué No. III-39.1 on the Principles of Establishment and Operation of Investment Institutions. In the end, it held that a refund of 80% of the transaction commission benefit and 50% of the loan interest income obtained by the intermediary institution would be in line with fairness and equity, and partly upheld the case against the intermediary institution.

📎 Full text of the decision: The decision was verified by docket and decision number in the Ministry of Justice case-law database (mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr).

🧮 The Regional Court of Appeal's Reasoning

On appeal, the intermediary institution argued that the loan interest and commission rates applied were below what could have been applied, that the investor knew these rates, that his will had not been impaired, and that merely giving recommendations does not create liability. The Chamber did not find these objections well-founded and relied on the following findings:

  • Low rates are not enough: The fact that interest and commission rates were low and that the investor knew of them is not sufficient for the amounts collected to be regarded as justified.
  • The representative initiated the transactions: Share purchases and sales did not take place, as the agreements provided, on the investor's own written or verbal orders, but mostly through the representative calling him and giving recommendations; in the great majority of transactions the investor only gave approval.
  • Lack of knowledge and experience: The investor has no knowledge or experience of the capital markets.
  • Misinformation: The representative misinformed the investor that a trading ban would be applied if the collateral fell.
  • Trading frequency for income: By making the investor trade more, the intermediary institution caused him to use extra credit and pay interest, and itself to earn more commission; it took advantage of the investor's lack of knowledge and experience.

The Chamber confirmed that this conduct was contrary to Article 58 of the communiqué applied until 1 July 2014 and to Article 56 of Communiqué No. III-39.1 applied afterwards. It stated that the part of the commission and loan interest earned in 2013-2015 that corresponds to fault must be refunded as the investor's loss, and that the fault rates in the expert report were consistent with the case file. The Chamber referred to its earlier decision in the same direction of 12 June 2025 (Docket No. (E.) 2024/1167, Decision No. (K.) 2025/961) and to the decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation of 29 April 2026 (Docket No. (E.) 2025/5420, Decision No. (K.) 2026/2438) affirming it. The appeal was rejected on the merits under Article 353/1-b-1 of the Civil Procedure Code (HMK).

🎙️ Voice Recordings and the Trading Pattern

The most decisive aspect of the decision for proof is how the transcripts of telephone calls were read. The intermediary institution had argued that every transaction was made with the investor's approval and that this was on record. The courts, however, looked not at the existence of approval but at who initiated the transaction and how often. Some of the statements quoted from the transcripts are as follows:

  • The investor saying to the representative: “I am a new student, from now on you will do your best for me, you will teach me this business” and “now whatever you say, I will not interfere”,
  • The representative suggesting to the investor, “I am following it, do not worry”,
  • The investor being called frequently at short intervals, and the representative giving information about a certain company's shares in standardised sentences.

According to the first instance court's finding, the occasions on which the investor objected were mostly about the sale of shares he had bought; while the investor tended to buy and hold, the representatives constantly pushed towards buying and selling. The recordings also show that the investor complained about his earlier transactions in a call of 10 December 2015, but that the same pattern of instructions continued afterwards.

This approach is distinct from situations in which a claim of steering could not be proved. Indeed, in the decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, 2025/5562, on steering by an intermediary institutionTR in this series, the case was dismissed because it could not be proved that advice was given and that the will was impaired. In the present case, although no impairment of will was found, the fact that trading frequency had been arranged in favour of the intermediary institution was in itself treated as a ground of liability.

💡 The Decision's Effect on Investment Relationships

The decision is a notable example of how loss can be defined in disputes between an intermediary institution and an investor. What was compensated here is not a portfolio loss arising from market movements, but the commission and loan interest paid because of excessive trading.

  • The fact that every transaction was verbally approved did not prevent a finding that the trading arrangement was set up in favour of the intermediary institution.
  • The mismatch between the low income declaration in the customer identification forms and credit limits of millions of liras was put forward by the claimant as one of the main bases of the claim.
  • The case against the bank, which signed the framework agreement as an agent, was dismissed for lack of standing; liability was directed at the intermediary institution.
  • The refund rates (80% for commission, 50% for interest) are an equitable assessment based on the fault assessment in the expert report, and are not fixed rates that can be applied unchanged in every case.

For a different view of the liability of intermediary institutions, see the Regional Court of Appeal decision on a portfolio manager's duty of careTR, and for the suitability test context, the forex suitability test decisionTR.

❓ Short Answers

Why was the intermediary institution held liable if the investor approved every transaction?

The courts did not dispute that approval existed; they looked at who initiated the transactions. According to the records, transactions mostly began with the representative's call and recommendation, and the investor, who had no knowledge or experience, only gave approval. Getting transactions made more often than needed, so as to earn commission and interest income, was found contrary to the prohibitions in the SPK communiqués and to TMK Articles 2-3.

Was the whole share loss refunded?

No. The item taken as the basis of the judgment is the transaction commission and loan interest earned by the intermediary institution in the 2013-2015 period. The first instance court ordered a refund of 80% of the commission and 50% of the loan interest, and the Regional Court of Appeal found these fault rates consistent with the case file. The total amount awarded is not stated separately in the decision.

Why was the bank that signed the loan agreement not held liable?

The first instance court accepted that the framework agreement for buying and selling capital markets instruments was signed by the bank as the agent of the intermediary institution, and dismissed the case against the bank for lack of passive standing. No appeal review against this part of the judgment is reflected in the decision; the Regional Court of Appeal examined only the intermediary institution's appeal.

Has the decision become final?

The decision was given with the route of appeal to the Court of Cassation open within two weeks of notification. However, the Chamber noted that its earlier decision in the same direction was affirmed by the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation on 29 April 2026; this shows that the approach has also passed Court of Cassation review.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page, and the other decisions in the series are in the Precedent DecisionsTR section.

This article is for general information only; the summary is compiled from the published appeal decision of the 13th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal. The decision was given with the route of appeal open, and its finality was not known at the date this article was prepared. The refund rates for commission and interest are based on the expert assessment in the case concerned. Each case is assessed on its own evidence and concrete facts. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Aşırı İşlem Yaptırmada İade – İstanbul BAM 13. HD 2026/1348.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp