TR

Intervening Party in Investment Fraud Trials: Court of Cassation

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 20 November 2026

Intervening Party in Investment Fraud Trials: Court of Cassation

In a criminal case in which money is alleged to have been collected with investment promises, who may appear in the courtroom as an “intervening party” (katılan) is often as important as the merits of the case. Is it the people who paid the money, the company in whose name the transactions were said to be made, or both? Intervening party status has concrete consequences, such as submitting evidence, appealing the judgment and being awarded legal representation fees. In a qualified fraud case in which a pension and life insurance company also took part as an intervening party, the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation made a short but practical correction on this question.

In its decision of 21 January 2026, Docket No. (E.) 2021/39708 and Decision No. (K.) 2026/849, the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation affirmed with correction the conviction for qualified fraud committed as a merchant or company manager (TCK Art. 158/1-h). The Chamber stated that the complaining company had no right under Article 237/1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK) to join the public prosecution for this offence, and removed from the judgment the wording awarding legal representation fees in the company's favour; as regards the other judgment, concerning a prison sentence of less than five years, it affirmed the supplementary decision rejecting the appeal request.

In short: The high criminal court sentenced the defendant, for acts against two separate intervening parties, under TCK Articles 158/1-h and 43/1, to 3 years 9 months' imprisonment and a judicial fine of TL 15,000 for one intervening party, and 5 years 4 months' imprisonment and a judicial fine of TL 32,000 for the other. The Regional Court of Appeal rejected the appeal on the merits, and then, for the judgment under five years, issued a supplementary decision rejecting the request for cassation appeal. The defence counsel argued that there had been a commercial relationship of nearly ten years between the parties, that the fate of the promised investment could be followed by the intervening parties, and that there was no deceit. The Court of Cassation affirmed the supplementary decision; for the other judgment it found the conviction well-founded, but held that admitting the company, which had no right to join, and awarding it a fixed legal representation fee of TL 4,360 were unlawful, and removed this wording from the judgment.

🗂️ The Course of the Case: From Izmir to the Court of Cassation

The proceedings reflected in the text of the decision have three stages:

  • First instance (10 October 2018): The Izmir 7th High Criminal Court, in its decision Docket No. (E.) 2017/324, Decision No. (K.) 2018/344, convicted the defendant of “fraud committed by persons who are merchants or company managers, or who act on behalf of a company, during their commercial activities” for acts against two separate intervening parties. For the first intervening party, 3 years 9 months' imprisonment and a judicial fine of TL 15,000 were imposed under TCK Articles 158/1-h, 43/1 and 52; for the second intervening party, 5 years 4 months' imprisonment and a judicial fine of TL 32,000 were imposed under the same articles.
  • Appeal (10 April 2019): The 13th Criminal Chamber of the Izmir Regional Court of Appeal, in its decision Docket No. (E.) 2019/366, Decision No. (K.) 2019/910, rejected the defendant's appeals on the merits under CMK Article 280/1-a.
  • Supplementary decision (14 November 2019): The same chamber rejected the request for cassation appeal against the judgment under five years.

The application of TCK Article 43/1 in both judgments shows that the acts were accepted as having been committed in a continuing manner against each intervening party. In its written opinion, the prosecution proposed affirming the supplementary decision and reversing the other judgment. On the second part, the Court of Cassation did not share the opinion to reverse.

🗣️ The Defence's Grounds of Appeal

In the petition of appeal, the defence counsel argued that the event was not a criminal dispute but the result of a long-running commercial relationship. The main objections reflected in the decision are as follows:

  • There was a commercial relationship of about ten years between the parties.
  • The money alleged to have been taken from the intervening parties was a large amount; in the ordinary course of life, the intervening parties would have been expected to question this sum and the fate of the investment promised for it.
  • One of the complainants was aware of all transactions at every stage, and the transactions were carried out with his or her consent and knowledge.
  • The transactions could be checked at any time over the internet and through bank records; therefore no deceitful conduct could be spoken of.
  • Witness statements alone were not sufficient to base a judgment on; the basic penalty was increased contrary to procedure, and the acts should be treated as a single offence.

These objections are typical examples of the “victim's ability to check” and “civil dispute” defences often met in cases where money is taken with investment promises. The Chamber did not find these defences well-founded in this case.

🔒 The Five-Year Limit and the Judgment That Could Not Be Appealed

The first part of the decision concerns the sentence of 3 years 9 months' imprisonment imposed on the first intervening party's side. Under CMK Article 286/2-a, decisions of the regional courts of appeal rejecting on the merits an appeal against prison sentences of five years or less given by first instance courts, and against judicial fines of any amount, cannot be appealed to the Court of Cassation. CMK Article 296/1 provides that if a judgment that cannot be appealed is nevertheless appealed, the regional court of appeal that gave the judgment will reject the appeal request by a decision.

The Chamber assessed these provisions together with the offences listed in CMK Article 286/3, which can be appealed despite the five-year limit (qualified fraud is not among them), and found nothing unlawful in the supplementary decision of the regional court of appeal dated 14 November 2019. The defence counsel's appeal request against this decision was rejected under CMK Article 296/2, and the supplementary decision was affirmed unanimously.

As a result, of the two judgments given against the same defendant in the same case, one never came under the Court of Cassation's review, while the other, containing a prison sentence of 5 years 4 months, was examined on the merits. This clearly shows that, in cases with more than one victim, the available appeal route is determined separately for each judgment.

🏢 The Company's Right to Join and the Legal Representation Fee

As regards the second judgment, the Chamber accepted that, under CMK Article 217, there was no error in the discretion of the court that assessed the evidence, that the claims and defences were discussed in the reasoned decision, that the act was established to have been carried out by the defendant, and that the characterisation of the offence and the sanction were correctly determined apart from the point corrected. The point corrected is as follows:

  • The first instance court had accepted the request to join of a pension and life insurance company that held the position of complainant, and had awarded this company a fixed legal representation fee of TL 4,360 in the judgment.
  • The Chamber stated that, for the qualified fraud offence being tried, the complaining company had no right to join the public prosecution under CMK Article 237/1.
  • Because this unlawfulness did not require a retrial, correction was chosen under CMK Article 303/1-h, instead of reversal under Article 302/2, and the wording on the legal representation fee was removed entirely from the operative part of the judgment.
  • The judgment, found in accordance with procedure and law in its other respects, was affirmed with correction, contrary to the written opinion and unanimously.

CMK Article 237/1 provides that the victim and natural and legal persons harmed by the offence, as well as persons with civil liability, may join the public prosecution during the prosecution stage before the first instance court until the judgment is given. The decision shows that a legal entity appearing as a complainant in the case and being named in the transactions does not, by itself, give it intervening party status. Whether a request to join is accepted is assessed according to whether the offence was directed at that person or harmed that person. Although the text of the decision does not contain a detailed reasoning on why the company was not seen as falling within this scope, the result was to remove the company's intervening party status and the legal representation fee attached to it.

📎 Full text of the decision: The decision was verified by docket and decision number in the Court of Cassation Decision Search system of the Presidency of the Court of Cassation.

📚 What Does TCK Art. 158/1-h Cover?

TCK Article 158/1-h provides as a qualified form of fraud its commission “by persons who are merchants or company managers or who act on behalf of a company, during their commercial activities; by managers of cooperatives within the activities of the cooperative”. In this form, the offender misleads the victim by using the relationship of trust that commercial life requires. In cases where money is collected with investment promises, this sub-paragraph comes into play especially when transactions are made while creating the impression of acting under a company umbrella or on behalf of a company.

In the present case, the first instance court assessed the act under this sub-paragraph, the regional court of appeal approved this view, and the Court of Cassation also accepted that the characterisation of the offence was correctly determined. For a similar assessment of the capacity of intermediaries working in insurance and pension, see the 11th Criminal Chamber decision in this series on the capacity of an agent in a fund promiseTR, and for the civil law side of the subject, the decision on the fate of a payment made to a pension intermediaryTR.

The defence's objection that “the intervening party could have followed the transactions” rests on the debate over whether the deceit in fraud is intense enough to remove the victim's ability to check. In this case the courts accepted the existence of deceitful conduct on the basis of the evidence as a whole; the Court of Cassation also found the discretion under CMK Article 217 well-founded.

🧭 Practical Takeaways

Although the decision is short, it is instructive on three points met in criminal cases in which money is alleged to have been collected with investment promises:

  1. The appeal route is determined judgment by judgment: Of the judgments given against the same defendant for different victims, those containing five years or less of imprisonment cannot be taken to the Court of Cassation where the appeal is rejected on the merits; judgments above five years are subject to cassation review.
  2. Intervening party status affects the consequences of the judgment: Admitting a legal entity with no right to join led to a legal representation fee being awarded in its favour; the Court of Cassation removed this result by way of correction.
  3. The long commercial relationship defence was not found sufficient: The defence that the relationship between the parties had lasted for years and that the intervening parties could follow the transactions did not remove the conviction in this case.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Did the Court of Cassation reverse the conviction?

No. The Chamber found the judgment containing the 5 years 4 months' prison sentence well-founded on the merits, and affirmed it with correction by removing only the wording on the legal representation fee awarded in the company's favour. The judgment on the 3 years 9 months' prison sentence, being of a kind that cannot be appealed, did not come under the Court of Cassation's review; the supplementary decision rejecting the appeal request was affirmed.

Did the company's lack of a right to join change the defendant's sentence?

No. According to the text of the decision, this correction resulted only in the removal of the wording on the fixed legal representation fee of TL 4,360 in the judgment. The part on the prison sentence and judicial fine was kept as it was.

Can a request to join be made at the Court of Cassation stage?

Under CMK Article 237/2, a request to join the case cannot be made in appeal proceedings. However, requests to join that were made before the first instance court and rejected or left undecided are examined and decided if they are expressly stated in the appeal application. In this case, the problem was that the request to join had been wrongly accepted by the first instance court.

Why did the Court of Cassation affirm although the written opinion sought reversal?

The written opinion is the view of the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Cassation and does not bind the Chamber. The Chamber stated that it saw no error in the discretion and application of the court that assessed the evidence under CMK Article 217, did not share the opinion to reverse, and affirmed the judgment with correction only as to the legal representation fee.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page, and the other decisions in the series are in the Precedent DecisionsTR section.

This article is for general information only; the summary is compiled from the published decision of the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation affirming with correction. Because the text of the decision does not include event details such as the amount of money taken from the intervening parties and the type of investment promised, the article does not go into these matters. Each case is assessed on its own evidence and concrete facts. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Yatırım Vaadinde Katılma Hakkı – Yargıtay 11. CD 2026/849.

More from Investment Fraud & Crypto Law in Türkiye

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp