TR

Bank System Error Credited a Card: İzmir Appeal Court Ruling

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 18 November 2026

Bank System Error Credited a Card: İzmir Appeal Court Ruling

Many people who believe they have made profits on trading platforms abroad use e-wallets and payment systems, rather than bank transfers, to bring that money into Türkiye. The money is sent through person-to-person transfer methods straight to a credit card or a bank account. So what happens when a transfer that shows as "rejected" on the bank's screen still reaches the account because of a system error? Can the account holder refuse to return it by saying, "this money is my foreign exchange profit, let the bank claim it from the person who sent it"? The İzmir Regional Court of Appeal, 11th Civil Chamber, answered this question with a ruling in favour of the bank.

In its decision of 27.03.2025, Docket No. (E.) 2022/1563, Decision No. (K.) 2025/549, the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal, 11th Civil Chamber dismissed on the merits the appeal of an account holder who, on the same day, had moved to another bank an amount credited to a credit card because of a system error. The first-instance judgment, which awarded a principal claim of 35,904.46 Turkish lira (TL) and 20 per cent enforcement denial compensation, therefore stands. The decision is final because of the amount in dispute.

In short: On 29.01.2018, a company's credit card was credited with a total of 36,418.80 TL in five separate transactions, made through the person-to-person money transfer method of an international card network. The transactions had in fact been rejected by both the bank and the card system; because of a system error the amount reached the card and then the deposit account. About 27 minutes after the credit, the money was sent to another bank by EFT through internet banking. The bank started enforcement proceedings on the basis of unjust enrichment. The account-holding company argued that the money was profit from foreign exchange trading and that the right counterparty was the non-party sender. The courts found in favour of the bank.

💳 Why Did a Rejected Transfer Reach the Account?

According to the text of the decision, the defendant company was a customer who held deposit accounts at a branch of the claimant bank in İzmir and used a credit card issued by the same bank. The dispute concerns a money transfer method developed by an international card network and used for person-to-person transfers. As a member of this network, the claimant bank enables its cardholders to make transactions with this method.

On 29.01.2018, five separate money transfers were requested from a virtual card to the defendant's credit card. According to the expert report and the records obtained by the court from the card system, all five of these transactions were rejected. Even so, because of an error in the bank's system, the transaction amounts were credited to the defendant's credit card and moved from there to the deposit account.

The timeline in the decision is quite clear:

  • 14:05: 36,418.80 TL was credited to the defendant company's deposit account.
  • 14:32: 36,400 TL was sent by EFT through internet banking to an account at another bank.
  • Afterwards: The bank sent a formal notice demanding a refund within 24 hours; when no payment was made, 09.02.2018 was accepted as the date of default.
  • 16.05.2018: The bank started enforcement proceedings without a court judgment for a principal claim of 36,371.12 TL and accrued interest of 541.78 TL; after the defendant's objection, the proceedings were stayed.

The expert report established that the bank had received no money from the card system for the rejected transactions, yet had credited the defendant's account, and had therefore suffered a loss.

🛡️ The Account Holder's Three Objections

In its response and appeal petitions, the defendant company objected to the bank's claim on three grounds:

  • Objection on standing: The money was said to have been sent not by the defendant company but by a non-party individual, from that person's account in an electronic payment system; the bank should therefore claim its money from that person.
  • Objection on profit: The non-party individual was said to have traded on some foreign exchanges and sent the income to the defendant's card through an e-wallet account; the transferred amount was said to include final payments approved by the bank and its affiliates, which the bank had not separated out.
  • Objection on the scope of the refund: The defendant could allegedly be liable only for the amount still in its hands, and since the claim was disputed, the conditions for enforcement denial compensation were said not to be met.

The defendant also asked for a report from a new panel of experts, including people with knowledge of bank IT systems and international exchange activity, and for written enquiries to be sent to the exchange companies and the money transfer company.

⚖️ What Did the First-Instance Court and the Appeal Court Say?

In its decision of 10.03.2022, the İzmir 5th Commercial Court of First Instance relied on the expert report. In the court's view, the transactions credited to the credit card fell within the card network's transfer system, and the rejection of the five disputed transactions was documented both by the bank's records and by records obtained from the card system. No money had entered the bank for the rejected transactions, yet the defendant's account had been credited.

The court therefore accepted that the defendant had been enriched at the bank's expense without a valid reason; it partly cancelled the objection and ordered the proceedings to continue for the collection of a principal claim of 35,904.46 TL with advance interest from the date of the enforcement proceedings, rejected the claim for the excess, and awarded 20 per cent enforcement denial compensation on the amount awarded.

The İzmir Regional Court of Appeal, 11th Civil Chamber, which conducted the appeal review, limited its examination to the grounds of appeal and to public order under Article 355 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK). The Chamber relied on the following findings:

  • The expert report is suitable as a basis for a judgment and for review.
  • The card system had not approved the money transfer made from the virtual card, yet the money was moved to the defendant's account.
  • To that extent the bank suffered a loss, and the defendant was enriched without a valid reason.
  • Because the claim was calculable (liquid) at the date of the enforcement proceedings, the conditions for enforcement denial compensation were met.

In the end, the Chamber dismissed the defendant's appeal on the merits under Article 353/1-b-1 of the HMK, saw no need for a hearing, and issued the decision as final because of the amount, under Article 362/1-a of the HMK.

📎 Full text of the decision: The decision of the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal, 11th Civil Chamber, dated 27.03.2025, E.2022/1563, K.2025/549, can be read here as a PDF.

📚 Assessment From the Unjust Enrichment Angle

Article 77 of the Turkish Code of Obligations provides that a person who is enriched from another's assets without a valid reason must give that enrichment back. Credits made by banks as a result of a system error are one of the typical areas where this provision applies: behind the amount reaching the account there is no valid payment instruction and no completed transfer.

In this case, the defendant's objection on standing really rested on the question of in whose hands the enrichment arose. According to the defendant, the money had been sent by the non-party individual, so there was no direct relationship between the bank and itself. The courts, however, accepted that the decisive point was that the bank had received no amount from the card system because of the rejected transactions. Since the non-party individual's transfer request had been rejected, there was no legally completed flow of money from that person to the defendant; the amount that reached the account came out of the bank's own resources. The enrichment arose in the defendant's account and the corresponding loss in the bank's assets.

The defendant's argument that "I am liable only for what remains in my hands" is an objection that can be assessed under Article 79 of the Code of Obligations. That article provides that the enriched person must return what remains, except for the part that they prove had left their hands by the time the refund was requested; however, a person who disposed of the enrichment in bad faith, or who should have taken into account when disposing of it that they might have to return it later, must return all of it. The decision does not discuss this argument separately; the calculation in the first-instance judgment was adopted by the Chamber as it stood. The fact that the money was moved to another bank shortly after reaching the account is a prominent feature of the case.

A similar "system error" discussion in the context of shares is covered in the article on a share block caused by a system errorTR, and another unjust enrichment dispute is covered in the article on a fund claim arising from bank embezzlementTR.

🧾 Enforcement Denial Compensation and Liquid Claims

Under Article 67/2 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK), if the debtor's objection is found unjustified in an action to annul the objection, the debtor is, at the creditor's request, ordered to pay enforcement denial compensation of not less than twenty per cent of the claim. In case law, this requires the claim to be liquid, that is, determined or determinable.

The defendant had objected to the compensation, arguing that the claim was disputed and had been determined through an expert review. The Chamber, however, found that the claim was calculable at the date of the enforcement proceedings. Indeed, the amount credited to the card is plainly visible in the bank's records, and the date of default had been fixed by the formal notice. According to the decision, having an amount that can be derived from account movements and system records confirmed by an expert did not stop the claim from being liquid.

🌍 What It Means for People Withdrawing Money From Foreign Platforms

Although the decision is not directly an investment dispute, it is notable because it shows the risks that can arise when profits said to come from foreign trading platforms are moved into Türkiye through e-wallets and card networks:

  • Describing the source of a transfer as "exchange profit" does not make valid a transaction that appears as rejected in the bank's system records. What is decisive is whether the transaction was approved in the payment system.
  • The argument that the money was sent by a third party did not, on its own, remove liability where the enrichment arose in the account holder's hands.
  • Documents obtained from card networks and bank records are at the centre of proof in cases of this kind. The defendant's requests for additional experts and written enquiries were not seen as affecting the outcome, because the existing report was suitable for review.
  • The timing between an unexpected amount reaching the account and that amount being quickly moved to other accounts can matter in discussions about the scope of the refund.

💬 Questions and Answers

Can the bank ask for money back that landed in an account through a system error?

In this decision, it was accepted that it can. Because no money had entered the bank for the rejected transactions, yet the account holder had been credited, it was concluded that the account holder had been unjustly enriched within the meaning of Article 77 of the Code of Obligations.

Why was the argument that someone else sent the money not accepted?

According to the court, the non-party individual's money transfer request had been rejected by the card system. There was therefore no completed transfer from that person to the defendant; the amount that reached the account came out of the bank's own resources. Because the enrichment arose in the account holder's hands, the repayment obligation was directed at the account holder.

What amount did the defendant end up having to pay?

The first-instance court ordered the proceedings to continue for the collection of a principal claim of 35,904.46 TL with advance interest from the date of the enforcement proceedings, rejected the claim for the excess, and awarded 20 per cent enforcement denial compensation on that amount. Because the appeal was dismissed on the merits, this judgment stands.

Can this decision be taken to the Court of Cassation?

No. The Chamber issued the decision as final because of the amount, under Article 362/1-a of the HMK; since the value of the claim is below the appeal threshold, there is no route to appeal on points of law in this case.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page; other decisions on banking and investment disputes can be found on the Court DecisionsTR page.

The information in this article is for general information only and may not be up to date; it has been compiled from the appeal decision of the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal, 11th Civil Chamber, published through the Bedesten database (mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr). In the decision text, the names of the parties, the card network and the banks are anonymised at the source. The result reached in the decision rests on the expert report, the bank and card system records in that particular case. In a case that looks similar, the result may differ depending on the transaction records, the time the money left the account, the good faith of the parties and the court's assessment. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Sistem Hatasıyla Geçen Transfer – İzmir BAM 11. HD 2025/549.

More from Turkish Court Decisions

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp