TR

Chargeback Refused: Bank Liability, Istanbul Appeal Court 2026/266

Savun Law & Consultancy · Updated 16 November 2026

Chargeback Refused: Bank Liability, Istanbul Appeal Court 2026/266

When an order paid for online by credit card never arrives, the first thing that comes to the cardholder's mind is a spending dispute, that is, the chargeback process. But when the card-issuing bank closes the process with the seller's answer that "we did not draw up these contracts", what must the court establish in the compensation case the cardholder brings against the bank? In a case concerning purchases made in US dollars from a company based in Northern Cyprus, the 13th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal stressed that neither the limitation defence nor the currency of the amount drawn from the card can be left unanswered.

By its decision dated 12.02.2026, Docket No. (E.) 2023/1008, Decision No. (K.) 2026/266, the 13th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal set aside the decision of the 13th Commercial Court of First Instance of Istanbul dated 17.02.2023 (E. 2021/484, K. 2023/136), which had partly accepted the claim, on the appeals of both parties, and sent the case back to the court of first instance for a new hearing.

In short: Using credit cards and virtual cards issued by the defendant bank, the claimant bought 15 mobile phones from two websites by distance sale between June and July 2016 and paid a total of 16,850 USD. When the products were not delivered, the claimant lodged a spending dispute on 07.09.2016; after the seller stated that it had not drawn up the contracts, the bank closed the dispute. The court of first instance held that the bank had not fulfilled its duty to investigate and partly accepted the claim. The Chamber found that no decision had been given on the bank's limitation objection and that the currency in which the money was collected had not been established from the statements, and set the decision aside under Article 353/1-a-6 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK).

📦 Fifteen Phones, Two Websites, Products Never Delivered

According to the facts accepted by the Chamber as established, the claimant concluded distance sales contracts through two websites and bought 15 mobile phones from a limited company that was not a party to the case. The payments were made with a credit card used by the claimant and belonging to the defendant bank. According to the findings of the court of first instance, the purchases were made between 01.06.2016 and 11.07.2016 with a main card and the virtual cards linked to it.

According to the claimant's account, the products were to be delivered within 30 days under the contract. The seller company is based in the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, was founded in 2010, and its fields of activity include automated trade, online trade, marketing and investment business. The products were not delivered within the period stated in the contract or afterwards.

The claimant sought, as a partial claim, the recovery of 1,500 USD for the time being with rediscount interest from the date of the unlawful deduction; in the amendment petition the claimant stated that the main claim was 16,850 USD.

🔎 Why Was the Spending Dispute Closed?

On 07.09.2016 the claimant applied to the bank and asked for the expenditures to be examined within the framework of the rules of the international card payment system. After the requested documents were submitted, the bank asked the seller, through the seller's bank, for copies of the distance sales contracts. When the seller stated that the contracts had not been drawn up by it, the bank informed the claimant that the dispute could not be processed. According to the findings of the court of first instance, the bank ended the chargeback process with its reply dated 30.01.2017.

According to the bank's defence:

  • The transactions were made over the internet, by a method in which the card was not physically used, with the claimant's knowledge and consent.
  • Under the card scheme's rules, for products or services to be delivered at a later date the cardholder must present the contract drawn up by the merchant; otherwise the chargeback request cannot be fulfilled.
  • The passwords and SMS messages sent to customers always stated that the password must not be shared with anyone.
  • Investigating the reliability of the company and its website is the cardholder's obligation; the claim is also time-barred.

🏛️ The First-Instance Court's Approach to the Duty to Investigate

The 13th Commercial Court of First Instance of Istanbul characterised the case as a claim for pecuniary damages arising from a banking transaction and based on breach of contract. Its assessment, made together with the main and supplementary expert reports, can be summarised as follows:

  • A separate distance sales contract was drawn up for each transaction; the contracts contained the product, delivery date, amount and card number, and were approved electronically by the buyer.
  • The claimant objected in time, while the seller, during the chargeback process, submitted no document showing that it had delivered the products and merely stated that the contracts were not its own.
  • Under the chargeback rules designed to make e-commerce safe, the bank issuing the card has a duty to investigate. Since no document was submitted showing that it had been queried whether the payments reached the account of the company shopped at through the correspondent bank, this investigation was held not to have been carried out.
  • If the spending amounts reached the merchant's account, the merchant will have collected the price of products it did not deliver, so the bank must cancel the transactions and refund the amounts to the cardholder.

The court accepted that a total of 43,183.77 TL had been collected from the claimant's card account and that the bank's liability would start from 30.01.2017, the date on which it ended the chargeback process, and partly accepted the claim.

🔁 The Appeal Grounds of Both Parties

Both parties objected to the decision. The claimant's counsel argued that it cannot be accepted that Turkish lira equivalent to dollars was drawn from the account without establishing the currency in which the payments were made; that the statements sent by the bank did not belong to June and July 2016, when the transactions were made; that statements were issued for the card in both foreign currency and Turkish lira; that otherwise the real loss must be determined under the principle of equalising justice; and that interest must run from the date of the unlawful deduction.

The defendant bank's counsel argued that all responsibility lay with the claimant, that the transactions were made with a password, that the bank had taken all possible measures, that the burden of investigating the security of the company and the site lay with the claimant, that the claimant was seriously at fault and that the compensation claims were time-barred.

⚖️ The Chamber's Two Grounds for Setting Aside

The Chamber limited its review under Article 355 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) to the appeal grounds and public order, and described the case as a claim for compensation of the loss suffered because of the rejection of the spending dispute lodged with the bank over products bought on the internet and not delivered. The setting-aside decision has two legs.

1. The limitation defence on which no decision was given. The bank raised the limitation objection both in its answer petition and in its statement against the amendment. The court of first instance gave no decision, favourable or unfavourable, on this objection, and did not assess it in the reasoned decision either. The Chamber found the bank's appeal ground on this point well founded.

2. Uncertainty about the currency and the amount collected. The main and supplementary reports accepted that 43,183.77 TL had been collected, relying on a statement in the bank's reply letter sent to the claimant in 2016. However, the credit card statements obtained for the file do not cover the relevant period, and the expenditures in dispute do not appear in these documents. According to the Chamber, the following needs to be done:

  1. The credit card statements showing the disputed expenditures must be requested again from the bank.
  2. If necessary, the expert panel must be made to carry out an on-site examination of the bank records.
  3. The currency, date and amount in which collection was made from the claimant's card must be established in a report open to review.

The transfer of the expert reports' findings word for word into the reasoned decision, and the failure to assess the claimant's allegations against concrete evidence, were found to be erroneous. For these reasons, the appeals of the parties' counsel were accepted, the decision was set aside under Article 353/1-a-6 of the HMK, and the case was returned to its court. The decision was given on 12.02.2026, as final and unanimously, under Article 362/1-g of the HMK.

📎 Text of the decision: The decision of the 13th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal has been compiled as published on Bedesten (mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr) and verified in the Court of Cassation decision search system; party names and card numbers are anonymised in the source.

📚 Law No. 5464 and the Burden of Proof

The claimant based the claim on Article 32 of the Law on Bank Cards and Credit Cards, No. 5464. Under the second paragraph of this article, in disputes between the card-issuing institution and the cardholder, the burden of proving that the transaction was recorded without error, was posted to the account, and that there was no technical insufficiency or failure lies with the card-issuing institution. The first paragraph of the same article places the burden of proof on the merchant in disputes arising from transactions made by giving the card number through means such as telephone, electronic media or an order form.

Article 33 of the Law also provides that institutions issuing cards and concluding merchant agreements must show the necessary prudence and care in fulfilling their obligations. The first-instance court's "duty to investigate" approach is related to this framework. However, the Chamber neither approved nor rejected this approach; the assessment of the merits will be made by the first-instance court once the limitation question and the amount collected have been clarified.

For a similar currency discussion, see the article on payments to a foreign platform, the case against an overseas platform intermediary, and for the bank's duty of care on the receiving side, the article on the bank in an IBAN–name mismatchTR.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Did the Chamber decide that the bank was liable?

No. The Chamber did not reach a conclusion on whether the bank was at fault. It set the decision aside because the limitation defence had not been assessed at all and the currency of the amount collected had not been established from the statements.

Why was the failure to assess the limitation objection a ground for setting aside?

When a limitation defence is raised, the court must give a decision on it, favourable or unfavourable. In this case the bank raised the objection in two separate petitions, but the reasoned decision gave it no place. The Chamber accepted this as a justified appeal ground for the defendant.

Why does the question of dollars or Turkish lira matter?

The claimant argued that the purchases were made in dollars and that the collection from the card was also made in dollars, and claimed 16,850 USD. The expert reports, relying on the bank's letter, accepted a collection of 43,183.77 TL. Because the statements did not cover the relevant period, it remained unclear which amount was drawn in which currency; the amount of compensation depends on this finding.

How was the seller's answer that "we did not draw up the contracts" treated in the case?

The bank closed the dispute relying on this answer. The first-instance court held that the seller had submitted no document on delivery and that the bank had not investigated whether the payments reached the seller's account. The Chamber gave no opinion on this assessment.

For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. Contact details are on the contact page, and similar decisions are in the Precedent DecisionsTR archive.

This article is for general information; its content is compiled from the decision of the 13th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal published on Bedesten. The decision is a setting-aside decision; it contains no finding on the merits about the bank's fault, limitation or the amount of compensation. The outcome of the case in the retrial is not known. Different results may be reached in cases where the card scheme rules, the payment method and the evidence differ. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for any application, lawsuit or defence made on the basis of this article.

3 attorneys registered with the Istanbul Bar Association · verifyGoogle 4.8 ★ · 127+ reviews · seeOffice in Istanbul · English-speaking team · about us
Attorney Veli Savun

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235

Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.

Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.

Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:

About your personal data

Savun Law & Consultancy processes your question or comment in order to publish and answer it. If you tick the contact box, your phone number is used only to contact you (Turkish Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5/2-c and f). Your nickname and text are published; your phone number, IP address and the uncleaned version of your text are not. Contact records are deleted within 12 months at the latest. You may exercise your rights under Art. 11 by contacting our office.

Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →

This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Chargeback Reddinde Banka – İst. BAM 13. HD 2026/266.

More from Turkish Court Decisions

All articles in this section →

WhatsApp