Overstayed Foreign-Plated Car in Türkiye: Court of Cassation 2026/121

If a foreign-registered car enters the country at a border gate on an entry form, using tourist facilities, and is not taken out of the country once its permitted period has expired, is there a smuggling offence or a customs misdemeanour under customs legislation? The answer decides not only the amount of the penalty but also what happens to the car: if it is an offence, the car becomes the subject of a confiscation debate; if it is a misdemeanour, the law must contain an express provision before ownership can be transferred to the state.
In its decision dated 25.02.2026, Docket No. E.2024/273, Decision No. K.2026/121, the Criminal General Assembly of the Court of Cassation held that failing to take out in time a car brought into the country under the temporary import regime, after being subjected to customs procedures, is not the offence in Article 3(1) of the Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607 but the misdemeanour in Article 238 of Customs Law No. 4458. By majority, the Assembly upheld the local court's judgment of acquittal and refusal of the confiscation request, and set aside the Special Chamber's decision of dismissal and confiscation.
- The two questions before the Assembly
- The story of the Georgian-plated car
- Preliminary issue: can the Court of Cassation order confiscation directly?
- The main issue: offence or misdemeanour?
- What happens to the car when the act is a misdemeanour
- The view put forward in the dissenting opinion
- Limits of the decision and takeaways
- Frequently asked questions
🧩 The Two Questions Before the Assembly
The Criminal General Assembly defined the core of the dispute as whether a car brought into the country under the temporary import regime can be confiscated if it is not taken out of the country after its period of stay has ended. However, under Article 27 of the Internal Regulations of the Court of Cassation, it first addressed a preliminary issue: whether the Special Chamber, which converted the first-instance court's acquittal into a dismissal because of the statute of limitations, could set aside the provision on returning the car in the same decision and order confiscation directly.
🚗 The Story of the Georgian-Plated Car
According to the findings in the decision, officers carrying out a traffic check stopped, on suspicion, a car of the 2000 model registered in Georgia and driven by the defendant. In contact with the Customs Directorate, it emerged that the car had entered the country through the Sarp Customs Gate on 30.09.2014 and had to leave the country by 30.12.2014.
| Item | Amount in the smuggled goods assessment report |
|---|---|
| CIF value | TRY 10,000.00 |
| Customs duty | TRY 14,760.65 |
| Dutiable customs value | TRY 24,760.65 |
In his defence, the defendant said he had bought the car in Batumi for 3,500 dollars, that the registered owner had given a power of attorney through a notary to another person, that he had brought the car into the country together with that person, and that he had then parted ways with him. On these facts, the case reached different results before three different authorities:
- Diyarbakır 1st Criminal Court of First Instance (03.12.2015): It acquitted the defendant and rejected the request to confiscate the car; it provided for a letter to be sent to the Customs Directorate so that an administrative sanction could be applied regarding the car.
- 7th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation (25.01.2024): It found that the defendant had acted with smuggling intent from the outset, aiming to leave the car in the country and use it permanently; it ordered dismissal because the ordinary eight-year limitation period had expired, and by majority ordered confiscation of the car under Article 54/4 of the Turkish Penal Code (TCK), as referred to by Article 13/1 of Law No. 5607. Two members of the Chamber dissented, stating that the act fell within Article 238 of the Customs Law.
- Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor at the Court of Cassation (07.03.2024): It objected, arguing that the car had entered the country using tourist facilities and under a customs regime, that it had been seized in line with its entry identity, and that its chassis and engine numbers had not been altered. When the Chamber, by majority, did not find the objection well founded on 18.04.2024, the case came before the Criminal General Assembly.
⚙️ Preliminary Issue: Can the Court of Cassation Order Confiscation Directly?
The Assembly first recalled the nature of appeal review. As a rule, the Court of Cassation is not an authority that corrects a judgment it finds unlawful itself, but a supervisory authority that quashes the judgment and sends it back to its court. A court whose judgment has been quashed may insist on its decision or retry the case and give a new judgment; the Assembly described this process as a safeguard for the parties.
The legislature listed the exceptions to this in a limited way in Article 322 of the Code of Criminal Procedure No. 1412 (CMUK), in force at the time of the decision, and in Article 303 of Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271 (CMK). According to the Assembly, none of these cases allows the Court of Cassation to correct, against the defendant, unlawful points that lie exclusively within the trial court's discretion; and exception provisions cannot be interpreted broadly.
The Assembly stressed that confiscation is a security measure regulated in Article 54 of the TCK, that confiscation requests are regulated separately in Articles 256 et seq. of the CMK, and that under Article 257 of the CMK a hearing must in principle be held. This procedure gives those who claim rights over the property the opportunity to make statements, submit evidence and use appeal remedies. For this reason, the Assembly expressly stated that it did not adopt the reasoning and result of its earlier decision, dated 27.02.2018, E. 2017/149 – K. 2018/71, which was based on procedural economy, and accepted that the Special Chamber cannot order confiscation directly without quashing the local court's decision on return of the car.
⚖️ The Main Issue: Offence or Misdemeanour?
The Assembly resolved the main dispute on the basis of the principle of legality in crimes and penalties. Under Article 38 of the Constitution, Article 7 of the European Convention on Human Rights and Article 2 of the TCK, no penalty can be imposed for an act the law does not clearly define as an offence; provisions containing offences and penalties cannot be interpreted broadly in a way that leads to analogy.
- The typical conduct of the offence: Article 3/1 of Law No. 5607 punishes bringing goods into the country without subjecting them to customs procedures. A customs procedure means placing goods under a procedure or use approved by customs.
- Temporary import is a customs regime: Articles 128-134 of Law No. 4458 and Articles 376-394 of the Customs Regulation govern this regime. Goods that enter the country after being subjected to customs procedures under the regime fall outside the typical conduct.
- Special provision: Article 238 of the Customs Law, in force on the date of the offence, regulated violations of the temporary import provisions as a misdemeanour; for vehicles for private use temporarily imported with full exemption, it provided a fine of one quarter of the amount of customs duties.
- Each case: The car had entered by legal means with a triptych document, had been under the follow-up and control of the Customs Administration, and the expiry of the exit period could easily be established by the administration. According to the Assembly, the defendant's act did not match any of the acts in Article 3 of Law No. 5607.
A notable aspect of the decision is the Assembly's position on its own recent case law. It stated that it did not adopt the reasoning and result of its decision dated 25.10.2023, E. 2023/223 – K. 2023/556, which had accepted that the same kind of act would constitute the offence in Article 3/2 of Law No. 5607; instead it reached the same result as the decision dated 01.03.2022, E. 2018/7-131 – K. 2022/139, which treated the act as a misdemeanour. The Assembly particularly emphasised that although every offence rests on some wrong, wrongs that the law does not define as offences cannot be punished.
🔐 What Happens to the Car When the Act Is a Misdemeanour
Characterising the act as a misdemeanour also directly affected the confiscation debate. The Assembly recalled that, under Article 18 of the Misdemeanours Law, ownership of the goods that form the subject of a misdemeanour can be transferred to the state only where the law contains an express provision. Because the Customs Law contains no provision that ownership of goods under the temporary import regime is to be transferred to the state, no decision transferring ownership to the state can be made for goods in this category.
The Assembly also pointed out that the position differs where the regime provisions are violated by making it appear, through a fraudulent transaction, that the goods have been taken out of the country. In that case the offence in Article 3/4 of Law No. 5607 and the misdemeanour in the Customs Law occur together, and under Article 15/3 of the Misdemeanours Law only a penalty for the offence is imposed. No such fraudulent transaction was established in the present case.
As a result, the Assembly found no error in the local court's decision that a letter be sent to the Customs Directorate so that an administrative sanction could be applied regarding the car that was not taken out of the country after its period expired. By majority, the Assembly accepted the objection, set aside the 7th Criminal Chamber's decision on dismissal and confiscation, and upheld the judgment of the Diyarbakır 1st Criminal Court of First Instance.
🗣️ The View Put Forward in the Dissenting Opinion
The decision was taken by majority. The members who did not join the majority on the preliminary issue and on the main dispute set out a different assessment:
- It was argued that where dismissal is ordered because of the statute of limitations, the Court of Cassation may order confiscation of goods that require no further investigation and whose confiscation is mandatory under Article 54/4 of the TCK, and that the Prosecutor's Office would suffer no loss of rights because of its objection route under Article 308 of the CMK.
- It was argued that a distinction must be made between a regime right-holder who brings the car in properly at the start and later overstays the period, and a person who is not a right-holder and has an entry form issued in another person's name in order to use the car permanently in the country from the outset.
- According to the dissent, in the present case the defendant's intent from the beginning was to bring the car into the country without subjecting it to customs procedures; the act constitutes the offence of smuggling and the car should be confiscated.
🧭 Limits of the Decision and Takeaways
The decision also gives guidance on the procedure by which, and the authority by which, security measures concerning seized property may be ordered. For other disputes about seized property, the articles on confiscation of a digital device without reasonsTR and on loss of earnings on a seized vehicleTR may also be consulted.
- According to the majority of the Assembly, failing to take out in time a car that entered under the temporary import regime after customs procedures does not, on its own, constitute the offence in Article 3/1 of Law No. 5607.
- This kind of violation was assessed under the misdemeanour in Article 238 of the Customs Law; because the law contains no express provision, transferring ownership of the car to the state was seen as closed.
- Facts such as making it appear through a fraudulent transaction that the car has left the country, altering the chassis or engine number, or attempting to register with a forged document may be subject to a different legal characterisation; the decision concerns a case in which these facts were absent.
- The Special Chamber cannot order confiscation directly against the defendant without quashing the local court's decision on return.
The scope of the decision should also be noted. The Assembly relied on the legislation in force on the date of the offence; the fine rates in Article 238 of the Customs Law and the rules on temporary import periods may change over time. In addition, because the decision points in a different direction from the Assembly's 2023 decision, the course of case law on the subject is worth following.
❔ Frequently Asked Questions
Why is the defendant treated as acquitted by the Assembly?
The Assembly did not create a new acquittal; it upheld the first-instance court's judgment of 03.12.2015 acquitting the defendant and rejecting the confiscation request. The reason is that the typical elements of the alleged offence of bringing goods into the country without subjecting them to customs procedures were not met, because the car entered the country after being subjected to customs procedures under the temporary import regime.
If the act is a misdemeanour, is no sanction applied at all?
A sanction can be applied. Article 238 of the Customs Law, in force on the date of the offence, provides a fine of one quarter of the amount of customs duties for vehicles for private use temporarily imported with full exemption. The local court also ordered a letter to the Customs Directorate so that an administrative sanction could be applied, and the Assembly found this part correct.
Why could the car not be confiscated although the limitation period had expired?
The Special Chamber had ordered confiscation of the car while ordering dismissal because of the statute of limitations. The Assembly, however, characterised the act as a misdemeanour rather than an offence, and therefore accepted that Article 54/4 of the TCK and Article 13 of Law No. 5607 could not be relied on, and that under Article 18 of the Misdemeanours Law the law contains no express provision for transferring ownership to the state. On the preliminary issue, it also stated that the Chamber cannot order confiscation directly without quashing the local court's decision on return.
Does this decision not conflict with the Assembly's 2023 decision?
The Assembly itself drew attention to this difference. The text of the decision expressly states that the reasoning and result of the decision of 25.10.2023, which accepted the same kind of act as the offence in Article 3/2 of Law No. 5607, were not adopted, and the same result was reached as in the decision of 01.03.2022 treating the act as a misdemeanour. Because the decision was taken by majority, the issue may be debated again in the future.
For detailed information and legal support, you can contact Savun Law & Consultancy. The contact page gives access to contact details, and the Precedent DecisionsTR archive to other articles in the series.
This article is for general information purposes only; the summary has been compiled from the decision of the Criminal General Assembly of the Court of Cassation, published in its decision search system, accepting the objection of the Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor at the Court of Cassation. The assessment rests on the specific case, which involved a car that entered the country after being subjected to customs procedures under the temporary import regime and was not taken out in time, and on the legislation in force on the date of the offence; the result may differ in cases where the manner of entry, the documents used and the conduct of the person concerned are different. The decision was taken by majority. Savun Law & Consultancy cannot be held responsible for applications, lawsuits and defences made on the basis of this article.

Questions & answers · Istanbul Bar Association 75235
Have a question about this topic? Ask our lawyer.
Write your question and Attorney Veli Savun will answer it on this page. You do not need to give your name.
Example questions — tap one and adapt it to your situation:
Answers are general information only; they do not create a lawyer–client relationship and are not legal advice on your specific case. All questions & answers →
This page is an English adaptation of our Turkish article Süresi Geçen Yabancı Plakalı Araç – Yargıtay CGK 2026/121.
More from Turkish Court Decisions
- Crypto Exchange Collapse: Suing the State, Council of State 2021
- Forex Case: Non-Prosecution Is Not Enough, Court of Cassation 2021/873
- IBAN–Name Mismatch: Bank Liability, İzmir Appeal Court 2026
- Bank Liable for Employee's High-Return Promise: Court of Cassation
- Inheritance Certificate Without Apostille: Court of Cassation 2026
- Bank System Error Credited a Card: İzmir Appeal Court Ruling